Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealDismissedCivil Appeal No. 266 of 2015· [2019] KECA 1045 (KLR)

Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen, Herman Philipus Steyn (also known as Hermannus Phillipus Steyn) & Hedda Steyn

Court of Appeal
25 January 2019
5,797 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~23 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This Court of Appeal judgment arises from a ruling of the High Court (J. Kamau, J) which declined Nguruman Limited's application to strike out Jan Bonde Nielsen's Plaint in HCCC No. 332 of 2010, a suit claiming a declaration of a partnership arrangement, lifting of the appellant's corporate veil, and transfer of 50% of its shares on constructive trust. The appellant argued that fresh evidence from UK bankruptcy proceedings showed the 1st respondent had admitted holding no legal or beneficial interest in any Kenyan asset, and that he had inconsistently shifted between suing personally and as agent of family trusts without authority, rendering the suit an abuse of process for want of locus standii. The High Court held that the standing question went to the merits and could not be resolved at an interlocutory stage. Dismissing the appeal, the Court of Appeal, applying Mbogo v Shah, held that the judge rightly exercised her discretion. It held that a question of locus standii not plain and obvious on the pleadings cannot be determined on a striking-out application, since doing so would require a trial within a trial on untested affidavit evidence. Adopting the English authority of Jason Pickthall, the Court formulated a three-part test for abuse of process based on lack of standing: the claimant must lack standing, know of the lack, and sue knowing he is the wrong claimant. It distinguished Pickthall, finding it could not be said with certainty that the 1st respondent knew the cause of action vested elsewhere. The appeal was dismissed with costs to the 1st respondent.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether locus standii can be determined on a striking-out application

Holding

No, where the answer is not plain and obvious; determining it would require interrogation of contested affidavit evidence amounting to a trial within a trial.

Reasoning

The court held that the question of the 1st respondent's standing was intrinsically tied to the substantive claim of a constructive trust and joint venture. Ascertainment of whether he personally advanced monies, whether he was a trustee or nominee, and whether the bankruptcy declarations negated standing would require evidence tested under cross-examination, which is beyond the remit of an interlocutory striking-out application.

p. 5
02

Whether the suit was an abuse of the court process for want of locus standii

Holding

No; it cannot be said with certainty that the 1st respondent knew he was the wrong claimant, so abuse is not established at this stage.

Reasoning

Applying the three-part criteria drawn from Jason Pickthall, the court distinguished that case: Pickthall knew from the outset, having been adjudicated bankrupt, that the cause of action vested in the Official Trustee. Here it is yet to be authoritatively established that the 1st respondent knew the cause of action belonged elsewhere; a finding of abuse can only follow such a finding.

p. 6
03

Whether the learned judge erred in declining to determine locus standii as a preliminary issue

Holding

No; the judge rightly declined and rightly ordered the suit to proceed to hearing on a priority basis.

Reasoning

Guided by Mbogo v Shah, the Court found no basis to interfere with the discretion exercised below. It was untenable for the judge to delve into the merits of the suit, which were the preserve of the trial court; her refusal to determine the standing question one way or the other was therefore proper.

p. 6

Legal principles established

#
  • A finding of abuse of process for want of locus standii requires that the claimant lacked standing, knew of the lack, and instituted the suit knowing they were the wrong claimant; where knowledge cannot be established with certainty, abuse is not made out.
  • A question of locus standii that is not plain and obvious on the face of the pleadings cannot be determined on a striking-out application; it must be left to trial.
  • An appellate court will not interfere with the exercise of a trial judge's discretion unless the judge misdirected himself or was clearly wrong, resulting in misjustice.
  • A plaintiff is entitled to pursue a claim however implausible unless the defendant demonstrates shortly and conclusively that the claim is bound to fail or is an abuse of process.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The appeal is dismissed with costs to the 1st respondent

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure Actsections 1A, 1B, 3, 3A
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 2 rule 15(1)(b), (c) & (d)
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 51 rules 1 and 3
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 31 rule 1

Cases cited (8)

  • DT Dobie & Co (Kenya) Ltd vs Muchina
    [1982] eKLR

    Caution in dismissing a suit for abuse of process without embarking on a trial of the merits

  • Alfred Njau vs Nairobi City Council
    [1983] KLR 625

    Distinction between locus standii and cause of action (cited by counsel)

  • Jason Pickthall vs Dickinson & another
    [2009] EWCA Civ 543

    Proceedings started knowing the cause of action is vested in another are an abuse of process

  • Mbogo vs Shah
    [1968] EA 93

    Appellate restraint in interfering with a trial judge's exercise of discretion

  • Crescent Construction Co Ltd vs Delphis Bank Limited
    [2007] eKLR

    Power to strike out pleadings is discretionary and must be exercised with great care and caution

  • Muchanga Investments Ltd vs Safaris Unlimited (Africa) Ltd and 2 Others
    [2009] eKLR

    Definition of abuse of the court process

  • Rajesh Pathania vs Edmond Adefolu Adedeji & others
    (2014) EWCA Civ 681

    Proceedings may not be abuse where claimant is uncertain of title to the cause of action

  • Yaya Towers Limited vs Trade Bank Limited (In Liquidation)
    Civil Appeal No. 35 of 2000

    A plaintiff may pursue a claim however implausible unless the defendant shows shortly and conclusively it is bound to fail

On appeal from
High Court of Kenya at Milimani Commercial Court
HCCC No. 332 of 2010
Jurisdiction invoked
First appellate jurisdiction over the High Court (ruling in HCCC No. 332 of 2010); no specific constitutional provision invoked

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (1)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Nguruman Limited v Jan Bonde Nielsen, Herman Philipus Steyn (also known as Hermannus Phillipus Steyn) & Hedda Steyn", Case Analysis (2019). Civil Appeal No. 266 of 2015. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2019/1045/eng@2019-01-25

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.