Carmine Crimaldi v Village on Rivers Limited & 3 others [2014] KEELC 96 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan court cancelled a second sale of Malindi land, holding that an unregistered but signed transfer is still an enforceable contract that a paid seller cannot simply walk away from.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the unregistered transfer of the suit property to the 1st Defendant was enforceable
Yes. The executed transfer of 18th June 2007 was a valid contract capable of enforcement notwithstanding non-registration; absent evidence of repudiation and refund, the subsequent sale to the 4th Defendant was illegal, null and void.
The court applied section 32(2) of the repealed Registration of Titles Act. The vendor acknowledged receipt of the full purchase price, and the 1st Defendant, a juristic person, never received any refund. There was no evidence the contract was repudiated. The vendor therefore could not lawfully resell the same property to the 4th Defendant, a company whose only directors were the 2nd and 3rd Defendants.
Whether the Plaintiff had an interest in the suit property at the time of the first transfer
Yes. As at 18th June 2007 the Plaintiff held 40% (400 shares) of the 1st Defendant, giving him an equivalent stake in the suit property.
The parties agreed to purchase the property through the 1st Defendant, incorporated 9th February 2007 with the Plaintiff holding 400 shares. The Plaintiff and 2nd Defendant signed the transfer as directors. Although the Plaintiff later transferred his 400 shares, that transfer occurred after 18th June 2007, so he held a 40% beneficial interest when the property was purchased.
Whether the Plaintiff's shareholding of 69% could be determined
No. The court could not determine the current shareholding because neither party produced transfer documents or share certificates, and the Registrar of Companies was not called to testify.
The parties produced conflicting letters from the Registrar of Companies showing different shareholdings at different times. The exhibits from the criminal case, including the transfer documents, had disappeared. The court found it could not determine the issue with finality and directed that it be pursued in a separate suit, as it did not arise from the pleadings.
Whether the Plaintiff discharged the burden of proof on his alleged payments
No evidence was placed before the court that the Plaintiff paid 96,000 Euros to the 2nd or 3rd Defendants, but the court inferred a contribution from the fact that the Defendants allocated him 400 shares at incorporation.
The Plaintiff claimed to have paid 96,000 Euros in cash, which by its nature left no documentary trail. The court reasoned that if the Plaintiff had paid nothing, the 2nd and 3rd Defendants would not have allocated him 400 shares at incorporation, the sole purpose of which was to buy the suit property. The 25,000 Euros deposited into the 2nd Defendant's account was also unexplained, the 2nd Defendant not having testified.
Legal principles established
#- An unregistered but executed and stamped transfer remains a contract capable of enforcement, and a vendor paid in full cannot resell the same property without first repudiating the contract and refunding the purchase price.
Court orders
#- 1.A declaration that the transfer of L.R. No. 10814, Malindi Municipality to the 4th Defendant was registered fraudulently
- 2.Cancellation of the transfer of L.R. No. 10814, Malindi to the 4th Defendant and rectification of the certificate of title to show the 1st Defendant as the bona fide registered owner
- 3.A permanent injunction restraining the 2nd, 3rd and 4th Defendants from selling, alienating, developing or dealing with L.R. No. 10814, Malindi
- 4.The 2nd, 3rd and 4th Defendants to pay the Plaintiff the costs of the suit
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original civil jurisdiction of the High Court/Environment and Land Court under the land and title legislation (suit on transfer, cancellation and rectification of title to L.R. No. 10814, Malindi)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Carmine Crimaldi v Village on Rivers Limited & 3 others [2014] KEELC 96 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2014). Civil Suit (Mombasa Registry, filed 11th January 2010). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2014/96/eng@2014-11-07
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.