Carol Alois Osos & another (suing as officials of Nakuru United Methodist Church) v Diane Quattlebaum Hamrick & another [2015] KEELC 296 (KLR)
The bottom line
#The Environment and Land Court in Nakuru refused to remove a church's lawyer from a land dispute because the defendants proved no conflict of interest.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Res judicata regarding prior ruling on counsel's representation
The court declined to hold the application res judicata because it lacked the pleadings and context of the earlier ruling in Nakuru CMCC No. 682 of 2014
The court acknowledged that the same issue of Mr. Waiganjo's representation was raised and decided in Nakuru CMCC No. 682 of 2014, but without the pleadings from that case it could not determine the context in which the earlier application was argued. It therefore hesitated to find res judicata and proceeded to determine the application on its merits.
Whether Rule 9 of the Advocates Practicing Rules barred Mr. Waiganjo from appearing
Rule 9 did not apply because it was never suggested that Mr. Waiganjo might be required as a witness
Counsel for the applicants invoked Rule 9, which bars an advocate from appearing where he may be called as a witness in a contentious matter. The court set out the rule verbatim but found no suggestion that Mr. Waiganjo would be a witness, so the rule was inapplicable.
Whether Mr. Waiganjo formerly acted for the defendants creating a conflict of interest
No evidence that Mr. Waiganjo ever acted for the defendants; his only connection was joint membership of the School's BOG with the 1st defendant
The court assessed the affidavits and found that Mr. Waiganjo's involvement was solely with the plaintiff church and the school it runs, which is distinct from the 2nd defendant NGO. He never sat on the 2nd defendant's board nor dealt with the defendants professionally. Mere joint membership of the BOG does not disqualify him from acting against the defendants.
Whether Mr. Waiganjo holds confidential information of the defendants
No proof of any confidential information; the allegation was vague and unsupported by particulars of any meeting where titles were discussed
The 2nd defendant alleged that confidential information, including discussions on the titles, passed between herself and Mr. Waiganjo. The court found no specifics of the alleged confidential information and no proof of any meeting at which the titles were discussed, making it impossible to find that Mr. Waiganjo possesses information confidentially passed by the defendants.
Legal principles established
#- An advocate ought not to appear in a contentious matter in which he may be required as a witness (Rule 9 of the Advocates Practicing Rules)
- A party is entitled to counsel of his choice, and disqualification of counsel is only warranted on special facts established in each case
Court orders
#- 1.The defendants' application dated 9 March 2015 seeking the disqualification of Mr. Waiganjo Mwangi Advocate is dismissed
- 2.The application is dismissed with costs to the plaintiffs
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original civil jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court (land dispute over suit properties LR No. 62295/15, LR No. 11739, Dundori/Lanet Block 5/2090 and 5/2084, and Residential Plot No. 7 at Ngecha 'A' Trading Centre)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Carol Alois Osos & another (suing as officials of Nakuru United Methodist Church) v Diane Quattlebaum Hamrick & another [2015] KEELC 296 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2015). Not stated in judgment (arising from suit filed 11 February 2015). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2015/296/eng@2015-07-15
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.