Ex-Parte Applicant Ngiri Ikua (Represented By Agostino Ndaru Muitanjau) v Minister For Lands & 2 others [2017] KEELC 2598 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Environment and Land Court ruled it cannot overturn a High Court decision—even a flawed one—so challenges must go through appeal.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether an amended Notice of Motion filed without leave under Order 8 of the Civil Procedure Rules is fatally defective
No. An interlocutory application is not a pleading, so Order 8 Rule 1 does not strictly apply; however, leave is generally required to amend applications. An amendment brought without leave should not be struck down absent prejudice or injustice incapable of remedy by costs.
The court adopted Karuri Limited v Uber Kenya Ltd, holding procedural law is a handmaiden of substantive justice. It went further than the cited authority, holding an amendment should not be struck out regardless of whether a response had been filed, so long as no unremediable prejudice is caused. Article 159(2)(d) and section 19 of the ELC Act supported dismissing the objection on technicalities.
Whether the introduction of merits issues in the amended application could sustain a preliminary objection
No. That complaint is an ordinary legal ground properly deployed as grounds of opposition, not a preliminary objection within the Mukisa Biscuits meaning.
The court found that faulting an application for raising merits rather than procedural issues does not meet the definition of a preliminary objection, which must be a point of law arising on the pleadings alone. It dismissed that ground of the objection accordingly.
Whether the ELC can review, set aside or nullify a High Court judicial review decision allegedly made without jurisdiction
Although a High Court decision may in a technical sense be reviewable by the ELC, the ELC cannot sit on appeal over High Court decisions; a party alleging the decision was made without jurisdiction must pursue an appeal.
The court distinguished the position of a co-ordinate court correcting its own mistakes (citing Kanyiita, Waweru and Nakumatt) from the position where an ELC judge is asked to nullify proceedings before a High Court judge. Under Article 162 the ELC is of equal status to the High Court and cannot overturn its decisions; only a higher court can. Hence the striking-out prayers failed.
Legal principles established
#- An interlocutory application is not a pleading, but amendments to applications generally require leave of court; failure to obtain leave is not fatal absent prejudice or injustice to the adverse party
- An ELC judge, being of co-ordinate jurisdiction with the High Court, cannot overturn or nullify a High Court decision; a party aggrieved by such a decision must appeal
- Procedural technicalities should not obstruct substantive justice, consistent with Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution and section 19 of the Environment and Land Court Act
Court orders
#- 1.The notice of preliminary objection succeeds in one respect
- 2.The amended Notice of Motion dated 17th February 2017 is struck out with costs
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Environment and Land Court Act (jurisdiction under Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution); Article 159(2)(d) invoked on overriding objective
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Ex-Parte Applicant Ngiri Ikua (Represented By Agostino Ndaru Muitanjau) v Minister For Lands & 2 others [2017] KEELC 2598 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2017). Not stated in the judgment (Judicial Review proceedings, Embu ELC). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2017/2598/eng@2017-06-28
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.