Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCPartially AllowedReference under Rule 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order (Chamber Summons dated 7th February 2017 and 20th February 2017)· [2017] KEELC 2938 (KLR)

Isaac Maina Kamau v Rahab Wangare Gachiengo & another [2017] KEELC 2938 (KLR)

High Court of Kenya
10 May 2017
2,333 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~9 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
Two applications under Rule 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order – one by the plaintiff, one by the first defendant – challenged the Deputy Registrar's taxation of 24th January 2017, which allowed item 1 (instruction fees) of each party's bill of costs at Kshs.5,000 on the footing that the bills arose from an application for stay of execution under Schedule 6 paragraph C8 ('Other applications not provided for'). Both applicants relied on their applications and supporting affidavits without oral submissions. The court found that item 1 of the plaintiff's bill pleaded instructions to file the originating summons for recovery of Njoro/Ngata Block 4/133 (Rumwe), while the first defendant's item 1 pleaded instructions to defend that originating summons; taxation should therefore have proceeded under Schedule 6, Part A, paragraph 1(b) of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, 2014, not paragraph (c)(viii). The taxing officer's decision was accordingly based on an error of principle and law. Invoking Moronge & Company Advocates v Kenya Airports Authority and related authorities, the judge exercised his discretion to tax the disputed item himself rather than remit, since no other items were contested. Applying the Joreth principle, the value of the subject matter was fixed at KShs 1,500,000 as at 2012 (the pleaded figures of Kshs 16 million and Kshs 12 million being unproven), and each applicant was awarded KShs 150,000 under item 1. The other items stood as taxed, yielding totals of KShs 297,725 and KShs 329,263 respectively. The applicants were awarded costs of the applications.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the Deputy Registrar applied the wrong provisions of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, 2014

Holding

Yes. Item 1 in each bill related to instructions to file or defend the originating summons, so taxation should have proceeded under Schedule 6, Part A, paragraph 1(b), not under paragraph (c)(viii) as if it were an application for stay of execution.

Reasoning

The Deputy Registrar treated the bills as arising from an application for stay of execution and taxed instruction fees at Kshs.5,000. On the face of the bills, item 1 covered instructions to institute (plaintiff) and defend (1st defendant) the originating summons on adverse possession. Taxing under the wrong schedule head, and pegging the fee to an application rather than the suit, was an error of principle and law justifying interference on the reference.

p. 3
02

Whether the judge could tax the contentious item himself instead of remitting it

Holding

Yes. The judge has jurisdiction and discretion to tax the contested item himself where the justice of the case requires.

Reasoning

Relying on Moronge & Company Advocates v Kenya Airports Authority, D'Sonza v Ferrao, James v Nyeri Electricity and Kipkorir Titoo & Kiara Advocates v Deposit Protection Fund Board, the court held that a judge on a reference may tax the bill himself after finding an error of principle. Since only the instruction-fee items were disputed, it was pragmatic to tax them once and for all rather than remit.

p. 3
03

What value of subject matter should anchor the instruction fees

Holding

KShs 1,500,000 as at the date of instructions in 2012, being the suit property's purchase price of KShs 990,000 in 1988 with appreciation in value, since the pleaded figures of Kshs 16 million and Kshs 12 million were unsupported.

Reasoning

The value of the subject matter must be drawn from pleadings, judgment or settlement (Joreth Limited v Kigano & Associates). The applicants' asserted values of 16 million and 12 million were not proven by pleadings or judgment. The judgment recorded a purchase price of KShs 990,000 in 1988; allowing for appreciation to the 2012 instructions dates, the court fixed the value at KShs 1,500,000 and applied the paragraph 1(b) scale.

Legal principles established

#
  • A judge of the High Court has jurisdiction on a Rule 11 reference to tax a contested bill himself rather than remit it to the taxing officer.
  • Instruction fees should be based on the value of the subject matter in dispute as determined from the pleadings, judgment or settlement.
  • Where a taxing officer proceeds on a wrong provision or wrong basis, that is an error of principle entitling the court to interfere.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The decision of the Deputy Registrar dated 24th January 2017 taxing item 1 of both bills of costs at Kshs.5,000 is set aside for error of principle
  2. 2.Applying Schedule 6, Part A, paragraph 1(b) of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, 2014, each applicant is awarded KShs 150,000 under item 1 of their respective bill of costs
  3. 3.The other items of the bills of costs remain as taxed by the Deputy Registrar
  4. 4.Total award under the plaintiff's bill of costs dated 12th March 2016 is KShs 297,725 and under the 1st defendant's bill of costs dated 20th May 2016 is KShs 329,263
  5. 5.The applicants are awarded costs of the applications

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Advocates (Remuneration) OrderRule 11(1) and Rule 11(2); Schedule 6, Part A, paragraph 1(b); paragraph (c)(viii); Schedule 6 paragraph C8; proviso (1) of Schedule VIA
  • Civil Procedure ActSection 2 (definition of 'pleading')

Cases cited (8)

  • Moronge & Company Advocates v Kenya Airports Authority
    [2014] eKLR
  • D'sonza v Ferrao
    [1960] EA 602
  • James v Nyeri Electricity
    [1961] 492
  • Haiders Bin Mohamed Elmandry and Others v Khadija Binti Ali Bin Salim
    (4) 1956, 23 E.A.C.A. 313
  • Kipkorir Titoo & Kiara Advocates v Deposit Protection Fund Board
    [Civil Appeal No. 220 of 2004] (UR)
  • Devshi Dhanji Naran Patel (No. 2)
    [1978] KLR 243
  • Eastland Hotel Limited v Wafula Simiyu & Co. Advocates
    [2014] eKLR
  • Joreth Limited v Kigano & Associates
On appeal from
Deputy Registrar (High Court, Nakuru) – taxing officer
Taxation of Plaintiff's Bill of Costs dated 12th March 2016 and 1st Defendant's Party & Party Bill of Costs dated 20th May 2016
Jurisdiction invoked
Rule 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order; inherent jurisdiction of the High Court on a reference from a taxing officer

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Isaac Maina Kamau v Rahab Wangare Gachiengo & another [2017] KEELC 2938 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2017). Reference under Rule 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order (Chamber Summons dated 7th February 2017 and 20th February 2017). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2017/2938/eng@2017-05-10

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.