Salim Bakari Mwinyi & Others v Mohamed Ali Moses Alias Gandi & 5 Others [2015] KEELC 538 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Mombasa court allowed an adverse possession case to be heard together with a related suit over the same Mtwapa land, but refused to touch already-decided matters.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether to consolidate this adverse possession suit with Mombasa HCC No. 13 of 2013
Consolidation allowed in part; the suits share the same subject property (plot LR 5692, Plot No. 1589/13/111/MN at Mtwapa) and should be heard together, subject to the pending contempt application in No. 13 being dispensed with first.
The court noted that the 1st and 4th defendants in suit No. 13 did not object, and that the property in dispute in suit No. 13 forms part of the parcels the plaintiffs seek to have declared theirs by adverse possession in the originating summons. Differing titles and non-joinder of the 3rd respondent did not defeat the common subject matter. The suit No. 13 contempt application must first be resolved.
Whether to consolidate with Malindi HCC No. 102 of 2012 (OS)
Refused because that suit had already been struck out on 26th April 2013 and no appeal was demonstrated.
The 5th respondent annexed the ruling striking out Malindi suit 102 of 2012 delivered by O.A. Angote J. The applicants produced no document showing an appeal against that ruling. A determined matter cannot be consolidated with a pending one, so the prayer was refused.
Whether prayer (2) - stay and setting aside of judgment in suit No. 13 of 2013 - was properly before the court
Struck out as misplaced; such applications must be made in the relevant file and no judgment had been entered in suit No. 13.
Counsel for the 5th defendant confirmed no judgment had been entered in suit No. 13 of 2013, which remained pending. The court held that setting-aside applications belong in the file where the judgment or order was made, so the court could access the background facts. The prayer was therefore misplaced in the present motion and was struck out with costs.
Legal principles established
#- An application to set aside an order or judgment must be made in the file in which that order or judgment was made.
- A pending suit cannot be consolidated with a suit that has already been determined, absent a pending appeal.
- The purpose of consolidation is to avoid duplicity where suits can be heard together.
Court orders
#- 1.Prayer (2) seeking to stay and set aside the judgment in Civil Suit No. 13 of 2013 struck out with costs to the 3rd and 5th defendants
- 2.Prayer to consolidate with Malindi ELC No. 102 of 2012 (OS) refused
- 3.Prayer (1) allowed in part: this suit to be heard together with MBS High Court Civil Case No. 13 of 2013, subject to the pending contempt application in No. 13 being dispensed with first
- 4.Costs of the entire application awarded to the 3rd and 5th respondents
- 5.Defendants at liberty to file responses to the originating summons; this file designated the lead file
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Inherent procedural jurisdiction to consolidate pending suits (Civil Procedure practice); not expressly stated in the judgment
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Salim Bakari Mwinyi & Others v Mohamed Ali Moses Alias Gandi & 5 Others [2015] KEELC 538 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2015). Originating Summons (Mombasa ELC) with application dated 16th June 2014. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2015/538/eng@2015-04-22
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.