James Mwangi Ngatia & another v China Road & Bridge Corporation (Kenya) Limtied [2020] KEELC 2226 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Nairobi court ordered a quarry operator to pay a homeowner Kshs.4.3 million for blasting damage, ruling that licences do not permit destroying neighbours' property.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the defendant's blasting caused damage to the 1st plaintiff's properties
The court found the blasting and resulting vibrations and tremor caused damage to the 1st plaintiff's house; the defendant itself had assessed the damage at Kshs.1,163,850/-
The court held it was not in doubt that the defendant carried out blasting at the quarry and that the vibrations and tremor damaged the 1st plaintiff's house. The defendant confirmed receipt of the complaint, assessed the damage and produced a bill of quantities through DW2 as exhibit D6, conceding damage.
Quantum of damages for the 1st plaintiff's house repairs
The court found the plaintiff's figure of Kshs.7,104,645/- an exaggeration and awarded Kshs.4,000,000/- for repairs
The plaintiff's structural engineer put repairs at Kshs.7,104,645/- in 2015, but there was no evidence of the state of the building five years later. The court considered the figure exaggerated, compared the two bills of quantities, and awarded Kshs.4,000,000/- as reasonable cost of repairs, alternatively payable in damages.
General damages for nuisance and environmental pollution
The court agreed the blasting subjected the 1st plaintiff to excessive noise and vibration amounting to nuisance and awarded Kshs.300,000/-
The court accepted that the blasting subjected the 1st plaintiff to excessive noise and vibration causing annoyance and nuisance, and awarded general damages of Kshs.300,000/- as reasonable compensation for the noise and dust pollution.
Whether the 2nd plaintiff's claim should stand
The 2nd plaintiff's claim was dismissed for failure to verify the suit through a duly authorised officer and failure to prove the alleged loss of milk production
No certificate of incorporation was filed to show the 2nd plaintiff was a registered company, and no company resolution authorised the 1st plaintiff to plead for it, contravening Order 4 rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Rules. Even assuming proper joinder, the livestock report was general information, gave no scientific nexus between blasts and reduced milk production, and the production schedule was undated, unsigned and unsupported by audited accounts.
Legal principles established
#- A licence to carry out excavation works does not authorise destruction of neighbouring property or environmental degradation
- Where the plaintiff is a corporation, the verifying affidavit must be sworn by a duly authorised officer under the company seal; non-compliance is fatal
- A claimant must establish a scientific nexus between the alleged cause and loss of milk production, supported by proper records and audited accounts
Court orders
#- 1.A mandatory injunction directing the defendant to carry out repairs to the 1st plaintiff's house in line with the structural engineers M/S Sirga Ogonda & Associates and Quantity Surveyor's Report outlining the bill of quantity, now assessed at Kshs.4,000,000/-
- 2.In the alternative, the defendant to pay the plaintiff the sum of Kshs.4,000,000/- to cater for the repairs
- 3.General damages for nuisance and environmental pollution by way of noise and dust of Kshs.300,000/-
- 4.Costs of the suit and interest to the 1st plaintiff
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original civil jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court over the plaint dated 27th May 2015
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "James Mwangi Ngatia & another v China Road & Bridge Corporation (Kenya) Limtied [2020] KEELC 2226 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2020). . Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2020/2226/eng@2020-05-28
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.