Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCOtherChuka ELC Case No. 16 of 2019· [2019] KEELC 602 (KLR)

Chuka Igamba Ng’ombe Development Association v County Government of Tharaka Nithi [2019] KEELC 602 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
26 November 2019
5,999 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~24 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court allowed a community association to sue the county government over a monument, dismissed a technicality-based challenge, and referred the parties to arbitration.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This Environment and Land Court ruling at Chuka arises from a suit filed on 23rd July 2019 by the Chuka Igamba Ng'ombe Development Association against the County Government of Tharaka Nithi over interference with the Centenary Celebrations Monument at Chuka town. The court had earlier granted interim injunctive relief in terms of prayer 2 of the plaintiff's Notice of Motion under Section 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act. The defendant filed a preliminary objection contending that the plaintiff, an unincorporated association, lacked locus standi and that those authorising the pleadings lacked capacity. The court, applying the Mukisa Manufacturing test, dismissed the objection, holding that the grounds invited argument and fact-finding rather than raising pure points of law, and that the identified members' failure to cite themselves directly was a procedural technicality curable under Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution. The court referred the parties to arbitration before the County Commissioner, Tharaka Nithi, under Section 20 of the Environment and Land Court Act, extended the interim orders, and gave compliance directions. After the arbitration talks failed, the judge disclosed subtle attempts by interested persons to discuss the case with him. Though these did not meet the recusal threshold and the judge expressly did not recuse himself, he held that perception matters, and directed that the suit be transferred to and heard by Lady Justice Lucy Mbugua at the ELC Meru, with existing interim orders remaining valid unless varied by that court and directions set for 10th December 2019. No costs order was made.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the plaintiff association has locus standi to institute the suit

Holding

The preliminary objection on capacity was dismissed; the identified members gave authority to Gitari Kea to plead on behalf of the association and their failure to directly cite themselves was a curable procedural technicality under Article 159(2)(d).

Reasoning

The court found that three members of the plaintiff association, Isaac Mugo, Justin Kinyua Kathuru and Samuel Mutegi, gave authority to Gitari Kea to plead on their behalf. Unlike the authorities proffered by the defendant, these are real persons who do not hide behind a nebulous association and can be condemned to pay costs. Their only infraction was not directly citing themselves in the plaint, curable under Article 159(2)(d). Article 22 of the Constitution also expands capacity to institute suits.

p. 8
02

Whether the preliminary objection raised pure points of law

Holding

The objection failed the Mukisa Biscuits test because its grounds invited argument and fact-finding rather than raising pure points of law.

Reasoning

Applying the Mukisa Manufacturing formulation, the court found the grounds in the preliminary objection nebulous and argumentative. The plaintiff's capacity under Article 22 was contested and required ascertainment of facts, and the ownership of the annexures also invited factual enquiry. Such matters could only be satisfactorily canvassed at the full hearing of the suit, so the objection was dismissed.

p. 8
03

Whether the judge should continue hearing the case given attempted extraneous contacts

Holding

Although the attempts did not meet the threshold for recusal and the judge did not recuse himself, he directed that the matter be heard by another judge to preserve the perception of judicial integrity.

Reasoning

The court noted subtle attempts to have the judge discuss the case with interested persons. Citing the Bangalore Principles on independence, integrity and propriety, the judge held that perception may be more significant than reality. Since justice must not merely be done but be seen to be done, he directed reassignment of the suit to Lady Justice Lucy Mbugua at Meru, while clarifying he had not recused himself.

p. 9
04

Whether the dispute should be referred to alternative dispute resolution

Holding

Under Section 20 of the Environment and Land Court Act, the court directed the parties to arbitration chaired by the County Commissioner, Tharaka Nithi County, within 14 days.

Reasoning

The court observed commonality in the parties' positions: neither opposed a monument; their only difference was whether the old monument should remain or be replaced, and no dispute existed over its location. Since public funds were an issue, the court invoked Section 20 of the Environment and Land Court Act to direct ADR before a report back to court.

p. 8

Legal principles established

#
  • A preliminary objection must raise a pure point of law and cannot be raised where facts have to be ascertained or judicial discretion exercised.
  • Article 22 of the Constitution expands the capacity of associations and citizens to institute proceedings, including in the interest of groups or in the public interest.
  • Procedural infractions such as failure to directly cite the individuals representing an association are curable under Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution.
  • Where attempts to influence a judge, though rebuffed and insufficient to warrant recusal, raise perceptions of impropriety, the judge may direct that the matter be heard by another judge so that justice is seen to be done.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Preliminary Objection dated 29th July 2019 was dismissed
  2. 2.The parties were directed to subject themselves to an arbitration process chaired by the County Commissioner, Tharaka Nithi County, or his/her appointed representative within 14 days, with a report to be filed in court
  3. 3.The plaintiff was ordered to fully comply with Order 11, CPR within 14 days
  4. 4.The defendant was ordered to fully comply with Order 11, CPR by 19th November 2019
  5. 5.Extant interim orders were extended in terms of Section 63, CPA, pending hearing of any interlocutory applications
  6. 6.This suit will be heard and determined by the Hon. Lady Justice Lucy Mbugua at the Environment and Land Court, Meru
  7. 7.Any interim orders issued in this case shall remain valid unless vacated or otherwise varied by the Environment and Land Court at Meru
  8. 8.The order that the suit be heard on 3rd and 4th December 2019 by this court was vacated
  9. 9.Parties to appear for directions before Hon. Lady Justice Lucy Mbugua in the ELC Court at Meru on 10th December 2019

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 40 Rules 1 and 4(1)
  • Civil Procedure Act, Cap. 21Sections 3A and 63(c)/(e)
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 22(1), 22(2)(a)-(d), 23, 40, 159(2)(a), (b), (d) and (e)
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 1 rule 1; Order 11
  • Societies Act
  • Environment and Land Court ActSection 20

Cases cited (10)

  • Housing Finance Co of Kenya Ltd v Embakasi Youth Development
    (2004) 2 KLR 548
  • Simu Vendors Association v The Town Clerk City Council of Nairobi & Another
    (2005) eKLR
  • Living Waters Church International v City Council of Nairobi
  • Baskins v United Mine Workers
    (1921) 150 ARK. 398, 234 s.w 464
  • Seely v Schenck & Denise quoted with Richardson v Smith
    (1885) 21 FLA 336, 341
  • Africa Orthodox Church of Kenya v Rev. Charles Omuroka & Lagos Ministry for Orthodox Renewal
    Civil Case No. 299 of 2013
  • Kipsiwo Community Self Help Group v The Hon Attorney General and 6 others
    E&L Petition 9 of 2013 (formerly HCC Pet 10/2013)
  • Kiserian Isinya Pipeline Road Resident Association (KIPRRA) & 6 Others v Jamii Bora Charitable Trust and Jamii Bora Charitable Trust Registered Trustees
  • Mukisa Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors
    (1969) E.A. 696
  • Celina Wambui v Urithi Housing Cooperative Society Limited
Jurisdiction invoked
Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010; Section 20 of the Environment and Land Court Act; Sections 3A and 63 of the Civil Procedure Act

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Chuka Igamba Ng’ombe Development Association v County Government of Tharaka Nithi [2019] KEELC 602 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Chuka ELC Case No. 16 of 2019. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/602/eng@2019-11-26

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.