Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealPartially AllowedCivil Appeal No. 33 of 2019 (Lead) & Civil Appeal No. 148 of 2019· [2022] KECA 25 (KLR)

Wadhwa (As Legal Representative of the Estate of Deshpal Omprakash Wadhwa) v Mohamed & 4 others (Civil Appeal 33 & 148 of 2019 (Consolidated)) [2022] KECA 25 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
21 January 2022
5,129 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~21 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal ruled that judges must hear a party before ruling against them, and set aside orders dismissing a request to add more evidence.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Court of Appeal at Mombasa (Kairu, Nyamweya and Lesiit, JJ.A) consolidated Civil Appeal No. 33 of 2019 (lead) with Civil Appeal No. 148 of 2019, both arising from interlocutory decisions of the Environment and Land Court at Malindi (Olola, J.) in a land dispute over Kilifi/Jimba/441, in which the deceased proprietor sought cancellation of two excised titles. The first impugned decision of 5th February 2019 declined the Appellant's oral application for leave to file an additional list and bundle of documents and expunged them; the second, of 15th October 2019, summarily dispensed with the Appellant's Notice of Motion dated 6th March 2019 seeking leave to file additional documents, reopen the case and recall the Land Registrar. The Court framed three issues: whether the trial judge exercised his discretion judicially, whether the Notice of Appeal challenged the correct order, and what remedies should issue. It held that the judge mistook an application for leave to file additional documents for an adjournment application, and that dispensing with the application of 6th March 2019 without hearing it breached Articles 48 and 50(1) of the Constitution. The Court rejected the Respondents' contention that the appeal should have targeted the 19th September 2019 order, finding that order could not have applied to the application of 6th March 2019. Relying on Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co, Peters v Sunday Post, Smith v New South Wales as adopted in Simba Telecom, Joginder Auto Service, and the Supreme Court's principles in the Mohamed Abdi Mahamud consolidation, the Court confirmed that courts may admit additional evidence even after a case is concluded but before judgment. It allowed both appeals, set aside both impugned orders, and remitted the application of 6th March 2019 for hearing on merit before any other judge except Olola, J. No costs order was made.

Key legal issues

#
01

Misapprehension of the application by the trial judge

Holding

The trial judge mistook an application for leave to file additional documents for an adjournment application and failed to apply the correct test, falling into error.

Reasoning

The record showed counsel sought leave to deem additional documents properly on record. The judge instead treated it as an adjournment application and refused it on grounds of the case's age and alleged ambush, without considering whether the Appellant had shown due diligence and lack of knowledge of the evidence. That misdirection was fatal to the order of 5th February 2019, which this Court set aside.

p. 7
02

Summary dispensation of a pending application without hearing

Holding

A judge has no power to dispense summarily with a properly listed application without hearing it; doing so violates the fair-hearing guarantees of Articles 48 and 50(1).

Reasoning

The application dated 6th March 2019 was fixed for hearing on 15th October 2019 by consent and all parties appeared ready to proceed. The judge nonetheless declared it dispensed with on the strength of the earlier 19th September order, which could not have applied to it. This constituted two errors: wrongly finding the application already dispensed with, and making an adverse order without hearing the party, contrary to the constitutional right of access to justice and fair hearing.

p. 7
03

Correct order appealed against

Holding

Where a judge's later order (15th October 2019) is the operative one affecting a party's application, a Notice of Appeal against that order is properly directed even if an earlier order (19th September 2019) is mentioned.

Reasoning

On 19th September 2019 what was listed were the 5th Respondent's application of 5th August 2019 and the Appellant's application of 16th September 2019, not the application of 6th March 2019, whose hearing had been fixed by consent for 15th October 2019. The Respondents' argument that the Appellant should have appealed the 19th September order therefore failed, and the objection on jurisdiction based on absence of a Notice of Appeal against that date was rejected.

p. 6
04

Powers on reopening and additional evidence after close of a party's case

Holding

Courts have power under Section 146(4) of the Evidence Act and Rule 29(1) of the Court of Appeal Rules to permit recall of witnesses and adduction of additional evidence even where the case has been concluded but before judgment.

Reasoning

Drawing on the Australian authority Smith v New South Wales as adopted in Simba Telecom in Uganda, and the Supreme Court's principles in the Mohamed Abdi Mahamud consolidation, the Court confirmed that additional evidence may be admitted in exceptional circumstances judged case by case, subject to relevance, diligence, credibility, absence of prejudice and proportionality. The fact that a defence hearing had commenced or the case concluded does not extinguish the discretion.

p. 9
05

Remedy on appeal

Holding

The appropriate remedy was to set aside both impugned orders and remit the application of 6th March 2019 for hearing on merit before another judge other than Olola, J.

Reasoning

Since the Appellant's applications had not been properly considered at all, the Court did not itself determine the additional-evidence question on the merits. Instead it set aside the orders of 5th February 2019 and 15th October 2019 and remitted the pending application for fresh hearing before a different judge, preserving the fairness of the retrial determination while respecting the ELC's original jurisdiction.

p. 10

Legal principles established

#
  • A court must not make an adverse order against a party without hearing them; the right to be heard in a fair and public hearing is a fundamental right under Article 50(1) of the Constitution.
  • An application for leave to file additional documents must be tested against whether the party showed the evidence could not, with due diligence, have been produced earlier - not treated as an adjournment application.
  • Courts retain the power to allow adduction of additional evidence and to recall witnesses, even where the case has been concluded, so long as it is before judgment; the expiry of a hearing does not defeat such an application.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The ELC order by Olola, J. dated 5th February 2019 declining the Appellant's oral application for leave to file additional list and bundle of documents, and the order of 15th October 2019 dispensing with the hearing of the Appellant's Notice of Motion dated 6th March 2019, be and are hereby set aside
  2. 2.The application dated 6th March 2019 be and is hereby sent back to the Environment and Land Court for hearing and determination on merit before any other Judge except Olola, J.

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 48
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 50(1)
  • Appellate Jurisdiction ActSection 3(2)
  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2010Rule 31
  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2010Rule 29(1)
  • Court of Appeal Rules, 2010Rule 84
  • Evidence ActSection 146(4) and 146(7)
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 11

Cases cited (18)

  • Joginder Auto Service Ltd v Mohammed Shaffique & Another
    [2001] eKLR
  • NSG VS SCG
    [2014] eKLR
  • Raindrops Limited VS County Government of Kilifi
    [2020] eKLR
  • Rubina Ahmed & 3 Others v Guardian Bank Ltd & 3 Others
    (2019) eKLR
  • Hannah Wairimu Ngethe VS Francis Mungai Ng'ang'a & another
    [2018] eKLR
  • Kenya Power & Lighting Company Ltd VS Karuri Hotels Ltd & another
    [2002] eKLR
  • Alex Muchira Mwangi VS Jade Mugure Mwaura
    [2017] eKLR
  • Manchester Outfitters Limited v Pravin Galot & 4 Others
    (2020) eKLR
  • Christopher Kanai Kamu & 4 Others v Kenya Forest Services & 4 Others
    (2018) eKLR
  • Selle & Another v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd. & others
    (1968) EA 123
  • Peters vs. Sunday Post Limited
    [1958] EA 424
  • Samuel Kiti Lewa Vs Housing Finance Co. Of Kenya Ltd
    [2015] eKLR
  • Simba Telecom –V- Karuhanga & Anor
    (2014) UGHC 98
  • Smith versus- New South Wales
    [1992] HCA 36; [1992] 176 CLR 256
  • Mzee Wanjie & 93 Others v. Saikwa & Others
    (1982-88) 1 KAR. 462
  • Edgar Ogechi & 12 Others v. University of Eastern Africa, Baraton
    (Civil Appeal (Application) 130 of 1997) (unreported)
  • Karmali Mohamed & Another v. Z. H. Lakhani & Company
    [1958] EA. 567
  • Hon. Mohamed Abdi Mahamud v Ahmed Abdullahi Mohamad & 3 others
    Petition 7 of 2018 consolidated with Petition 9 of 2018
On appeal from
Environment and Land Court at Malindi
Civil Suit 51 of 2012
Jurisdiction invoked
Section 3(2) of the Appellate Jurisdiction Act; Rule 31 of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2010 (first appellate jurisdiction over interlocutory decisions of the ELC)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Wadhwa (As Legal Representative of the Estate of Deshpal Omprakash Wadhwa) v Mohamed & 4 others (Civil Appeal 33 & 148 of 2019 (Consolidated)) [2022] KECA 25 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2022). Civil Appeal No. 33 of 2019 (Lead) & Civil Appeal No. 148 of 2019. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2022/25/eng@2022-01-21

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.