Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissed· [2018] KEELC 2731 (KLR)

Mesgo Limited v National Bank of Kenya Ltd [2018] KEELC 2731 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
21 June 2018
1,570 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~6 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court allowed a bank to proceed with selling a borrower's land because the borrower could not prove the bank's valuation was deliberately wrong.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Plaintiff, a borrower charged over Title No. Embu/Municipality/931 to secure a loan of Kshs 15,000,000 from the Defendant bank, moved the Environment and Land Court at Embu by notice of motion dated 19th July 2017 (later amended) under Order 40 Rules 12 and 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules, seeking an interlocutory injunction to restrain the Defendant from selling, alienating or transferring the suit property under its statutory power of sale. The Plaintiff contended that the Defendant's valuation of Kshs 41 million (forced sale value Kshs 31 million) grossly undervalued property worth some three times the debt, pointing to its own valuation of Kshs 50 million. The Defendant filed grounds of opposition only, arguing breach of Order 51 Rule 4 and duplication of a pending magistrates' court suit. The court framed three issues. It held that the procedural flaw in the amended application did not go to the root of the matter and could not defeat the application in light of Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution and section 19(1) of the Environment and Land Court Act. It held that section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act did not apply because the magistrates' court lacked pecuniary jurisdiction over the subject matter. On the merits, applying Giella v Cassman Brown and following Zum Zum Investment and Olkasasi, the court found that a mere difference in valuations, without more, was not evidence of mischief, and the Plaintiff had not demonstrated a prima facie case of undervaluation in breach of section 97 of the Land Act. Having failed the first Giella limb, the other limbs fell away. The application was dismissed with costs to the Defendant.

Key legal issues

#
01

Compliance with Order 51 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Rules

Holding

The technical flaw in the amended application (no new affidavit annexed) did not go to the root of the matter and did not oust the court's jurisdiction; justice must be administered without undue regard to procedural technicalities.

Reasoning

The Plaintiff obtained leave to amend the original notice of motion but instead filed what appeared to be a new application dated 27th July 2017 without a fresh supporting affidavit, while still referring to the earlier affidavit of Njue Mugo. The court held that since no prejudice was shown to the Defendant, the flaw was a technicality which, under Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution and section 19(1) of the Environment and Land Court Act, could not defeat the application.

p. 2
02

Pendency of Embu CMCC No. 228 of 2016 and section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act

Holding

Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act was inapplicable because the subject matter's value exceeded the magistrates' court's pecuniary jurisdiction, so that court could not grant the relief sought.

Reasoning

The Defendant contended the suit duplicated a pending lower court case. The court noted scanty material on record about the magistrate's court matter, including an unannexed exhibit. It nevertheless found that the value of the suit property was beyond the magistrates' court pecuniary jurisdiction, making that court incompetent to grant an injunction over the charged property; res judicata/section 6 bar therefore did not apply.

p. 2
03

Whether an interlocutory injunction should issue to restrain the statutory power of sale

Holding

The Plaintiff failed to establish a prima facie case with a probability of success under the Giella v Cassman Brown test because it did not demonstrate deliberate undervaluation of the suit property; the application failed at the first Giella limb.

Reasoning

The Defendant's valuation of Kshs 41 million (April 2016) and the Plaintiff's of Kshs 50 million (May 2017) differed by about Kshs 9 million, but the valuations were done about a year apart and different valuers may differ without malice. Citing Zum Zum Investment and Olkasasi, the court held that a counter-valuation alone cannot dislodge a bank's valuation; there was no breach or threatened breach of section 97 of the Land Act. The other Giella limbs did not need consideration.

p. 2

Legal principles established

#
  • A procedural flaw in a notice of motion that causes no prejudice does not defeat the court's jurisdiction, having regard to Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution and section 19(1) of the Environment and Land Court Act.
  • A plaintiff cannot resist a chargee's exercise of the statutory power of sale by merely producing a counter-valuation report; it must demonstrate on real terms and legal parameters that the bank's valuation does not give the best price reasonably obtainable.
  • A mere variance between a plaintiff's valuation and the bank's valuation is not, without more, evidence of mischief or deliberate undervaluation by the chargee.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Plaintiff's application for injunction dated 19th July 2017 (as amended) is dismissed with costs to the Defendant

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 40 Rules 12 and 9
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 51 Rule 4
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 50 Rule 4
  • Civil Procedure Act (Cap 21)section 3
  • Civil Procedure Act (Cap 21)section 6
  • Constitution of KenyaArticle 159(2)(d)
  • Environment and Land Court Act (Cap 12A)section 19(1)
  • Land Actsection 97

Cases cited (3)

  • Giella Vs Cassman Brown & Co Ltd
    [1973] EA 358
  • Zum Zum Investment Ltd Vs Habib Bank Ltd
    (2014) eKLR
  • Olkasasi Ltd Vs Equity Bank Ltd
    [2015] eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Article 162(2) of the Constitution of Kenya (Environment and Land Court) - implied; procedural applications under Order 40 Rules 12 and 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules and section 3 of the Civil Procedure Act (Cap 21)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Mesgo Limited v National Bank of Kenya Ltd [2018] KEELC 2731 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2018). . Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2018/2731/eng@2018-06-21

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.