Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealAllowedCivil Appeal No. 62 of 2007· [2018] KECA 836 (KLR)

Denis Costello Doyle & Phoenix of EA Assurance Co Ltd v Diamond Trust Bank (K) Ltd & Peter Mailanyi

Court of Appeal
16 February 2018
3,590 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~14 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal ruled that an insurer cannot be forced to pay a decree that no longer exists, and vague statements don't count as legal admissions.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This appeal arose from a 1994 road accident in which Peter Mailanyi, an advocate, obtained a High Court decree of Kshs. 3,266,674 against Denis Costello Doyle, his driver, and Diamond Trust Bank, the financier and registered co-owner of the lorry involved. In execution, the Bank paid Kshs. 4,083,052 to avoid attachment. The Court of Appeal later set aside that judgment, finding Mailanyi had proved neither injuries nor losses. The Bank then sued Mailanyi, Doyle and Phoenix Assurance to recover the sum it had paid. Emukule, J. struck out the defences of Doyle and Phoenix, holding that under section 10(1) of the Insurance (Motor Vehicle Third Party Risks) Act they were ultimately liable to Mailanyi, and entered judgment for the Bank with interest at 36% and 30% per annum for different periods. Allowing the appeal, this Court held that the appellants' averment that the Bank paid the decree was not a plain and unequivocal admission of liability, and that their defence raised bona fide triable issues entitling them to unconditional leave to defend. Critically, the Court held that a subsisting judgment against the insured is a condition precedent to insurer liability under section 10(1); the decree having been set aside, Phoenix could not be compelled to satisfy it, and Mailanyi, the wrongful executor and beneficiary of the payment, was the party obliged to repay the Bank. The Court set aside the ruling as against the appellants, declined to determine the remaining issues, and directed the appellants and the Bank to bear their own costs. Mailanyi, who did not appeal, remains liable under the ruling as it relates to him.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether judgment on admission was properly entered against the appellants

Holding

It was not; the appellants' averment that the Bank paid the decree was not an unequivocal admission of the Bank's claim, as they disputed liability on several grounds.

Reasoning

The Court held that admission of the fact of payment is not admission of liability. The appellants' defence and replying affidavit raised matters such as joint judgment, the auctioneer's decision to execute, absence of agreement to pay, and lack of cause of action. Such an admission was not plain and obvious as required by Choitram v. Nazari and could not sustain judgment on admission.

p. 5
02

Whether striking out the appellants' defence was justified

Holding

It was not; the defence raised bona fide triable issues which had to go to trial.

Reasoning

Applying Dhanjal Investments and the settled summary judgment jurisprudence, the Court held that a defence raising a bona fide triable issue entitles a defendant to unconditional leave to defend. The contention that there was no subsisting judgment against Doyle, hence no insurer liability under section 10(1), was a strong triable issue the judge was obliged to allow to proceed to trial.

p. 5
03

Whether Phoenix could be compelled under section 10(1) to refund money paid under a decree later set aside

Holding

No; the judgment having been set aside, the condition precedent for insurer liability could not be satisfied, and Mailanyi, the beneficiary of the payment, was the person obliged to repay the Bank.

Reasoning

The Court held that section 10(1) requires a subsisting judgment against the insured before an insurer can be called to pay. The Court of Appeal had set aside Mailanyi's judgment on 30th June 2000; by the date of the High Court ruling the decree no longer existed. Mailanyi, who had wrongfully attached the Bank's property and received the money, was the party responsible for repayment.

p. 6

Legal principles established

#
  • An admission relied on for judgment on admission must be plain, clear and unequivocal; admissions of a payment do not amount to an admission of liability on the whole claim.
  • Once a bona fide triable issue is raised, the defendant is entitled to unconditional leave to defend; the court has no discretion to deny a defence.
  • Under section 10(1) of the Insurance (Motor Vehicle Third Party Risks) Act, a subsisting judgment against the insured is a condition precedent to the insurer's liability to satisfy a decree.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Appeal allowed
  2. 2.Ruling dated 16th January 2006 set aside as far as it relates to the appellants
  3. 3.Appellants and the Bank to bear their own costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Insurance (Motor Vehicle Third Party Risks) Actsection 10(1)
  • Civil Procedure Actsection 91(2)
  • Civil Procedure Actsection 26
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 12 rule 6

Cases cited (7)

  • Choitram v. Nazari
    [1984] KLR 327

    Admissions relied on for judgment on admission must be plain and obvious, leaving no room for doubt.

  • Dhanjal Investments Ltd v. Shabaha Investments Ltd
    CA. No. 232 of 1997

    A defendant showing a bona fide triable issue must be allowed to defend without conditions.

  • Kandlal Restaurant v. Devshi & Company
    [1952] EACA 77

    Early authority that a bona fide triable issue entitles a defendant to defend.

  • Souza Figuerido & Company Ltd v. Mooring Hotel Ltd
    [1959] EA 425

    Followed Kandlal on the entitlement to defend where a triable issue is shown.

  • Kenya Trade Combine Ltd v Shah
    CA. No. 193 of 1999

    A triable issue need not be a defence that must succeed on trial.

  • Momanyi v. Hatimy & Another
    [2003] 2 EA 600

    Once a bona fide triable issue is raised, defendant is entitled to unconditional leave to defend.

  • Moule v. Garette
    [1872] LR 104

    Cited by the Bank for restitution where a party pays a decree under compulsion of law.

On appeal from
High Court of Kenya
HCCC No. 177 of 2002
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal to the Court of Appeal under the Court of Appeal's appellate jurisdiction (appeal from High Court ruling)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Denis Costello Doyle & Phoenix of EA Assurance Co Ltd v Diamond Trust Bank (K) Ltd & Peter Mailanyi", Case Analysis (2018). Civil Appeal No. 62 of 2007. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2018/836/eng@2018-02-16

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.