Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissed· [2019] KEELC 1712 (KLR)

Mugumoini Farmers Company Limited v Inshwil Builders & Engineers Limited [2019] KEELC 1712 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
23 September 2019
1,902 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~8 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court refused to throw out a land fraud suit, ruling that earlier dismissed cases don't block a fresh claim and procedural paperwork errors can be fixed.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Plaintiff, Mugumoini Farmers Company Limited, moved the Environment and Land Court at Murang'a by Notice of Motion filed on 17 August 2018 seeking a temporary injunction over suit lands Kakuzi/Kirimiri/Block 7/381, 382, 383, 250 and 445, a caveat on the suit lands, and cancellation of the titles with reversion to the Plaintiff. The Defendant, Erastus G Nduhiu, filed a Preliminary Objection dated 13 September 2018 contending that the suit was res judicata, offended Order 4 Rules 1(1)(f), 2 and 4 for non-disclosure of previous suits and lack of authority for the verifying affidavit, and was frivolous and an abuse of process. The court framed the key issue as whether the objection was a pure point of law. Examining ELC 1643 of 2007, HCCC No 1159 of 2005, CMCC No 68 of 2018 and HCCC No 3086 of 1994, it found none had determined the present fraud-based cause of action: two suits were dismissed for want of prosecution, one for want of jurisdiction, and the 1994 suit concerned debt recovery with the current Defendant not a party. The suit was therefore not res judicata. The verifying affidavit sworn by Joseph Kamande Ngone lacked authorization under the company seal as required by Order 4 Rule 2(4), but following Microsoft Corporation v Mitsumi Computer Garage Ltd and Jovenna East Africa Ltd, the court declined to strike out the suit, granting 30 days to file a compliant affidavit. Failure to plead previous suits did not go to the substance of the suit. The Preliminary Objection was dismissed with costs to the Plaintiff.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the suit is res judicata

Holding

The suit is not res judicata; none of the cited previous suits determined the issues of fraud and illegality in the transfer of the suit lands now raised

Reasoning

The court examined each previous suit against the res judicata elements. ELC 1643 of 2007 and HCCC No 1159 of 2005 were dismissed for want of prosecution and thus never heard on the merits. CMCC No 68 of 2018 was dismissed for want of jurisdiction. HCCC No 3086 of 1994 concerned recovery of a debt and execution, not fraud in the transfer, and the current Defendant was not party to it. ELC No 245 of 2017 was dismissed as there was no existing suit to revive. Since the fraud-based cause of action was never determined, res judicata is not established.

p. 2
02

Whether the verifying affidavit sworn without company authorization under seal warrants striking out the suit

Holding

The affidavit is non-compliant with Order 4 Rule 2(4) but the defect is not fatal; the Plaintiff is granted 30 days to file a compliant affidavit

Reasoning

Order 4 Rule 2(4) requires a corporation's verifying affidavit to be sworn by an officer duly authorized under the seal of the company. No such authorization was exhibited. However, following Microsoft Corporation v Mitsumi Computer Garage Ltd and Jovenna East Africa Ltd, courts have declined to strike out suits for this defect, instead granting liberty to file compliant affidavits. The court adopted the same approach, holding striking out would be drastic at the suit's infancy.

p. 2
03

Whether failure to disclose previous suits under Order 4 Rule 1(1)(f) is fatal

Holding

The omission does not go to the substance of the suit given the court's finding that the suit is not res judicata

Reasoning

Order 4 Rule 1(1)(f) is a precaution against res judicata and sub judice, requiring an averment that there are no pending or previous proceedings between the parties over the same subject matter. Although previous suits existed between the parties, the court held that in light of its finding that the suit is not res judicata, and taking the circumstances of the case, the failure to plead the previous suits does not go to the substance of the suit.

p. 3

Legal principles established

#
  • A suit is only res judicata where the matter in issue was heard and finally decided by a competent court between the same parties; dismissal for want of prosecution or for want of jurisdiction does not trigger the doctrine
  • A verifying affidavit sworn on behalf of a corporation without authority under the seal of the company is defective under Order 4 Rule 2(4), but the defect is curable and does not justify striking out the suit at its infancy
  • Failure to plead previous suits between the parties in the plaint under Order 4 Rule 1(1)(f) does not, where the suit is not res judicata, go to the substance of the suit

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Preliminary Objection is dismissed with costs to the Plaintiffs
  2. 2.The Plaintiff is directed to file and serve the appropriate compliant verifying affidavit within 30 days from the date of the Ruling
  3. 3.It is so ordered

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 4 Rule 1(1)(f)
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 4 Rule 2(4)
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 4 Rules 2 & 4

Cases cited (3)

  • Henderson v. Henderson
    (1843) 67 E.R. 313
  • Microsoft Corporation v. Mitsumi Computer Garage Ltd
    [2001] 2 EA 460
  • Jovenna East Africa Ltd. v. Sylvester Onyango & Others
    Milimani HCCC No. 1086 of 2002 (unreported)
Jurisdiction invoked
Original jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court over the suit lands (Kakuzi/Kirimiri Block 7); the ruling determines a Preliminary Objection in the first-instance suit

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Mugumoini Farmers Company Limited v Inshwil Builders & Engineers Limited [2019] KEELC 1712 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). . Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/1712/eng@2019-09-23

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.