Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedELC Suit (Mombasa) - Notice of Motion dated 15.9.2017· [2018] KEELC 4021 (KLR)

Mahmood Shariff Ali & 10 others v Safaricom Limited [2018] KEELC 4021 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
15 February 2018
1,457 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~6 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenyan landowners challenging a Safaricom phone mast lost because they had no expert report proving the station would actually harm the environment.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Plaintiffs moved the Environment and Land Court at Mombasa by Notice of Motion dated 15 September 2017 seeking a temporary injunction to restrain the Defendant from erecting a base trans-receiver station on title number Mombasa/Block XX/139 at Mwembe Tayari, near Uhuru Gardens, pending trial. They argued the station would emit harmful rays, contravening their Article 42 right to a clean and healthy environment, and that Article 70(3) required no proof of loss or injury. The Defendant opposed, noting seven public participation forums had been held, that NEMA had approved the Environmental Impact Assessment project report by Mazingira Limited, and that technical issues required expert evidence. A preliminary objection on jurisdiction under Section 129 of EMCA was withdrawn. Framing three issues - violation of the right to a clean environment, prima facie case, and costs - the court applied the Giella principles and the Mrao definition of a prima facie case. It held that without a project-specific expert report on emissions, the court could not conclude the station would harm the environment; the ICNIRP guidelines attached were mere guidelines, and the court should not enter technical issues outside its remit, following Evanson Gachoka Kamau and West Kenya Sugar. The claim of failure to seek Communications Authority consent was unsupported by material. The application was dismissed with costs to abide the outcome of the main suit.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the right to a clean and healthy environment under Article 42 was threatened by the base trans-receiver station

Holding

No violation or infringement of Article 42 rights was established in the absence of expert evidence.

Reasoning

The court accepted that Article 42 entitles the plaintiffs to a clean environment and Article 70(3) removes any need to show loss or injury. However, the claim rested on assertions that the station would emit harmful rays. No expert report on the particular station was placed before the court; the ICNIRP guidelines attached were merely guidelines. NEMA had approved the EIA report by Mazingira Limited, and technical evaluation of emissions falls to persons with specialized expertise, not the court. Hence no threat was proved.

p. 3
02

Whether a prima facie case with probability of success was established for an interlocutory injunction

Holding

No prima facie case established; the application failed on the first limb of the Giella principles.

Reasoning

Applying the Mrao definition of a prima facie case, the plaintiffs had to show an apparent infringement of a right calling for rebuttal. Their assertions of harm were unsupported by expert material, and their averment that the defendant failed to seek consent of the Communications Authority was likewise unsupported by any material. Technical issues on emissions would require expert testimony at trial. The first limb of Giella -v- Cassman Brown not being satisfied, the injunction could not issue.

p. 4

Legal principles established

#
  • In the absence of an expert report on the effect of a base trans-receiver station, a court cannot conclude it has a negative environmental impact; general guidelines are not a substitute for a project-specific expert report.
  • A court should not adjudicate on technical matters outside its remit; such issues require expert testimony at trial.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Notice of Motion dated 15.9.2017 is dismissed
  2. 2.The costs of the application shall abide the outcome of the main suit

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Environmental Management and Coordination ActSection 68(1), Section 129(1) & (2)
  • Environmental (Impact Assessment and Audit) RegulationsRegulations 17 and 21
  • Civil Procedure ActSections 1A, 1B, 3A
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 40 Rule 1; Order 51 Rule 1
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 42, 70, 70(3)

Cases cited (5)

  • Giella -versus- Cassman Brown And Company Limited
    (1973) E.A 358
  • Mrao Limited -versus- First American Bank Limited And 2 Others
    (2003) KLR 125
  • Ken Kasinga -versus- Daniel Kiplangat Kirui And 5 Others
    Nakuru ELC Petition No 50 of 2013
  • Evanson Gachoka Kamau And 5 Others -versus- Cabinet Secretary, Roads & Infrastructure And 2 Others
    (2016) eKLR
  • West Kenya Sugar Co. Ltd -versus- Kenya Sugar Board And Another
    (2014) eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Section 68(1) of the Environmental Management and Coordination Act 1999; Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act; Orders 40 Rule 1 and 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2010

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Mahmood Shariff Ali & 10 others v Safaricom Limited [2018] KEELC 4021 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2018). ELC Suit (Mombasa) - Notice of Motion dated 15.9.2017. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2018/4021/eng@2018-02-15

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.