Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedPetition dated 8th February 2018 (ELC, Kisii)· [2018] KEELC 2663 (KLR)

Simon Otwori & 7 v Lake Victoria South Weather Service Board & 6 others [2018] KEELC 2663 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
29 June 2018
4,202 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~17 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

The court refused to stop the Bonyunyu Dam project, ruling residents had not shown a strong enough case while the project is only at feasibility study stage.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is an interlocutory ruling of the Environment and Land Court at Kisii on a Notice of Motion dated 8th February 2018 seeking a conservatory/temporary injunction to restrain the respondents from surveying, beaconing, or dealing with land in eight villages within Gachuba Ward, Nyamira County, pending hearing of a petition challenging the proposed Bonyunyu Dam project. The petitioners alleged the project was being implemented secretly without public participation, without an Environmental Impact Assessment, and in breach of Articles 10, 35, 40 and 47 of the Constitution. The 1st respondent, Lake Victoria South Water Services Board, countered that the project was a Vision 2030 flagship co-financed by Kenya and the Netherlands, that only a feasibility study was underway, that about six families (not 600) would be affected, and that extensive stakeholder forums evidenced public participation. NEMA raised a jurisdictional objection which dissipated as the matter was properly before the ELC. Applying the Giella v Cassman Brown principles as adapted for conservatory orders in Munya and Kenya Association of Manufacturers, and the definition of a prima facie case in Mrao Ltd, Mutungi J held the petitioners had not demonstrated a prima facie case: stakeholder meeting minutes showed engagement, the EIA with public participation was still to come, and no information had been denied to the petitioners. Any displacement would be compensated under Article 40(3) and sections 107-133 of the Land Act through compulsory acquisition by the National Land Commission. The balance of convenience favoured the wider public benefit of the project. The motion was dismissed with no orders as to costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the petitioners established a prima facie case for interim relief

Holding

No prima facie case was demonstrated; the evidence shows the project is at feasibility study stage with documented stakeholder engagement, and the EIA process with public participation lies ahead

Reasoning

The court found minutes of stakeholder forums annexed to the 1st respondent's replying affidavit demonstrated public engagement. The project was at feasibility stage, not implementation, and the EIA study would yet provide opportunity for participation and objection before any NEMA licence. The petition was premature since the court lacked full information to weigh benefits against adverse impacts.

p. 5
02

Whether the petitioners' rights under Articles 10, 35 and 40 were being violated

Holding

No infringement shown; the respondents were acting transparently and no denial of access to information was proved; Article 40 protects against deprivation of land only with just compensation

Reasoning

The court held there was no evidence the petitioners had sought information which was denied. The project's transparency negated claims of opacity under Article 10. Article 40(3) permits deprivation for a public purpose with prompt, just compensation through compulsory acquisition by the National Land Commission, so damages would be an adequate remedy.

p. 5
03

Balance of convenience and adequacy of damages

Holding

The balance of convenience tilts against the injunction given the wider public benefit of the project, and any affected persons can be compensated by damages

Reasoning

The proposed dam is an infrastructural project intended to benefit a wider public extending to Kisii County. The uncertainty over the number of persons affected stemmed from the incomplete feasibility study. If certified viable after EIA, affected persons would be compensated under Article 40(3) and the Land Act, so no irreparable injury was demonstrated.

p. 6

Legal principles established

#
  • In determining whether to grant a conservatory order in a constitutional petition, the primary consideration remains whether the petitioner has demonstrated a prima facie case with a probability of success
  • At the interlocutory stage of a conservatory order application the court makes no definite findings of fact or law but evaluates whether a prima facie case and prejudice exist
  • Land required for a public purpose may be compulsorily acquired under the Land Act with prompt payment of just compensation, rendering damages an adequate remedy

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The petitioners' Notice of Motion dated 8th February 2018 is dismissed
  2. 2.No orders as to costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 10, 20, 22, 23, 24, 35, 40(3), 47, 64, 67, 159, 165, 232; Chapter Five
  • Land ActSections 107 to 133 (No. 6 of 2012), Section 107
  • Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedural Rulesgeneral

Cases cited (4)

  • Giella -vs- Cassman Brown Co. Ltd
    [1973] EA 358
  • Gatirau Peter Munya -vs- Dickson Mwenda Kithinji & 2 Others
    (Pet No. 2 of 2014) [2014] eKLR
  • Kenya Association of Manufacturers & 2 Others -vs- Cabinet Secretary Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources & 3 Others
    [2017] eKLR
  • Mrao Ltd -vs- First American Bank of Kenya Ltd & 2 Others
    [2003] KLR 125
Jurisdiction invoked
Articles 10, 20, 22, 40, 64, 159 and 165 of the Constitution; Article 23 and 24 (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedural Rules

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (6)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Simon Otwori & 7 v Lake Victoria South Weather Service Board & 6 others [2018] KEELC 2663 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2018). Petition dated 8th February 2018 (ELC, Kisii). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2018/2663/eng@2018-06-29

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.