Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealDismissedCivil Application No. E006 of 2021 (Motion dated November 15, 2018)· [2023] KECA 935 (KLR)

Hanos (K) Ltd v Shah (Civil Application 110 of 2018) [2023] KECA 935 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
28 July 2023
2,884 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~12 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal confirmed that paying a judgment debt or issuing titles does not stop someone from appealing, and dismissed an attempt to strike out the appeal.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This was a Notice of Motion dated November 15, 2018 by Hanos (Kenya) Limited seeking to strike out the Respondent Dhiren Mohanlal Shah's Notice of Appeal dated October 22, 2018, on the grounds that no appeal lay from a decision on an Originating Summons without leave, that the Notice was served before it was lodged and endorsed by the Deputy Registrar, that it was served out of time, and that the appeal had been overtaken by events following issuance of titles pursuant to the judgment of October 18, 2018. The motion was brought under Rules 75, 77(1), 83 and 84 of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2010, and argued virtually on March 20, 2023. The Court identified the applicable striking-out provision as Rule 84. It held that an appeal being overtaken by events is not a ground under that rule, and that execution of a decree does not bar the undoubted right of appeal, following Machakos District Co-Operative Ltd v Nzuki Kiilu. On service of an un-lodged Notice, the Court held that Rule 79(1) expressly permits service before or within seven days after lodging, so a filed but un-endorsed notice may validly be served; to hold otherwise would penalise an intending appellant for registry delays not of his making. The Court further noted that the issues of service before lodging and service out of time had already been determined in its ruling of February 7, 2020 on the stay application (Civil Application No 59 of 2019), and could not be re-litigated by a fresh application. On appealability, it held that an Originating Summons is a suit, and a merit determination that finally disposes of it is a decree appealable as of right under Section 66 of the Civil Procedure Act without leave. The Court dismissed the motion with costs to the Respondent.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether an appeal overtaken by events is a ground for striking out a Notice of Appeal

Holding

It is not a ground under Rule 84, and in any event execution of a decree does not bar the right of appeal.

Reasoning

Rule 84 of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2010 limits grounds for striking out to (i) that no appeal lies, and (ii) that some essential step in the proceedings has not been taken within the prescribed time. The appeal having been overtaken by events, because titles were issued pursuant to the impugned judgment, is not among the statutory grounds. Substantively, following Machakos District Co-Operative Ltd v Nzuki Kiilu, the fact that the decretal sum has been paid or execution undertaken does not deprive a party of the undoubted right of appeal.

p. 4
02

Whether service of an un-lodged Notice of Appeal is incompetent

Holding

No; Rule 79(1) permits service before or within seven days after lodging, so an un-endorsed Notice of Appeal may validly be served.

Reasoning

Rule 79(1) allows an intended appellant to serve the notice before or within seven days after lodging it. This accommodates situations where the Deputy Registrar's endorsement is delayed through no fault of the intending appellant; penalising such a party would be unjust, and a court of justice has no jurisdiction to do injustice. The Court adopted the reasoning in Gulamhussein Noormohamed Cassam v Shashikant Ramji Sachania and Shital Bimal Shah v Akiba Bank Limited. Further, the issue was already determined in the stay application ruling of February 7, 2020.

p. 4
03

Whether an appeal lies as of right from a decision on an Originating Summons without leave

Holding

Yes; an Originating Summons is a suit, and a merit determination that finally disposes of it is a decree appealable as of right under Section 66 of the Civil Procedure Act.

Reasoning

The Court distinguished an application from a suit: an Originating Summons is a suit, and where a determination on merit finally disposes of the suit, the resulting order is a decree. Section 66 of the Civil Procedure Act provides that an appeal shall lie from decrees or orders of the High Court to the Court of Appeal. This accords with Ishmael Ithongo v Geoffrey Ithongo Thindiu and Roy Shipping SA v Dodoma Fishing Co. Ltd, where orders conclusively determining the parties' rights were held appealable as of right. No leave was therefore required.

p. 5
04

Whether the application is res judicata and moot given prior determinations in the stay application

Holding

Two of the issues (service before lodging and service out of time) were raised and determined in the stay application; the proper course for an aggrieved party is not another application.

Reasoning

In the ruling on Civil Application No 59 of 2019 delivered on February 7, 2020, the Court found the appellant could not be faulted for serving the notice as it was and that the two days' delay was sufficiently explained and non-prejudicial. Issues already dealt with in that ruling cannot be re-litigated by a fresh application; the remedy of an aggrieved party lies elsewhere. However, the third issue - whether an appeal lies from a decision made on an Originating Summons - was not substantially in issue in the stay application and was therefore dealt with on its merits in this judgment.

p. 5

Legal principles established

#
  • A Notice of Appeal that has been filed but not yet lodged or endorsed by the Deputy Registrar may validly be served on the party affected.
  • Execution of a decree under appeal does not bar the aggrieved party's right of appeal; payment of the decretal sum does not deprive a party of the right of appeal.
  • A decision made on an Originating Summons that finally and on the merits disposes of the suit is a decree appealable as of right under Section 66 of the Civil Procedure Act, without leave.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Motion dated November 15, 2018 is dismissed
  2. 2.Costs of the application to the Respondent

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2010Rule 75
  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2010Rule 77(1) (and Rule 77 generally)
  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2010Rule 83
  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2010Rule 84
  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2010Rule 76(1)
  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2010Rule 74
  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2022Rule 79(1)
  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2022Rule 86
  • Civil Procedure ActSection 66
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 37 Rule 7
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 39

Cases cited (10)

  • Salama Beach Hotel Ltd & 3 others vs. Kenyariri & Associates
    [2016] eKLR
  • Postal Corporation of Kenya vs. Kamconsult Limited & Another
    Civil Appeal No 42 of 2003
  • Kenya Commercial Bank Limited vs. Tony Manaseh Esipaya
    Civil Appeal No 105 of 1998
  • Machakos District Co-Operative Ltd. vs. Nzuki Kiilu
    Civil Application No Nai 17 of 1997
  • M Mwenesi vs. Shirley Luckhurst & another
    Civil Application No Nai. 170 of 2000
  • Kenya Industrial Estates Ltd vs. Transland Shoe Manufacturers Ltd. & 2 Others
    Civil Application No Nai. 364 of 1999
  • Gulamhussein Noormohamed Cassam & another v Shashikant Ramji Sachania & another
    1 KAR 24
  • Shital Bimal Shah & 2 Others Vs. Akiba Bank Limited
    [2006] 2 EA 323
  • Ishmael Ithongo v Geofirey Ithongo Thindiu
    Civil Appeal No 37 of 1980
  • Roy Shipping SA and Others v Dodoma Fishing Co. Ltd (1)
    [1995-1998] 1 EA 293
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya (ELC, Mombasa)
Jurisdiction invoked
Rules 75, 77(1), 83 and 84 of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2010

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Hanos (K) Ltd v Shah (Civil Application 110 of 2018) [2023] KECA 935 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2023). Civil Application No. E006 of 2021 (Motion dated November 15, 2018). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2023/935/eng@2023-07-28

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.