Shainaz Jamal & 8 others v Abdulrasul Manji & another [2020] KEELC 1417 (KLR)
The bottom line
#What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Validity of the county approval for the alterations
The alterations were legally implemented pursuant to the approval dated 22/11/2016; the repealed Physical Planning Act provided no mechanism for revocation, only appeal to the Liaison Committee under Section 33, which the plaintiffs never pursued.
At the time the impugned works were carried out a valid approval dated 22/11/2016 was in place. The letter of 3/3/2017 purporting to disapprove the plans came after completion, and the repealed Act contained no revocation framework. The statutory remedy of any aggrieved person was an appeal under Section 33, which the plaintiffs did not avail themselves of, so the court lacked a basis to declare the works illegal in this suit.
Effect of absence of lessor's written consent
The absence of the lessor's written consent did not render the alterations illegal because there was no subsisting lessor from whom consent could be obtained.
All villas had been sold and the developer-lessor was no longer on the ground, while the management company contemplated in Clause 3(v) of the lease had never been incorporated or operationalized. It was the collective duty of all lessees, including the plaintiffs, to operationalize the management company; they could not rely on their own default to invalidate the defendants' alterations.
Encroachment on or blockage of the common parking area
The alterations did not encroach or block the common parking area; the two impugned gates were pedestrian gates, one within the defendants' property, and any inconvenience was minimal.
The court conducted a site visit and examined the competing site plans. The plaintiffs' plan was not the registered site plan; the defendants' plan, upon which the lease titles were generated, showed Villa 14's land was larger and differently shaped. The gates were pedestrian gates. The closure of the original gate was justified by genuine safety need, and the inconvenience from the new pedestrian gate was minimal and did not constitute encroachment or blockage.
Legal principles established
#- Where a development is implemented under a valid subsisting approval, an aggrieved neighbour must challenge the approval through the statutory appeal mechanism (Section 33 of the repealed Physical Planning Act, appeal to the Liaison Committee) rather than institute a fresh civil suit; a court cannot subsequently declare such developments illegal in a collateral suit.
- Where the lease contemplates transfer of the reversionary interest to a management company to be incorporated by all lessees, and the lessees have failed to incorporate and operationalize that company, the absence of the lessor's written consent cannot render alterations by a co-lessee illegal.
- Interlocutory-injunction tests (prima facie case, irreparable injury, balance of convenience) are irrelevant at the stage of final determination of a suit.
Court orders
#- 1.The plaintiffs' suit is dismissed for lack of merit
- 2.Parties shall bear their respective costs of the suit
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original civil jurisdiction over a land dispute concerning land parcel LR Number 1870/III/140, Prestige Villas Estate, Westlands, Nairobi (no specific constitutional/statutory provision stated in the judgment)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Shainaz Jamal & 8 others v Abdulrasul Manji & another [2020] KEELC 1417 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2020). . Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2020/1417/eng@2020-07-27
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.