Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCPartially AllowedMiscellaneous Application No. 65 of 2013 (Reference)· [2016] KEELC 131 (KLR)

Joseph Memba Syuma & 5 others v Okong’o Wandago & Co. Advocates [2016] KEELC 131 (KLR)

High Court of Kenya
4 November 2016
2,038 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~8 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court cut a law firm's fee bill slightly, ruling that legal costs included in a settlement cannot count when calculating instruction fees.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This was a reference under Rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order 2009 challenging the taxation by the Deputy Registrar (Hon. S. Mwayuli) of the Respondent advocates' Advocate/Client Bill of Costs, in which only the instruction fees of Kshs.20,000,000/= were contested. The Respondent had acted for the Applicants in a land dispute (Nairobi ELC No. 507 of 2009) settled first by a consent of 14th February 2011 at Kshs.250,000,000/=, which was set aside, and later by a second consent of 2nd December 2014 at Kshs.350,000,000/= plus Kshs.4,000,000/= legal fees. The Deputy Registrar adopted Kshs.354,000,000/= (the full settlement figure) as the value of the subject matter, following Joreth Limited v. Kigano & Associates, and taxed instruction fees at Kshs.4,535,000/=. The judge agreed that the second consent, not the set-aside first consent or the valuation of Kshs.465,000,000/=, determined the value of the subject matter, and found that the Applicants had not discharged the burden of showing an error of principle. However, the court held of its own motion that legal costs should not have been included in the value of the subject matter. The reference was allowed in part: the assessed instruction fees were set aside and substituted with Kshs.4,399,000/= computed on Kshs.350,000,000/=, and the Bill of Costs was taxed overall at Kshs.4,708,625/=. As the decisive ground was raised by the court sua sponte, each party was ordered to bear its own costs of the reference.

Key legal issues

#
01

Which consent determines the value of the subject matter for taxation

Holding

The value of the subject matter is taken from the final settlement, not the earlier consent that was set aside

Reasoning

The first consent of 14th February 2011 settling the suit at Kshs.250,000,000/= was disputed and set aside. After the parties entered a new consent on 2nd December 2014 settling at Kshs.350,000,000/= plus Kshs.4,000,000/= legal fees, the taxing officer correctly adopted the second consent as the basis for the value of the subject matter, applying the Joreth Limited principle.

p. 3
02

Whether legal costs form part of the value of the subject matter

Holding

The Deputy Registrar erred by including the Kshs.4,000,000/= legal costs in the value of the subject matter; instruction fees should be assessed on Kshs.350,000,000/= alone

Reasoning

The settlement figure of Kshs.354,000,000/= comprised a principal sum of Kshs.350,000,000/= and legal costs of Kshs.4,000,000/=. The court held that legal fees cannot be part of the value of the subject matter for assessing instruction fees, and substituted the correct figure and recomputed fees itself to avoid remitting back.

p. 3
03

Standard of interference with the taxing officer's discretion

Holding

The Applicants failed to discharge the burden of showing an error of principle, save for the inclusion of legal costs

Reasoning

Applying Kipkorir, Titoo & Kiara and Arthur v. Nyeri Electricity Undertaking, the court would interfere only for an error of principle or manifest excess. The Applicants did not show that the choice of the settlement amount as the value of the subject matter was erroneous; only the inclusion of legal fees warranted interference.

p. 3

Legal principles established

#
  • On a reference under Rule 11, the judge will not interfere with the taxing officer's discretion unless the taxing officer erred in principle; quantum alone is interfered with only in exceptional cases
  • For taxation purposes, the value of the subject matter is determined from the pleadings, judgment or settlement
  • Legal costs included in a settlement amount should not be counted as part of the value of the subject matter for assessing instruction fees

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Set aside the sum of Kshs.4,537,000/= assessed by the Deputy Registrar as instruction fees
  2. 2.Substitute therefor instruction fees of Kshs.4,399,000/= based on Kshs.350,000,000/= as the value of the subject matter
  3. 3.Tax the Respondent's Bill of Costs dated 22nd October 2012 at Kshs.4,708,625/= (Item 1 Kshs.4,399,000; Items 1–6 Kshs.212,859; Disbursements Kshs.96,766)
  4. 4.Each party to bear its own costs of the reference

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Advocates Remuneration OrderRule 11

Cases cited (4)

  • Kipkorir, Titoo & Kiara Advocates vs. Deposit Protection Fund Board
    [2005] IKLR 528
  • Arthur vs. Nyeri Electricity Undertaking
    (1961) E.A
  • Devshi Dhanji vs. Kanji Naran Patel (No. 2)
    (1978) KLR 243
  • Joreth Limited vs. Kigano & Associates
    [2002] 1 E.A 92
On appeal from
Deputy Registrar (Taxing Master)
Misc. Application No. 65 of 2013, Okong'o Wandago & Co. Advocates vs. Bishop Rev. Joseph Memba Syuma & 5 Others
Jurisdiction invoked
Rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order 2009

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Joseph Memba Syuma & 5 others v Okong’o Wandago & Co. Advocates [2016] KEELC 131 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2016). Miscellaneous Application No. 65 of 2013 (Reference). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2016/131/eng@2016-11-04

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.