Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedNot stated in judgment (ruling on notice of motion dated 4th July, 2019 by 3rd Defendant and notice of motion dated 27th September, 2020 by Plaintiff)· [2020] KEELC 1857 (KLR)

Green Square Limited v Sheladia Associates & 2 others [2020] KEELC 1857 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
30 June 2020
3,555 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~14 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan land court refused to remove a road contractor from a trespass lawsuit, ruling that old documents cannot be passed off as newly discovered evidence.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This Environment and Land Court ruling at Kericho determined two competing interlocutory applications in a trespass suit arising from the design and construction of the Mau Summit-Kericho-Nyamasaria road. The 3rd defendant, SBI International Holdings AG (Kenya), sought review of a ruling delivered on 27th June, 2017 which had dismissed its earlier application to be removed from the proceedings. It relied principally on alleged discovery of new evidence - a Conditional Notification of Award from KeNHA and its Unconditional Acceptance of Award - contending it held a separate contract and was neither a necessary nor proper party. The plaintiff, in turn, sought to set aside the leave granted for the review application or, alternatively, to strike it out, arguing the 3rd defendant was frustrating the hearing of the main suit. The court dismissed the plaintiff's application first, holding it was an afterthought filed about three months after leave was granted without protest, and was pre-emptive, pre-judging, presumptive and anticipatory - the proper course being to respond to the review application once filed. The court then dismissed the review application, finding the purported new evidence comprised 2009 documents that must have been in the 3rd defendant's possession when the earlier application was filed, and rejecting the 3rd defendant's credibility. The court further held the 3rd defendant a necessary party because the trespass complained of occurred during construction works it physically executed, and that a defendant later found not liable would simply be awarded costs. Both applications were dismissed with costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the 3rd defendant made out grounds for review of the ruling of 27 June 2017

Holding

No. The claimed discovery of new evidence was not genuinely new: the Conditional Notification of Award and Unconditional Acceptance of Award were 2009 documents which must have been in the 3rd defendant's possession when the earlier application was filed.

Reasoning

The court examined the annexures and found they were dated 26th and 28th October, 2009, not 2019 as the 3rd defendant asserted. One document was sent to the 3rd defendant by the Ministry of Lands and the other was sent by it, so both must have been in its possession. The court found it hard to believe the 3rd defendant and held that law based on misrepresented facts is an unhelpful tool.

p. 4
02

Whether the 3rd defendant should be removed as a party from the proceedings

Holding

No. The 3rd defendant is a necessary party because the trespass complained of arose from the construction works it physically carried out.

Reasoning

The court distinguished between the substance of the contracts and their implementation and execution. The plaintiff saw the 3rd defendant trespassing on its land during construction. Removing the 3rd defendant would make it impossible for the plaintiff to connect the act complained of with the construction. Defendants later found not liable are simply awarded costs.

p. 4
03

Whether the plaintiff's application to set aside the leave granting review or strike out the review application had merit

Holding

No. It was an afterthought, pre-emptive, pre-judging, presumptive and anticipatory, and was dismissed with costs.

Reasoning

Leave was granted on 19th June, 2019 with the plaintiff represented in court and no protest raised; three months later the plaintiff filed the application without explanation. The court held the correct course was to wait for the application to be filed and respond to it, rather than pre-judge an unseen application.

p. 4

Legal principles established

#
  • Where the presence of a party is necessary for the complete and effectual determination of a case, the court cannot allow removal of such party.
  • Documents already in a party's possession do not constitute new and important matter for review; and where facts are misrepresented, elegant legal submissions become unhelpful.
  • An application seeking to strike out a notice of motion before it is filed or seen is a wrong approach and should not be entertained.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The plaintiff's second application (notice of motion dated 27th September, 2019) is dismissed with costs
  2. 2.The 3rd defendant's first application for review (notice of motion dated 4th July, 2019) is dismissed with costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of KenyaArticle 159
  • Civil Procedure Act (Cap 21)Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 80
  • Civil Procedure Act (Cap 21)Sections 1A, 1B, 3, 3A and 63(e)
  • Civil Procedure Rules, 2010Order 45
  • Civil Procedure Rules, 2010Order 51 rule 1
  • Environment and Land Court Act, 2011Sections 14, 19(1), (2) and (3)(f)
  • Practice Direction No. 1Gazette Notice No. 5178 of 28th July, 2014

Cases cited (8)

  • Joseph Njenga Njoroge vs Kabiri Mbiti
    (1986) eKLR
  • Francis Origu & Another vs Jacob Kumali Mungala
    (2005) eKLR
  • Daniel Luwambi & 2 Others vs Penguin Holdings Limited
    (2017) eKLR
  • Pancras T. Swai vs Kenya Breweries Limited
    (2014) eKLR
  • Afpack Enterprises Limited vs Runita Jayant Acharya
    (2018) eKLR
  • Joseph Njau Kingori vs Robert Maina Chege & 3 Others
    (2002) eKLR
  • Cecilia Mudondo Wandera vs Matilda Wandera
    (2015) eKLR
  • Pithon Waweru vs Thuku Mugiria
    (1983) eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Article 159 of the Constitution of Kenya; Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 80 of the Civil Procedure Act (Cap 21); Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010; Sections 1A, 1B, 3, 3A and 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act; Order 51 rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010; Sections 14, 19(1), (2) and (3)(f) of the Environment and Land Court Act, 2011

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Green Square Limited v Sheladia Associates & 2 others [2020] KEELC 1857 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2020). Not stated in judgment (ruling on notice of motion dated 4th July, 2019 by 3rd Defendant and notice of motion dated 27th September, 2020 by Plaintiff). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2020/1857/eng@2020-06-30

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.