Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedCivil Appeal No 52 of 2018· [2019] KEELC 24 (KLR)

Constatine Martin Kithinji Gitobu v Harriet Nkuene Kirimania & 9 others [2019] KEELC 24 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
10 December 2019
2,343 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~9 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court upheld a family's claim that a plot was held in trust for them, because the buyer could not prove he actually paid for the land.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is a first appeal to the Environment and Land Court at Meru (Mbugua, ELC J) against the judgment of Hon. J. M. Irura, Senior Resident Magistrate, delivered on 31/10/2018 in Nkubu Principal Magistrate's Court Civil Suit No. 134 of 2014. The dispute is between family members over built-up Plot No. 11A Kithirune Market, registered in the name of the 2nd defendant M'Kirimania M'Ikiugu (father and husband of the plaintiffs). The plaintiffs sued for a permanent injunction and a declaration that the 2nd defendant held the plot in trust for the family, asserting they had collectively purchased it and built on it. The 1st defendant (the appellant), a cousin, counterclaimed, alleging he had bought the plot from the 2nd defendant for Kshs. 900,000 on 28/6/2012. The trial court found a constructive trust in favour of the plaintiffs, granted a permanent injunction against the appellant and dismissed his counterclaim. On appeal, the eleven grounds were collapsed into three: error in finding a trust, error in invalidating the sale agreement, and bias. The court, guided by Selle vs Associated Motor Boat Company Ltd, re-evaluated the evidence. It held that the trust claim was pleaded and proved by uncontroverted evidence of family contributions, construction and payment of rates; that the sale agreement failed the requirements of section 3 of the Law of Contract Act with no proof of payment of the purchase price and no acknowledgement receipt, the 2nd defendant's unproven pleadings having no evidential value; and that the bias claim was unfounded as it was never raised at trial. The appeal was dismissed with costs to the respondents on 10th December 2019 at Meru.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether a constructive trust was established between the plaintiffs and the 2nd defendant over Plot No. 11A Kithirune Market.

Holding

Yes. The plaintiffs contributed money, bought the plot, built a permanent building and paid rates; the appellant never challenged that evidence. The trial magistrate correctly found a constructive trust and correctly restated the requirements for constructive trust from Halsbury's Laws of England.

Reasoning

PW1 gave minute details of how the family combined efforts to purchase the plot and registered it in the father's name in trust. The averment that the plaintiffs assisted in the purchase was never disputed by the 2nd defendant, who did not testify. The claim of trust was pleaded in paragraphs 10 and 15 of the amended plaint, so the doctrine was properly before the court. The appellant had even admitted on cross-examination that PW1 occupied the plot and was not a tenant.

p. 3
02

Whether the agreement of sale between the appellant and the 2nd defendant was valid and enforceable.

Holding

No. There was no sufficient proof of purchase; the sale agreement did not meet the criteria set out in section 3 of the Law of Contract Act, no document captured payment of the Kshs. 900,000 purchase price, and there was no acknowledgement receipt. The 2nd defendant's unproven pleadings had no evidential value.

Reasoning

The 2nd defendant did not testify in the lower court, so his pleadings were mere averments, not evidence. The trial magistrate dwelt at length on whether consideration passed and found none. The appellant had also proceeded clandestinely despite knowing his cousin was utilizing the suit plot, indicating awareness of the plaintiffs' interest. The counterclaim was therefore dismissed on sound principles of law and fact.

p. 3
03

Whether the trial magistrate was biased against the appellant.

Holding

No. There was nothing in the proceedings before the trial magistrate to indicate bias, and the issue was never raised before that court; the claim of bias was unfounded.

Reasoning

The court treated the allegation of bias as a very serious one given the requirement of judicial impartiality, but noted the appellant had neither raised nor had the issue addressed at trial. Nothing in the record pointed to the magistrate entering the arena of litigation, so the ground failed.

p. 3

Legal principles established

#
  • The onus lies on a party relying on the existence of a trust to prove it through evidence; courts will not imply a trust save in case of absolute necessity or to give effect to the intentions of the parties.
  • On a first appeal, the appellate court must re-evaluate the evidence, assess it and make its own conclusions, while making allowance for the fact that it neither saw nor heard the witnesses.
  • Pleadings are not evidence; averments that are not proved or admitted have no evidential value and no decision can be founded upon them.
  • A constructive trust may arise from the conduct of the parties where there is a common intention that the claimant have a beneficial interest and the claimant has acted to his detriment in reliance on that intention.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The appeal is dismissed with costs to the respondents.
  2. 2.The judgment of the Senior Resident Magistrate delivered on 31/10/2018 (which found a constructive trust in favour of the plaintiffs, granted a permanent injunction against the appellant and costs of the suit) is upheld and left undisturbed.
  3. 3.The appellant's counterclaim (restraining orders and damages of Kshs. 35,000), which was dismissed by the trial court, remains dismissed.

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Law of Contract ActSection 3

Cases cited (4)

  • Selle vs. Associated Motor Boat Company Ltd
    (1968) EA. 123
  • Juletabi African Adventure Limited & Another v Christopher Michael Lockley
    [2017] eKLR
  • Robert Ghonzi Kimani vs. David Bwire Khisa & Another
  • CMC Aviation Limited vs Cruisair Limited (No. 1)
    1978 KLR 103 and 104
On appeal from
Principal Magistrate's Court at Nkubu (before the Senior Resident Magistrate, Hon. J. M. Irura)
Civil Suit No. 134 of 2014
Jurisdiction invoked
First appellate jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court over the decision of the Senior Resident Magistrate in a land dispute (this being a first appeal, the court re-evaluated the evidence as required by Selle vs Associated Motor Boat Company Ltd)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Constatine Martin Kithinji Gitobu v Harriet Nkuene Kirimania & 9 others [2019] KEELC 24 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Civil Appeal No 52 of 2018. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2019/24/eng@2019-12-10

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.