Santaben Ramniklal Parmar & another v Beatrice Waruguru Gituru & 2 others [2019] KEELC 145 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A company that bought a disputed Nairobi property during ongoing court proceedings must pay the outstanding Kshs 2.9 million balance within 90 days or lose its title.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Capacity of the suit property for partition
The property cannot be partitioned; there was a consensus that the tenancy be determined by sale and no evidence of the property's condition supporting partition
No evidence was tendered on the nature and condition of the 0.0348-hectare leasehold property. The parties had agreed to sell the property to the 2nd defendant, implying consensus that it could not be partitioned. Leasehold tenure may also require consent to partition. In the absence of contrary evidence, the court found partition impossible.
Mode of determining the tenancy in common
Sale of the whole property was the best option for determining the tenancy in common
A tenancy in common can be determined by partition, sale of the whole property, or sale of shares among co-owners. The parties had agreed to sell the property to the 2nd defendant, and no other options had been considered, so sale was held to be the best available option.
Whether the 1st defendant unreasonably refused the sale to Michael Mbira
Her refusal was not unreasonable given the disputed status of the earlier agreement with the 2nd defendant and payments she had received
The 2nd defendant paid only a deposit and did not prove payment of the full purchase price, so the owners were at liberty to rescind and sell elsewhere. However, the 1st defendant had received payments from the 2nd defendant and wanted the first agreement resolved first; her refusal was therefore not unreasonable.
Validity of the transfer to the 2nd and 3rd defendants
The transfers could not be declared irregular or illegal because the 2nd defendant held under Mombasa court orders not shown to have been set aside, but the 2nd defendant was held liable for the unpaid balance of the purchase price
The court could not assess the genuineness of the Mombasa orders because the files disappeared. The 2nd and 3rd defendants gave no evidence; no proof of full payment or of consideration moving from the 3rd to the 2nd defendant. The 3rd defendant took subject to lis pendens. Equity required the 2nd defendant to account for the unpaid Kshs. 2,900,000/= balance.
Cancellation of the transfers
No immediate basis for cancellation; cancellation only in default of payment of the balance within 90 days
Since the 2nd defendant's interest derived from court orders not set aside, the transfers could not be cancelled outright, but the court would not allow the defendants to keep the property without paying the balance of Kshs. 2,900,000/=; hence a conditional cancellation order.
Which pleading governs the trial
The suit proceeds on the amended Originating Summons of 29th November, 2010, per Mutungi J.'s unvaried direction
Although the 2nd plaintiff twice disowned the amended Originating Summons, Mutungi J. had ordered that the hearing proceed on the amended pleading, and that order was never varied or set aside; a party's disavowal could not overturn it.
Legal principles established
#- A tenancy in common may be determined through partition, sale of the whole property, or sale of shares among co-owners
- Where co-owners agree to determine a tenancy in common by sale of the whole property, that consensus, absent contrary evidence, precludes partition
- A transferee of suit property during the pendency of a suit takes subject to the outcome of those proceedings under the doctrine of lis pendens
- A purchaser who has not proved payment of the full purchase price remains liable for the balance notwithstanding that transfer was effected pursuant to court orders
Court orders
#- 1.The 2nd defendant shall pay to the plaintiffs Kshs. 2,900,000/= being the balance of the purchase price for L.R No. 209/2489/21 within 90 days with interest at court rates from the date of judgment until payment in full
- 2.In default of payment within the prescribed period, the transfer of the suit property to the 2nd defendant registered on 21st June, 2005 and the subsequent transfer to the 3rd defendant registered on 27th July, 2006 shall be cancelled and the property reverted to the names of the plaintiffs and the 1st defendant
- 3.If the transfers are cancelled, the plaintiffs and the 1st defendant shall sell the suit property after valuation and refund to the 2nd defendant Kshs. 1,400,000/= which amount shall be deducted from the share of the 1st defendant
- 4.Each party shall bear its own costs of the suit
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Not stated in the judgment; suit brought by Originating Summons under civil procedure (Order 37 procedure implied) and heard by the Environment and Land Court
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Later judgments citing this (1)
#Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.
Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Santaben Ramniklal Parmar & another v Beatrice Waruguru Gituru & 2 others [2019] KEELC 145 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Not stated in the judgment provided. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/145/eng@2019-12-05
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.