Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedNot stated in the judgment as supplied· [2019] KEELC 107 (KLR)

Esther Mwaura Kibe v Patrick Wamula t/a Patros Agencies Ltd & another [2019] KEELC 107 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court of Kenya (first-instance civil suit)
17 December 2019
3,235 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~13 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court dismissed a tenant's multi-million shilling claim because earlier settlement consents were binding and her claimed losses lacked documentary proof.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Plaintiff, a tenant of shop No. A2 on L.R. No. 209/138/4, River Road, Nairobi, sued the 1st Defendant (auctioneer) and the 2nd Defendant (her landlord) over distress for rent levied on 29th November 2008, in which her shop merchandise was carted away. She sought an injunction, return of the goods, special damages of Kshs. 15,000,000 for goods lost or damaged and loss of business, general damages of Kshs. 10,000,000 for closure of the business, general damages and costs. The 2nd Defendant denied the claim, asserting the goods were returned on 31st July 2009, that he paid Kshs. 1.2 million under a judgment of 28th July 2009 (with Kshs. 400,000 in costs), purged contempt by paying Kshs. 300,000, and that consents of 14th July 2010 and 7th February 2012 confirmed full settlement. Two issues were framed: whether the 2009 order and the 2010 and 2012 consents extinguished the entire claim, and whether the Plaintiff was entitled to general and special damages. Relying on authority that consent orders bind parties with contractual effect, the court held the consents, never set aside, settled the whole dispute and that the 28th July 2009 order was a final judgment compensating the Plaintiff. On damages, the court found the special damages specifically pleaded but not proved - the valuer relied only on the Plaintiff's instructions - and general damages unavailable because she had been compensated. The court found the ten-year-later amendment amounted to unjust enrichment, dismissed the suit and ordered each party to bear its own costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the court order of 28th July 2009 and the consents of 14th July 2010 and 7th February 2012 compromised the entire suit

Holding

Yes - the order and consents settled the whole dispute; the order of 28th July 2009 was a final judgment, not an interlocutory one, and the consents were never set aside

Reasoning

The court examined the order of 28th July 2009, which entered Kshs. 1.2 million as judgment in the Plaintiff's favour and directed release of the goods, and the two consents confirming payment, purge of contempt and release of deposits. The court reasoned that consents compromise disputes and take effect as judgments, binding until set aside on grounds such as fraud. It found no indication in the consents that the Plaintiff retained any further claim against the 2nd Defendant.

p. 3
02

Whether the Plaintiff proved her claim for special damages of Kshs. 15,000,000 for goods lost or damaged

Holding

No - special damages were specifically pleaded but not proved with credible documentary evidence

Reasoning

The Plaintiff relied on a valuation report whose author admitted he never inspected the goods and relied on the Plaintiff's instructions and the Auctioneer's Proclamation. She failed to prove that the Balozi loan was used for the business, produced no tax returns, and admitted varying daily sales that were not banked daily. The court held she threw abstract figures to the court and, being herself in breach of the tenancy by subletting and in rent arrears, could not sustain the claim.

p. 4
03

Whether the Plaintiff was entitled to general damages for loss of business and closure

Holding

No - the order of 28th July 2009 was a final judgment compensating her for the damages caused by the distress

Reasoning

The court noted the Plaintiff's counsel stated in court on 28th July 2009 that she was ready to accept Kshs. 1.2 million in exchange for the lease plus Kshs. 400,000 in costs, and that the goods be released unconditionally. The court held this demonstrated final compensation. Amending the Plaint in 2018, ten years later, to add general and special damages when the matter was settled amounted to unjust enrichment.

p. 4
04

Whether the 2nd Defendant's distress was lawful

Holding

The court accepted the distress was illegal in manner (confiscating goods), but the Plaintiff was herself in breach of the tenancy through subletting and rent arrears

Reasoning

The court observed it was undisputed that the 2nd Defendant levied an illegal distress and later released the goods on 31st July 2009. However, the Plaintiff was in breach of the tenancy agreement by subletting, which caused rescission, and was in rent arrears. These findings did not avail her damages because the claim had been compromised and damages were unproved.

p. 4

Legal principles established

#
  • A consent order binds both parties, takes effect as a consent judgment with contractual effect, and can only be set aside on grounds which would justify setting aside a contract, such as fraud, concealment of material facts or non-fulfilment of conditions
  • Consents entered into by parties to compromise a dispute render the matter settled and stop litigation, taking effect as a judgment resulting from a court's decision
  • Special damages must not only be specifically pleaded but also strictly proved with credible documentary evidence; a claimant cannot merely state a loss and throw the figure to the court
  • The burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on the person who wishes the court to believe in its existence (Section 109, Evidence Act)

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Plaintiff's suit as per the Amended Plaint dated 23rd May 2018 is dismissed for failure to prove her case on a balance of probability
  2. 2.Each party to bear its own costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Evidence ActSection 109

Cases cited (3)

  • Edward Acholla vs. Sogea Satom Kenya Branch and 2 others
    (2014) eKLR
  • Samuel Mbugua vs. Barclays Bank of Kenya
    (2015) eKLR
  • Farah Awad Gullet v CMC Motors Group Limited
    [2018] eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Original civil jurisdiction over the claim pleaded in the amended Plaint dated 23rd May 2018 (no specific constitutional/statutory provision cited in the judgment as supplied)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Esther Mwaura Kibe v Patrick Wamula t/a Patros Agencies Ltd & another [2019] KEELC 107 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Not stated in the judgment as supplied. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/107/eng@2019-12-17

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.