John Maina Kihara & 33 others v James Heho Wanjohi & 9 others [2019] KEELC 1311 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan court confirmed that citing the wrong law in an application doesn't sink it, but a magistrate cannot rule on arguments that were never heard.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Definition and proper scope of a Preliminary Objection
The court adopted the Mukisa Biscuits definition, holding that a Preliminary Objection must be on a pure point of law.
The court restated the classic Mukisa Biscuits formulation: a Preliminary Objection raises a pure point of law on the assumption that all facts pleaded by the other side are correct, and cannot be raised where facts must be ascertained or judicial discretion exercised. It applied this standard in assessing the Appellant's objection that the Respondent's application was incompetent for citing wrong provisions.
Effect of invoking wrong provisions of law on an application
Wrong invocation of legal provisions does not defeat an otherwise meritorious application, absent bad faith or prejudice.
Following Nancy Nyamira & Another v Archer Dramond Morgan Ltd (which itself followed Gitari v Muriuki), the court held that an application will not be dismissed solely because it cites a wrong provision, so long as the invocation is not in bad faith or calculated to mislead or prejudice the other side. On this basis the dismissal of the Preliminary Objection was upheld.
Whether the magistrate could allow the main application without directions
The magistrate misdirected himself in allowing the Notice of Motion dated 6th February 2006 when only the Preliminary Objection had been heard and no directions taken on the main application.
The court found that what came up for hearing on 9th March 2006 was the Preliminary Objection, not the main application. In allowing the main application without the parties having taken directions on how to canvass it, the magistrate decided matters not properly before him for determination, warranting setting aside that order and remitting the matter for hearing de novo before another magistrate.
Legal principles established
#- A Preliminary Objection must raise a pure point of law argued on the assumption that all facts pleaded by the other side are correct.
- Invoking the wrong provisions of law does not necessarily doom an otherwise meritorious application.
Court orders
#- 1.The appeal partially succeeds in that the order dismissing the Preliminary Objection is upheld
- 2.The order allowing the Notice of Motion dated 6th February 2006 is set aside and the matter is referred to Wanguru Law Courts for hearing before a magistrate other than Kimutai K.T.
- 3.The Appellant shall bear the costs of this appeal
- On appeal from
- Senior Resident Magistrate's Court (Wanguru)
- S.R.M.C.C No. 31 of 2005
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appeal from the magistrates' court to the Environment and Land Court
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Later judgments citing this (18)
#Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.
- Rugumi v Republic (Criminal Appeal 103 of 2020) [2026] KECA 197 (KLR)[2026] KECA 197 (KLR)30 Jan 2026
- Kivisha v Republic (Criminal Appeal 209 of 2018) [2024] KECA 1118 (KLR)[2024] KECA 1118 (KLR)30 Aug 2024
- Kiplangat v Republic (Criminal Appeal 362 of 2019) [2024] KECA 702 (KLR)[2024] KECA 702 (KLR)21 Jun 2024
- CLK v Republic (Criminal Appeal 103 of 2023) [2024] KECA 536 (KLR)[2024] KECA 536 (KLR)9 May 2024followed
- Odiyo v Republic (Criminal Appeal 72 of 2021) [2023] KECA 669 (KLR)[2023] KECA 669 (KLR)9 Jun 2023followed
- Kinyaga v Republic (Criminal Appeal 10 of 2016) [2021] KECA 220 (KLR)[2021] KECA 220 (KLR)3 Dec 2021applied
- Simon Njoroge Waithira v Republic [2020] KECA 735 (KLR)[2020] KECA 735 (KLR)24 Apr 2020applied
- Alex Lichua Lichodo v Republic [2015] KECA 445 (KLR)[2015] KECA 445 (KLR)31 Jul 2015followed
- John Njara Maina v Republic [2014] KECA 166 (KLR)[2014] KECA 166 (KLR)17 Dec 2014applied
- Simon Mutuku Musyoka v Republic [2014] KECA 167 (KLR)[2014] KECA 167 (KLR)16 Dec 2014followed
- Daniel Bundi Njuki v Republic [2014] KECA 197 (KLR)[2014] KECA 197 (KLR)16 Dec 2014applied
- J.W.A v Republic [2014] KECA 484 (KLR)[2014] KECA 484 (KLR)4 Jul 2014followed
- Peter Wachiuri Gichira v Republic [2014] KECA 659 (KLR)[2014] KECA 659 (KLR)31 Mar 2014applied
- Agm v Republic [2014] KECA 731 (KLR)[2014] KECA 731 (KLR)5 Feb 2014applied
- Jeremiah Muthengi Mathinyo V Republic [2013] KECA 87 (KLR)[2013] KECA 87 (KLR)10 Dec 2013applied
- Boniface Mugendi Kinyua v Republic (Criminal Appeal 468 of 2010) [2013] KECA 108 (KLR)[2013] KECA 108 (KLR)28 Nov 2013applied
- Joseph Gichuki Gitonga alias Smoky Joe v Republic [2013] KECA 506 (KLR)[2013] KECA 506 (KLR)20 Jun 2013applied
- George Kimathi Michubu & another v Republic [2013] KECA 315 (KLR)[2013] KECA 315 (KLR)29 May 2013applied
Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "John Maina Kihara & 33 others v James Heho Wanjohi & 9 others [2019] KEELC 1311 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). S.R.M.C.C No. 31 of 2005 (Appeal). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/1311/eng@2019-10-04
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.