Hellen Jane Achieng’ Odegi v Kenya Commercial Bank [2016] KEELC 13 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan court stopped a bank from selling a charged home only because the sale figures didn't match the bank's own valuation, while rejecting other objections.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Prima facie case and service of the Notice to Sell
The Plaintiff admitted receiving the Statutory Notice but denied receipt of the Notice to Sell; the Defendant's Certificate of Postage to the Plaintiff's undisputed address satisfied the court that service was properly effected
Section 96 of the Land Act permits a chargee to sell where the chargor remains in default after expiry of the Section 90(1) notice, but requires service of a Notice to Sell at least 40 days before completing any sale contract. Since service was disputed, the burden shifted to the chargee. The charge instrument, notices and Letter of Offer all showed the address 16982–00100 Nairobi, matching the Certificate of Postage, and the Plaintiff did not dispute that address. The Certificate of Postage was held sufficient proof of posting and proper service.
Alleged breach of contract by variation of interest rates
The Letter of Offer expressly reserved the Bank's right to vary interest rates without notice, so the allegation of breach was unfounded
The Plaintiff contended that the Defendant breached the contract by varying interest and penalty rates and thereby clogging her right of redemption. The Defendant relied on Clause 5 of the Letter of Offer, which stipulated that the Bank reserves the right to charge such rate or rates as it may decide and is not required to advise any change in the rate of interest. On perusal, the court found the Defendant had authority to vary the rate at any time without notifying the Plaintiff, and that the dispute over the amount demanded could not ground an injunction.
Alleged gross undervaluation contrary to Section 97 of the Land Act
The Plaintiff cast doubt on the true market and forced sale valuations; a disparity existed between the Defendant's valuation report and the Notification of Sale, justifying preservation of the property pending a joint valuation
The Defendant's valuer, M/s Kenstate Valuers, gave an Open Market Value of Kshs. 16.5 Million and forced sale value of Kshs. 13 Million, yet the Notification of Sale stated Kshs. 15 Million and Kshs. 12 Million respectively, and it was unexplained where the Notification of Sale figures were derived from. The Plaintiff's own valuation returned Kshs. 19 Million and Kshs. 14.3 Million. The court was satisfied the Plaintiff raised cogent evidence of possible undervaluation and, on this sole ground, entered a status quo order directing a joint valuation within 45 days.
Legal principles established
#- Where service of statutory notices is disputed, the burden shifts to the chargee to demonstrate prima facie that service was effected
- A chargee must issue a Statutory Notice under Section 90(1) and a Notice to Sell under Section 96(2) of the Land Act, and may only complete a sale after at least 40 days from service of the notice to sell
- A certificate of postage is sufficient proof of posting to a chargor's last known address where the address is not disputed
- A dispute as to the amount due cannot be a basis for granting an injunction to restrain a bank from exercising its statutory power of sale
- The values in a valuation report are supposed to inform the Notification of Sale
Court orders
#- 1.The Court declined to confirm the injunction orders prayed in the Notice of Motion dated 10th September 2015
- 2.A status quo order to the effect that the Defendant shall not dispose of the suit property until the issue of valuation is settled
- 3.The parties to select one valuer to undertake a joint valuation within 45 days of the date of the order, with the report to be filed within 7 days thereafter
- 4.Costs of the joint valuation to be borne by both parties equally
- 5.Costs of the application to be in the cause
- 6.Mention on 28th July 2016 for the joint valuation report and way forward
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original civil jurisdiction over the charge/land dispute and the Land Act (Sections 90, 96, 97 and 99(4)); no specific constitutional provision invoked in the judgment
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Hellen Jane Achieng’ Odegi v Kenya Commercial Bank [2016] KEELC 13 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2016). Notice of Motion dated 10th September 2015. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2016/13/eng@2016-05-23
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.