Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedNot stated in the judgment as provided· [2014] KEELC 620 (KLR)

James Kimunyu Gathare v Videlia Muthoni Ndungu & another [2014] KEELC 620 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
2 October 2014
1,422 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~6 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan land court refused to end a plot ownership dispute early, ruling the paperwork was defective and both sides must argue it fully at trial.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This ruling by J.M. Mutungi, Judge, dated 2nd October 2014, disposed of a Notice of Motion dated 2nd October 2013 by the 1st Defendant. The motion, premised on Order 36 Rule 1(1)(b), Order 2 Rule 15(1)(a), Order 40 and sections 3A, 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act, sought review of the conservatory order made by Hon. Lady Justice Ougo on 11th March 2013, an injunction restraining the plaintiff from dealing with plot Nos. 12 and 13 Ruiru/Ruiru East Block 2/25314 (formerly plots 28 and 29 Embakasi Multipurpose Co-operative Society), striking out of the plaintiff's suit with judgment on the counterclaim, and police enforcement. The application followed a report by the 2nd Defendant, made pursuant to Justice Ougo's directions, which indicated the 1st Defendant was the bona fide owner. The court held the review limb fatally defective because the order sought to be reviewed was neither annexed to the application nor served, and that no Order 45 ground was satisfied in any event. The court further held that contested ownership of the plots cannot be resolved on affidavit evidence, since the plaintiff denies participating in the meeting that produced the report and would be entitled to cross-examine its makers at trial. Both parties occupy portions of the premises, and their competing claims can only be resolved at a full trial. The application was dismissed; the plaintiff's suit and the counterclaim were directed to proceed to trial, with Order 11 compliance within 45 days and a pretrial conference fixed for 27th November 2014. The status quo was maintained: no sale, transfer or permanent development, with unrestricted access preserved. Each party was ordered to bear their own costs of the application.

Key legal issues

#
01

Competency of the application for review

Holding

The application for review is fatally defective for failure to annex and serve the order sought to be reviewed, and in any event no Order 45 ground (new and important matter, error apparent on the face of the record, or sufficient reason) was demonstrated

Reasoning

Order 45 requires an aggrieved party to annex the decree or order under review. The 1st Defendant did not annex a copy of the 11th March 2013 order and did not serve it. Independently, the only new material was the 2nd Defendant's report, which the plaintiff does not admit and which can at best be tendered at trial with cross-examination of its makers.

p. 2
02

Injunction pending trial

Holding

Injunction refused; the plaintiff is in occupation of part of the premises and the 1st Defendant's children occupy another portion, so neither party is entitled to exclusive relief at the interlocutory stage

Reasoning

Both parties claim ownership of plots 28 and 29 (now 12 and 13) and both are in occupation of portions. Justice Ougo had earlier declined to determine ownership at the interlocutory stage; the court equally could not, as the competing interests can only be resolved by a full trial.

p. 3
03

Striking out the plaintiff's suit

Holding

The suit was not struck out; the court directed that the suit and counterclaim proceed to trial

Reasoning

The ownership dispute requires viva voce evidence tested by cross-examination; the 2nd Defendant's report favouring the 1st Defendant is not admitted by the plaintiff and cannot dispose of the suit on paper. Interlocutory skirmishes merely delay the final determination.

p. 3

Legal principles established

#
  • An application for review under Order 45 is fatally defective if the decree or order sought to be reviewed is not annexed to the application and served
  • Contested ownership of land cannot be determined on affidavit evidence and must be resolved at trial where witnesses can be cross-examined

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The 1st Defendant's application dated 2nd October 2013 is dismissed
  2. 2.Each party to bear their own costs of the application
  3. 3.The parties to comply with Order 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules within 45 days from the date of the ruling
  4. 4.Pretrial conference scheduled before any ELC Judge on 27th November 2014
  5. 5.The suit and counterclaim to proceed to trial
  6. 6.Parties to maintain the existing status quo: no party to sell, dispose of or transfer the suit properties; no further permanent developments; respective parties to retain unrestricted access to their buildings

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure Actsection 3A
  • Civil Procedure Actsection 1A
  • Civil Procedure Actsection 1B
  • Civil Procedure Actsection 2
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 36 Rule 1(1)(b)
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 2 Rule 15(1)(a)
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 40 Rules 1, 2(2), 3, 4, 8 and 10
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 45 Rule 1(1)
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 11
Jurisdiction invoked
Inherent jurisdiction under sections 3A, 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act and Orders 36, 40, 45 and 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules (original civil jurisdiction over land dispute)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "James Kimunyu Gathare v Videlia Muthoni Ndungu & another [2014] KEELC 620 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2014). Not stated in the judgment as provided. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2014/620/eng@2014-10-02

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.