Ali Abdalla Salim & 2 others (as Trustees of the Tawheed Girls Secondary School Trust) v Abubakar Masoud & another [2017] KEELC 1 (KLR)
The bottom line
#The court confirmed the plaintiffs as lawful trustees who own the Malindi school plot on behalf of the school, not a private association.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the Plaintiffs are the lawful Trustees of Tawheed Girls Secondary School
Yes. The Plaintiffs were recognised as trustees by the Board minutes, the Ministry of Education's Directorate of Quality Assurance report, and the letter of allotment and Grant were issued in the school's name, not the Association's.
The court relied on Board of Governors and Trustees minutes from 2008-2010 in which the 1st Defendant participated without objection, the Ministry of Education registration and Quality Assurance report recognising the management structure, and the allotment letter and Grant issued in the school's name. The 1st Plaintiff and 1st Defendant were the first trustees, and no evidence showed the Association owned the land or built the school. The Defendants were compensated Kshs. 3,000,000 for structures, inconsistent with a claim of ownership.
Whether the duplicate Deed Plan was fraudulently obtained
No. The original Deed Plan was misplaced or withheld by the 1st Defendant; the duplicate was lawfully obtained after the Director of Surveys verified the school's status with the Malindi District Education Board.
The evidence showed the original Deed Plan was handed to the 1st Defendant to pursue title and was thereafter reported lost. Mr. Bakshwein swore the affidavit and obtained a certified copy after the Director of Surveys confirmed with the Education Board that the land should be registered in favour of the school. The school then obtained Grant No. 53762 in 2011. The Defendants produced no proof that the process was unlawful or fraudulent.
Ownership of Plot No. 8604
The school, through its Board of Trustees, owns Plot No. 8604; Tawheed Muslim Association does not.
The land was allocated for a nursery school/public utility and the letter of allotment of 21st March 1994 was issued to Lelabei Ventures, not the Association. The school obtained its own allotment letter in 2001 and Grant in 2011. The Association's annual returns 1986-2012 showed its only asset as Plot No. 5050 with buildings, not the suit land. The Defendants were compensated for structures they put up, negating ownership.
Intermeddling by the 2nd Defendant
The 2nd Defendant, being neither a trustee nor a Board member, unlawfully interfered with the school's management; an injunction issues against him and the 1st Defendant.
The court found from the exhibited correspondence that the 2nd Defendant, who held no position in the school's management structure recognised by the Ministry of Education, purported to dissolve the Board of Trustees, Board of Governors and teaching staff. Such interference justified a permanent restraint in favour of the lawful trustees.
Legal principles established
#- Persons who hold registered land only as trustees for an institution cannot have that arrangement disturbed by non-trustees claiming ownership through a separate association
Court orders
#- 1.The Plaintiffs are declared the legitimate Trustees of Tawheed Girls Secondary School Trust
- 2.Abubakar Masoud and Munir Abubakar Masoud, either individually or as members of Tawheed Muslim Association, or their agents, servants or nominees, are restrained from interfering, obstructing, impeding and or otherwise tampering with the running and management of Tawheed Girls Secondary School
- 3.The Defendants' Amended Counter-Claim dated 13th July 2015 is dismissed with costs
- 4.The 1st and 2nd Defendants to pay the costs of the Amended Originating Summons and the Counter-Claim to the Plaintiffs
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court over disputes relating to ownership of land (Plot No. 8604, Malindi) and trusteeship of the trust holding it
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Ali Abdalla Salim & 2 others (as Trustees of the Tawheed Girls Secondary School Trust) v Abubakar Masoud & another [2017] KEELC 1 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2017). Malindi ELC Originating Summons (Amended) dated 12th March 2014. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2017/1/eng@2017-10-05
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.