Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealPartially AllowedCivil Appeal No. 34 of 2011· [2019] KECA 820 (KLR)

David Harris v Middle East Bank Kenya Limited & 3 others [2019] KECA 820 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
8 March 2019
6,560 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~26 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal freed a guarantor from liability because the bank granted a bigger loan behind his back and lost the guarantee documents.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Court of Appeal (Warsame, M'Inoti and Murgor, JJ.A) allowed a first appeal by David Harris against a High Court judgment (Kimaru, J, 29th October 2010) in which the Bank had recovered Kshs 27,373,081 jointly and severally from the principal debtor, Kilifi Air Charters Limited, its directors, and Harris on personal guarantees, with interest reduced from the contracted 26% to 18% per annum simple. The Bank had advanced Kshs 10,000,000 in two tranches in 1995 and 1996, secured by a Charge and Further Charge over land and by personal guarantees. The Court framed six issues: proof of the debt, credit for a Kshs 2,500,000 payment, whether the Bank had to sell the charged land first, the interest rate, the existence of two guarantees, and discharge of the guarantor. It held the debt proved on a balance of probabilities; that the Kshs 2,500,000 paid in March 2001 fell outside the pleaded debt; that the land, occupied by squatters, could not be sold, so the Bank could call on the guarantees first; and that the trial court had jurisdiction to reduce the unconscionable 26% rate. Critically, the Court found the Bank failed to prove a second guarantee signed by Harris - only a photostat copy of a lost original was produced - and, applying Holme v Brunskill, held that the unconsented additional facility which increased the debt and extended repayment time discharged Harris even from the initial guarantee. The appeal was allowed with costs. The judgment binds subordinate courts on the discharge of guarantors by unconsented variations and on the weight to be accorded secondary evidence of lost documents.

Key legal issues

#
01

Proof of the outstanding debt

Holding

The Bank proved on a balance of probabilities that the principal debtor owed the sums claimed through bank statements and testimony of disbursements; the discrepancy between the amount demanded in the demand and the plaint did not defeat the claim.

Reasoning

The Court evaluated the bank statements for the loan and overdraft accounts showing disbursements and outstanding balances, and the testimony of the Bank's Executive Director. Since the facilities were applied for, disbursed in two tranches, and repayment was not demonstrated, the burden of proof was discharged. The appellant did not contend that the principal debtor had repaid the loan, so the discrepancy in demanded amounts was not fatal.

p. 4
02

Admissibility and weight of secondary evidence of a lost second personal guarantee

Holding

The Bank failed to prove the existence of a second personal guarantee signed by the appellant; a photostat copy, without proof the original was ever in the Bank's possession, was insufficient on a balance of probabilities.

Reasoning

Applying sections 66, 67 and 68 of the Evidence Act and the Springsteen approach that weight of secondary evidence is a matter for the court in all the circumstances, the Court held that because the existence of the second guarantee was the central dispute, the Bank had to show the original was in its possession but untraceable. It did not, and the surrounding loan documentation bore only the signatures of the 3rd and 4th respondents.

p. 6
03

Discharge of the guarantor by variation of the guaranteed facility

Holding

The additional facility, granted without the appellant's knowledge or consent, increased the debt and extended repayment time, materially varying the arrangement and discharging the appellant even from the initial guarantee.

Reasoning

Relying on Halsbury's Laws and Holme v Brunskill, and this Court's decision in Cooperative Bank of Kenya v Washington Otieno Ogindo, the Court found the Further Charge increased the aggregate borrowing to Kshs 10,000,000 and extended time, all behind the guarantor's back. A guarantor cannot be held liable for transactions carried out without his privity; the conduct of the Bank, principal debtor and the 3rd and 4th respondents discharged the appellant.

p. 7
04

Whether the Bank was obliged to realise the charged land before calling on the guarantees

Holding

No. The charged land was invaded by squatters and could not be sold, so the Bank could call on the personal guarantees ahead of its other remedies.

Reasoning

The Court accepted the trial judge's finding that squatters occupied the land and no buyer was willing to purchase, rendering sale of the subdivided plots impossible. In these peculiar circumstances the Bank was left with no option but to resort to the directors' personal guarantees in lieu of its rights of redemption over the charged property.

p. 4
05

Interest rate

Holding

The interest rate was agreed in the letters of offer, but the High Court had jurisdiction to reduce the unconscionable 26% rate to 18% simple interest, a decision the Court of Appeal declined to disturb.

Reasoning

The letters of offer specified 26% and 30% per annum, defeating the contention that the rate was never agreed. However, citing Halsbury's Laws on relief against harsh and unconscionable transactions, the Court confirmed the trial judge's jurisdiction to interfere with the oppressive rate and found no reason to interfere with the reduction to 18% per annum simple interest.

p. 5
06

The Kshs 2,500,000 payment

Holding

The Kshs 2,500,000 paid on 19th March 2001 fell outside the debt as claimed and computed at the date of filing suit, and remains to be computed into the outstanding balance.

Reasoning

The trial judge did not address this payment. The Bank's witness confirmed the sum was received by the Bank's advocate on 19th March 2001, after the suit was filed on 31st August 1999. Since the payment post-dated the pleaded debt, it could not have been computed within the amount claimed and remains an amount yet to be computed into the outstanding balance.

p. 4

Legal principles established

#
  • A guarantor who was not privy to, and did not consent to, a variation of the guaranteed facility that increases the debt and extends time for repayment is discharged from the guarantee.
  • A court has jurisdiction to interfere with a harsh and unconscionable contractual interest rate even absent duress or undue influence.
  • On a first appeal, the appellate court must re-evaluate the whole evidence afresh but accord due respect to the factual findings of the trial court.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The appeal against the appellant is allowed with costs
  2. 2.The appellant is discharged from the initial personal guarantee and the further liability created by the Bank, the principal debtor and the 3rd and 4th respondents

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Evidence ActSection 67
  • Evidence ActSection 68
  • Evidence ActSection 66

Cases cited (15)

  • Susan Munyi vs Keshar Shiani
    Civil Appeal No. 38 of 2002
  • Captain Harry Gandy vs Casper Air Charters Limited
    (1955) EACA 139
  • Kenyenga vs Ombwori
    Civil Appeal No. 96 of 1998 KLR 103
  • Harilal & Company Advocates vs The Standard Bank Limited
    Civil Appeal No 41 of 1966
  • Kenya National Capital Corporation vs Thamo Holdings Limited & Another
    HCCC 1501 of 1985
  • Daima Bank Limited vs Osmond
    Civil Appeal No 82 of 1998
  • Peter Muriithi Ngatia vs Kenya Commercial Bank Limited
    HCCC No 675 of 1999
  • Kenya Commercial Bank Limited vs Peter Muriithi Ngatia
    Civil Appeal No 310 of 2000
  • Kenindia Assurance vs Commercial Bank of Africa
    null
  • China and South Sea Bank vs Tan
    (1989) 3 All ER 838
  • Masquarade Music Limited and others vs Springsteen
    [2001] EWCA Civ 563
  • Holme vs Brunskill
    (1878) 3 QBD 495
  • Rees vs Berringtom
    null
  • Marubeni Hong Kong and South China Ltd vs Government of Mongolia
    [2004] All ER (D) 257
  • Cooperative Bank of Kenya vs Washington Otieno Ogindo
    [2012] eKLR
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya, Milimani Commercial Courts, Nairobi
Civil Suit No. 1198 of 1999
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal to the Court of Appeal under the appellate jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal (the judgment states 'This is a first appeal'); no specific constitutional/statutory article is quoted in the judgment.

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (5)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "David Harris v Middle East Bank Kenya Limited & 3 others [2019] KECA 820 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Civil Appeal No. 34 of 2011. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2019/820/eng@2019-03-08

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.