Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissed· [2019] KEELC 195 (KLR)

Josephine Jebitok Choge, Deborah Jeruto, Silas Kipkosgei Sirtui & Susan Jemutai Sirtui v Samwel Choge & Elizabeth Jeruto (Environment & Land Case 82 of 2019) [2019] KEELC 195 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
10 December 2019
3,145 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~13 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

The court refused to strike out a land dispute, confirming that preliminary objections cannot be used to resolve disputed facts—such suits must proceed to full hearing.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This ruling of the Environment and Land Court at Eldoret (M. A. Odeny, J) determined a notice of preliminary objection dated 28th June 2019 by the defendants, seeking to strike out the plaintiffs' application dated 12th June 2019 and the entire suit concerning portions of land known as Sergoit/Karuna Block (Chepkoilel), which the plaintiffs alleged was being interfered with. The defendants raised seven grounds: lack of locus standi, the applicants being a daughter-in-law and wife of the 1st defendant, the subject property being under intestate succession, contravention of sections 6(1) and (2) of the Matrimonial Property Act, want of jurisdiction, sub judice in light of Eldoret CMCC No. 101 of 2018 and Eldoret HCC (OS) No. 84 of 2018, and material non-disclosure. The defendants argued the suit properties belong to the estate of the late Simon Sirtui Choge and that no grant ad litem had been annexed, relying on Hawo Shanko and related authorities that a suit filed without a limited grant is void ab initio. The plaintiffs countered that a grant ad litem was issued on 22nd March 2019, that disputed factual questions fell outside the Mukisa Biscuits threshold, and that the prior suits involved different parties. The court applied Lemitei Ole Koros and Muhu Holdings, holding that a preliminary objection must be a pure point of law on undisputed facts and that striking out a suit is a draconian measure. Finding the objection raised contested factual issues, the court dismissed the preliminary objection with costs to the plaintiff, allowing the suit to proceed.

Key legal issues

#
01

Threshold for a preliminary objection

Holding

The preliminary objection failed because it invited the court to determine disputed factual questions, including whether a grant ad litem existed and whether the suit property is matrimonial property

Reasoning

The court restated the Mukisa Biscuits threshold, citing Munyao J's formulation that contested facts automatically fall outside the ambit of a preliminary objection. The defendants' grounds required evidence — for instance, the grant ad litem allegedly not annexed, and whether the property is matrimonial property are matters requiring proof. Following Muhu Holdings, evidence cannot be introduced later to prop up a preliminary objection, and sub judice allegations also require evidence.

p. 4
02

Locus standi and the grant ad litem

Holding

The objection on locus standi could not succeed at the preliminary stage since the plaintiffs asserted they had obtained a grant ad litem issued on 22nd March 2019 in Ad Litem Application No. 54 of 2019, a fact requiring evidence to resolve

Reasoning

Defendants argued the plaintiffs admitted the suit properties belong to the estate of the late Simon Sirtui Choge and that no grant ad litem was annexed, relying on Hawo Shanko for the rule that a suit filed without a limited grant is void ab initio. Plaintiffs countered that a grant ad litem was in fact issued on 22nd March 2019 and forms part of the record. This factual dispute could not be resolved on a preliminary objection.

p. 3
03

Jurisdiction and succession law

Holding

The jurisdictional objection based on the Law of Succession Act was entangled with disputed facts and could not be determined preliminarily

Reasoning

Defendants submitted that the suit properties, registered in the name of the deceased, fall under intestate succession governed by section 2(1) of the Law of Succession Act, so only the High Family Court or Magistrates Court could determine entitlement until a Certificate of Confirmation of Grant issued. Plaintiffs relied on Re Estate of Kabuthi Kithitu, that whether property is matrimonial property requires proof by evidence, beyond the purview of a preliminary objection.

p. 3
04

Sub judice

Holding

The suit was not sub judice because the prior suits cited involve different parties, and the claim required evidence to adjudicate

Reasoning

Plaintiffs submitted that Eldoret CMC No. 101 of 2018 is a judicial separation matter between only one plaintiff and the 1st defendant, while Eldoret HCC (OS) No. 84 of 2018 similarly does not involve all four plaintiffs and the 2nd defendant, so the same matter is not directly and substantially in issue between the same parties under section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act. The court followed Muhu Holdings, where determining sub judice would require evidence such as pleadings and proceedings.

p. 4

Legal principles established

#
  • A preliminary objection must be a pure point of law on undisputed facts; where facts are contested, evidence must be adduced and the objection fails
  • Striking out a suit is a draconian remedy reserved for clear cases

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The preliminary objection dated 28th June 2019 is dismissed
  2. 2.Costs of the preliminary objection are awarded to the plaintiff

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Matrimonial Property Actsections 6(1) and 6(2)
  • Law of Succession Actsections 2(1), 29, 54 and 67
  • Civil Procedure Actsection 6

Cases cited (10)

  • Hawo Shanko vs Mohamed Uta Shanko
    (2018)
  • In the Matter of the Estate of Moraii Bhanii Dhanak
    Nairobi Succession Cause No. 1731 of 2000
  • Julian Adoyo Ongunga & Another vs Francis Kiberenge Bondeva (Suing as the Administrator of the Estate of Fanuel Evans Amudavi (Deceased)
    eKLR
  • PLR vs JNR & Another
    (2013) eKLR
  • In Re Estate of the late Chemweno Chebor Kibolot (Deceased)
    Eldoret HCC No. 81 of 1992
  • Re Estate of Kabuthi Kithitu (Deceased)
    Miscellaneous Probate Administration Application 87 of 2013
  • Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Co. Ltd vs West End Distributors Ltd
    (1969) EA 696
  • Republic vs Attorney General sued for and on behalf of the Ministry of Lands & 2 others Ex parte South and Central Thika Investments Limited & another
    (2016) eKLR
  • Lemitei Ole Koros & another v Attorney General & 3 others
    (2016) eKLR
  • Muhu Holdings Limited v James Muhu Kangari
    (2017) eKLR, Environment and Land Court at Nakuru Case No. 112 of 2017
Jurisdiction invoked
Original jurisdiction under the Environment and Land Court Act over land known as Sergoit/Karuna Block (Chepkoilel) 166 & 138

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Josephine Jebitok Choge, Deborah Jeruto, Silas Kipkosgei Sirtui & Susan Jemutai Sirtui v Samwel Choge & Elizabeth Jeruto (Environment & Land Case 82 of 2019) [2019] KEELC 195 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). . Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/195/eng@2019-12-10

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.