Edward Nyaoga Onsongo v Job Mekubo Mogusu [2019] KEELC 4767 (KLR)
The bottom line
#What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Locus standi and public nuisance under Section 61 of the Civil Procedure Act
The suit was not dismissed for non-compliance with Section 61; EMCA Section 3 and Articles 42, 69-70 of the Constitution confer standing on any person alleging environmental harm
The court held that Section 61's requirement (Attorney-General or consenting persons in public nuisance suits) is obliterated by Section 3 EMCA and constitutional provisions which open the corridors of justice to any person. Requiring compliance with an unamended statute would deny a citizen the constitutional right to be heard on environmental matters. The ground was dismissed as having no merit.
Whether the hole poses a danger
The court found the hole poses a danger to both parties, based on uncontradicted evidence of health risks
PW2, a Senior Public Health Officer, testified that occupants risked contracting pneumonia or rheumatism owing to the problem. The defendant adduced no evidence to the contrary. Despite this finding of danger, the court found the specific prayers before it defective or unavailable, and dismissed the suit.
Permanent injunction
The prayer was dismissed as defective since the hole was already dug
The court noted it had earlier flagged in the temporary injunction ruling that the hole was already dug, yet the plaintiff never amended his prayer. The court cannot assume what the plaintiff wished to state; pleadings bind the parties. An injunction against a completed act cannot issue.
Environmental restoration order
The court declined to issue a restoration order, holding NEMA alone is mandated to issue them under Section 108 of EMCA
A restoration order had already been issued by NEMA (PExh 6) but the defendant did not comply. The court held it has no role issuing a restoration order qua restoration order; the plaintiff ought to have sought enforcement of the existing order, which he did not. The order cannot be granted by this court.
Costs
Each party to bear own costs; both parties acted to safeguard themselves from the elements and public authorities bore responsibility for the dispute
The court found both neighbours acted in self-protection - the defendant dug the hole for storm water and the plaintiff built a wall blocking drainage. It faulted NEMA for failing to enforce its restoration order and the County Government planning department for failing to safeguard citizens from floods, holding that public laxity spawning private litigation should be discouraged.
Legal principles established
#- Section 3 of EMCA, backed by Articles 42, 69 and 70 of the Constitution, removes the requirement of locus standi in environmental disputes before the Environment and Land Court, displacing Section 61 of the Civil Procedure Act
- Restoration orders under the EMCA are the preserve of NEMA, not the Environment and Land Court
- A prayer to restrain an act already completed is defective in an adversarial system where pleadings define the relief
Court orders
#- 1.The plaintiff's suit is hereby dismissed
- 2.Each party shall bear his own costs of the suit
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Article 162(2) jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court; Section 3 of the Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act and Articles 42, 69 and 70 of the Constitution invoked
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Edward Nyaoga Onsongo v Job Mekubo Mogusu [2019] KEELC 4767 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Not stated in judgment (plaint dated 17th July, 2017). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/4767/eng@2019-02-04
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.