Seventhday Adventist Church (E.A) Ltd (Nairobi East S.D.A. Church) v Strathmore Educational TrustRegistered Trustees & 2 others [2019] KEELC 1587 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Nairobi church lost its land claim because it relied on a verbal promise instead of a written contract, and was ordered to pay over Kshs.2.2 million.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the subdivision giving rise to the suit parcels was un-procedural and illegal
The subdivision was not un-procedural or illegal; the Commissioner of Lands granted provisional and final approvals and the plaintiff's own evidence showed a Part Development Plan had been submitted for approval.
The plaintiff relied on the Mburugu report stating the Commissioner of Lands held no PDP or approved survey plan on record. The court held absence of records did not mean none existed; a letter from the 2nd defendant showed a PDP had been submitted for approval, and the Commissioner's provisional and final approvals, deed plan and Survey Plan F/R 361/61 demonstrated due process. The seller owed the plaintiff no duty to consult during subdivision.
Whether the plaintiff was entitled to additional 3 acres from the 2nd defendant
No. The claim founded on an oral contract was unenforceable under section 3(3) of the Law of Contract Act, and equitable estoppel was not established; the plaintiff was at most a non-contractual licensee.
The plaintiff paid for and was entitled to only 1 acre (L.R No. 209/19706). The alleged oral sale and the conduct-based claim failed under section 3(3). There was no evidence of representations by the 2nd defendant relied on to the plaintiff's detriment, and no evidence that PW2, the acting estate manager, had authority to allocate or promise land. Occupation pending application merely created a revocable licence.
Whether the plaintiff trespassed on the 1st defendant's L.R No. 209/19707
Yes. The plaintiff demolished the 1st defendant's fence on 4th September 2009 and leased the land to a third party; only the first demolition was proved.
The additional 3 acres claimed by the plaintiff formed part of the 1st defendant's titled parcel. The 1st defendant was entitled to possession and to fence the land; PW1 admitted removing the fence to access the church. The July 2011 demolition occurred at night without credible evidence attributing it to the plaintiff. Leasing the land to a Chinese construction company was uncontested.
Whether the 1st defendant's counter-claim should succeed
Yes: eviction, permanent injunction, special damages of Kshs.72,940/= and general damages of Kshs.2,000,000/= for trespass and mesne profits.
The 1st defendant proved the plaintiff's occupation of its titled land, one proved fence demolition costing Kshs.72,940/= to restore, and leasing of the land to a third party. The court exercised discretion to award Kshs.2,000,000/= general damages and mesne profits taking all factors into account, plus interest.
Whether the plaintiff trespassed on the 3rd defendant's land
Yes; the 3rd defendant proved trespass and was awarded Kshs.250,000/= general damages.
The plaintiff's own witnesses disowned the claim against the 3rd defendant, and the plaintiff did not deny entering L.R No. 209/19704, interfering with her activities, stopping her from putting up a perimeter wall, and demolishing her wall. The plaintiff failed to show any claim over the 3rd defendant's parcels.
Legal principles established
#- An oral contract for the disposition of an interest in land is unenforceable under section 3(3) of the Law of Contract Act
- Equitable/proprietary estoppel requires proof of a representation, reliance on it, and change of circumstances
- Mere occupation of land pending consideration of an allocation application, even if authorised, creates at most a revocable non-contractual licence and confers no entitlement to allocation
- A seller carrying out a subdivision of its land is under no duty to consult a purchaser whose agreement was expressly subject to survey
Court orders
#- 1.The plaintiff's suit is dismissed as against all the defendants
- 2.Judgment entered for the 1st defendant against the plaintiff in terms of prayers (a) and (b) in the amended defence and counter-claim dated 11th November, 2016 (eviction and permanent injunction)
- 3.Judgment for the 1st defendant for special damages of Kshs.72,940/= being the cost of partial fencing of L.R No. 209/19707
- 4.Judgment for the 1st defendant for general damages of Kshs.2,000,000/= for trespass and mesne profits, with interest at court rates until payment in full
- 5.Judgment for the 3rd defendant against the plaintiff for Kshs.250,000/- general damages for trespass with interest at court rates until payment in full
- 6.The plaintiff shall pay the costs of the suit and the two counter-claims
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original civil jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court over a land dispute (claim and counter-claims for trespass, sub-division nullification and specific performance of a land sale)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Seventhday Adventist Church (E.A) Ltd (Nairobi East S.D.A. Church) v Strathmore Educational TrustRegistered Trustees & 2 others [2019] KEELC 1587 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Not stated in the judgment as provided. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/1587/eng@2019-09-30
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.