Arthur Kamau Kariuki v Chief Land Registrar & 5 others;Agricultural Development Corporation (Interested Party) [2019] KEELC 1516 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan court nullified parallel land titles because the Government allotted land it did not own, confirming the true owner's title.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Validity of the SFT/Government allocation and RLA titles over ADC land
The suit properties were never part of the land transferred to SFT; the allotments to Tuikong and Kipkoti were irregular and the resulting RLA titles are invalid and were nullified.
The mother title showed SFT acquired only 3,944 Ha being LR No. 20591/57. LR Nos. 20591/50 & 51 were carved out of LR No. 20591/11 and remained owned by ADC, which transferred them to the petitioner in 2012. The Government could not allocate land it did not own; only ADC could allot it, and ADC never did.
Reliability of the survey plan F/R No. 259/65 and the claim the scheme emanated from LR No. 19184/3
The argument that SFT acquired 4,033 Ha from LR No. 19184/3 has no basis; LR No. 19184/3 is owned by Mgetunye Limited and measures only 59.69 Ha, and the survey plan F/R No. 259/65 is unauthenticated.
The title to LR No. 19184/3 shows ownership by Mgetunye Limited measuring 59.69 Ha. The plan F/R No. 259/65 lacked authentication, approval, tracing and comparison entries. The acreage of 4,033.81 Ha does not match the 3,944 Ha SFT acquired, undermining the claimed provenance of the Settlement Scheme.
Limitation of actions defence
The limitation defence fails because the petitioner and ADC were unaware of the 5th respondent's titles; the earlier ruling also addressed the point under Section 26 of the Limitation of Actions Act.
There was no evidence the petitioner or ADC knew of the titles issued to the 5th respondent or his predecessors before the letters of 6 September 2012. Waithaka J had already dismissed the time-bar argument in her ruling of 3 October 2014, and the court declined to revisit that ruling.
Relevance of the pending criminal case against the Provincial Surveyor
The criminal case against Mr. Kirui does not affect the outcome; regardless of its result, SFT could not have title beyond LR No. 20591/57.
Mr. Kirui, the then Provincial Surveyor, was a beneficiary of at least four parcels and is charged with abuse of office. But the finding that the titles of Tuikong and Kipkoti did not emanate from LR No. 20591/57 stands independent of the trial's outcome, so the criminal proceedings do not assist the 5th and 6th respondents.
Legal principles established
#- The Government could not allot land still owned by ADC; only ADC, as registered proprietor, could allocate the suit parcels
- An entity cannot acquire good title beyond the land it actually purchased; parallel RLA titles over land retained under RTA titles are invalid
Court orders
#- 1.Declared that the titles Nakuru/Moi Ndabi Settlement Scheme/1267 and 1322 are invalid and nullified them
- 2.Directed the Chief Land Registrar and District Land Registrar to expunge the register of the titles Nakuru/Moi Ndabi Settlement Scheme/1267 and 1322
- 3.Declared that the valid title to the ground is LR No. 20591/50 and LR No. 20591/51 held by the petitioner
- 4.Directed the 5th and/or 6th respondents to give vacant possession within 30 days, failing which petitioner may apply for an eviction order
- 5.Petitioner awarded costs to be shouldered by the Attorney General on behalf of the State; no orders as to costs for or against the other parties
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original constitutional petition jurisdiction (petition filed under the Constitution); no specific article stated in the excerpt
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Arthur Kamau Kariuki v Chief Land Registrar & 5 others;Agricultural Development Corporation (Interested Party) [2019] KEELC 1516 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Constitutional Petition filed 13 August 2013 (Nakuru). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/1516/eng@2019-10-01
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.