Loise Nkatha Muthuri v Silas Kiogora Mburugu & another [2019] KEELC 1480 (KLR)
The bottom line
#What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the incoming advocates were properly on record under Order 9 Rule 9
The advocates were properly on record as they came on record by consent of the previous advocates, and no prejudice was demonstrated by the respondent
The court traced the two scenarios under Order 9 Rule 9: leave upon application with notice, or coming on record upon a consent filed between the outgoing and incoming advocates. Carl Peters Mbaabu & Co. filed a consent from the previous advocates together with a notice of change and the application on 4 March 2019. Following Buscar EA Ltd and Kazungu Ngari Yaa, the court held the consent proper, noting only that leave ought to have been sought orally, and that the respondent showed no prejudice.
Whether time should be extended to file a notice of appeal out of time
Extension of time was merited; the delay of about three months was explained by the applicant's ignorance of the judgment and the 30-day stay, the appeal was arguable on adverse possession, and no prejudice would be occasioned to the respondents
Applying the Leo Sila Mutiso criteria, the court found the delay of three months explained by the previous advocates' failure to inform the applicant of the judgment and the 30-day stay. The applicant had moved with speed, applying for certified copies of the judgment and proceedings and annexing a draft memorandum of appeal raising arguable adverse-possession issues. The judge declined to assess the prospects of the appeal against his own judgment but found no prejudice to the respondents and noted the applicant had not exhausted her right to be heard.
Whether an order maintaining the status quo over the suit premises should issue pending the intended appeal
Status quo as at the date of judgment was to be maintained, notwithstanding doubts about the applicant's candour on the nature of the structures
The court noted discrepancies between the applicant's testimony describing semi-permanent buildings and her affidavit claiming permanent and semi-permanent buildings, finding her 'not candid on this issue.' However, the defendants had admitted the plaintiff was on the land as a squatter and remained the registered owners. On that balance, the court found it necessary to preserve the status quo pending the appeal, subject to security and a one-year time limit.
Legal principles established
#- Where a new advocate comes on record after judgment by filing a consent under Order 9 Rule 9(b), the consent is effective even if leave of the court was not formally sought, provided no prejudice is occasioned to the other party
- The factors for extending time to appeal are the length of the delay, the reason for the delay, the chances of the appeal succeeding and the degree of prejudice to the respondent
- A first-instance judge cannot assess the chances of an appeal succeeding against his or her own judgment, as that would cast doubt on the judgment itself
Court orders
#- 1.Leave granted to the Plaintiff/Applicant to file her appeal within 7 days of 2nd October 2019
- 2.Pending the hearing and determination of the intended appeal in the Court of Appeal, an order maintaining and preserving the status quo obtaining in respect of Meru Municipality Block I/244 as at the time of delivery of judgment on 28th November 2018
- 3.The applicant to deposit Ksh. 200,000 as security in court within 30 days
- 4.The orders granted to remain in force for a period of ONE YEAR ONLY
- 5.If there is non-compliance with orders (a) and (c), the orders granted shall lapse
- 6.The applicant to bear the costs of the application
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Inherent discretion of the Environment and Land Court and Order 9 Rule 9 and Order 42 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2010 (extension of time and status quo pending intended appeal to the Court of Appeal at Nyeri)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Loise Nkatha Muthuri v Silas Kiogora Mburugu & another [2019] KEELC 1480 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Application dated 4th March 2019 (Meru ELC; suit number not stated in the ruling). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/1480/eng@2019-10-02
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.