Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealDismissedElection Petition Appeal No. 11 of 2018· [2018] KECA 446 (KLR)

Hassan Aden Osman v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) & 2 others [2018] KECA 446 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
20 July 2018
12,417 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~50 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal dismissed an attempt to overturn the Mandera North senatorial election, confirming that proved irregularities must affect results before elections are nullified.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Court of Appeal (Ouko, P., Makhandia and M'inoti, JJ.A) dismissed an appeal by Hassan Aden Osman against the High Court's dismissal (Tuiyott, J., judgment of 26 February 2018) of his petition challenging the election of Mahamed Maalim Mahamud as Senator for Mandera North Constituency in the 8 August 2017 elections. The appellant had pleaded irregular replacement of presiding and deputy presiding officers, relocation of polling stations, transportation of materials by police, non-use of KIEMS Kits, double voting, ballot stuffing, unrealistic voter turnout, assisted-voting irregularities and voting beyond 5 p.m. The High Court dismissed the petition after scrutiny and recount in 11 polling stations, which reduced the 3rd respondent's votes by 2,165 but left a residual gap of 6,033 votes. On appeal, the court first held that although 43 of the 50 grounds were framed as errors 'in law and fact' contrary to section 85A of the Elections Act, poor drafting does not oust jurisdiction, and it isolated five questions of law using the Munya guidelines. It found the trial court's evidential findings not perverse, affirmed the intermediate standard of proof and the petitioner's legal burden, held that Forms 38A signed by deputy presiding officers are valid under Regulation 5(4), and held that disregarding polling station results with excess votes is a legitimate exercise of the nullification test and not disenfranchisement. The appeal was dismissed with costs: the 1st and 2nd respondents awarded High Court costs capped at Kshs. 500,000 each, the 3rd respondent Kshs. 1,500,000, and the appellant to pay each respondent Kshs. 1,000,000 for the appeal. The High Court judgment was affirmed in full.

Key legal issues

#
01

Admissibility of grounds of appeal expressed as errors 'in law and fact' under section 85A of the Elections Act

Holding

Poor drafting does not oust the court's jurisdiction; the court will isolate conclusions of law from conclusions of fact using the Munya principles, though such drafting is improper and burdens the court.

Reasoning

Section 85A confers appellate jurisdiction on matters of law only. Although 43 of 50 grounds began 'the learned trial Judge erred both in law and fact', jurisdiction conferred by statute cannot be lost through poor pleading. The court applied the Supreme Court's Munya guidelines distinguishing questions of law and urged counsel to comply with Rule 86(1) of the Court of Appeal Rules requiring concise, distinct grounds.

p. 7
02

Whether the trial court erred in finding no proof of illegal replacement of presiding officers, non-use of KIEMS Kits, double voting and ballot stuffing, and voting beyond 5 p.m.

Holding

These were questions of fact; the trial court's conclusions were based on evidence and not so perverse that no reasonable tribunal would reach them, so the appeal court cannot interfere.

Reasoning

Within the Munya framework, an appellate court may only interfere where conclusions rest on no evidence or are so perverse that no reasonable tribunal would reach them. The trial judge, who saw and heard the witnesses, gave detailed reasons for rejecting the allegations; only two of 46 alleged replaced officers testified, no victim of double voting testified, and no expert basis was laid for questioning high voter turnout. Missing SD cards were not pleaded and the interference with ballot boxes occurred after declaration of results.

p. 10
03

Burden and standard of proof in election petitions

Holding

The appellant bore the burden at an intermediate standard; the trial judge correctly stated and applied the principles and did not misapply them.

Reasoning

Section 107 of the Evidence Act places the burden on the petitioner; section 83 of the Elections Act creates a rebuttable presumption that declared results are correct. Where a petitioner adduces sufficient evidence, the evidential burden shifts to the respondent. The trial judge correctly stated the intermediate standard and correctly held that the burden shifted only upon cogent evidence of replacement of trained officers, which was not discharged.

p. 3
04

Validity of Forms 38A signed by deputy presiding officers

Holding

Such forms are valid; Regulation 5(4) of the Elections (General) Regulations, 2012 allows a deputy presiding officer to perform any act of a presiding officer.

Reasoning

The court relied on Regulation 5(4) and Regulation 79 and endorsed the Chikati decision holding that a statutory form is valid once signed by the presiding officer, the deputy presiding officer, or either of them. Submissions that the deputy may act only where the presiding officer is 'legally not available' were inconsistent with the clear regulatory provision.

p. 12
05

Whether disregarding results of polling stations with excess votes disenfranchised voters

Holding

It did not; the election court may disregard such results under Regulation 83(1) and section 80(1)(d), and the trial judge was justified in doing so where results were unverifiable.

Reasoning

Regulation 83(1)(b) and (c) permit disregard of results where votes exceed registered voters or turnout; the court held the election court possesses the same power under section 80(1)(d). The right to vote under Article 38 is not absolute and is subject to reasonable restrictions; disregarding unverifiable results is not disenfranchisement but a legitimate exercise of the nullification test under section 83.

p. 6

Legal principles established

#
  • Under section 85A of the Elections Act, the Court of Appeal may hear election petition appeals on matters of law only, but a poorly drafted memorandum does not oust jurisdiction; the court may isolate questions of law from questions of fact using the Munya guidelines.
  • An election will only be nullified where non-compliance or irregularities are of such magnitude that they affected the result or so negatively impacted the integrity of the election that no reasonable tribunal would uphold it.
  • The legal burden of proof in an election petition rests on the petitioner, at an intermediate standard above balance of probability but below beyond reasonable doubt, unless criminal allegations are made, in which case the criminal standard applies.
  • A declaration form (Form 38A) is validly signed by either the presiding officer or the deputy presiding officer, since Regulation 5(4) permits a deputy presiding officer to perform any act a presiding officer is required or authorized to perform.
  • An election court may, pursuant to section 80(1)(d) of the Elections Act and Regulation 83(1), disregard the results of a polling station where the total valid votes exceed the number of registered voters or the number of voters who turned out, and doing so is not disenfranchisement.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Appeal dismissed in its entirety
  2. 2.1st and 2nd respondents awarded High Court costs capped at Kshs. 500,000 each
  3. 3.3rd respondent awarded High Court costs of Kshs. 1,500,000
  4. 4.Appellant to pay each of the respondents Kshs. 1,000,000 costs of the appeal

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 86
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 38 (38(1), 38(3)(b))
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 81(e)
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 25
  • Elections ActSection 83
  • Elections ActSection 85A
  • Elections ActSection 82
  • Elections ActSection 80(1)(d)
  • Evidence ActSection 107
  • Evidence ActSection 108
  • Evidence ActSection 109
  • Evidence ActSection 112
  • Elections (General) Regulations, 2012Regulation 5 (5(4))
  • Elections (General) Regulations, 2012Regulation 79
  • Elections (General) Regulations, 2012Regulation 66
  • Elections (General) Regulations, 2012Regulation 77
  • Elections (General) Regulations, 2012Regulation 83(1) (83(1)(b), (c), (d))
  • Court of Appeal RulesRule 86(1)
  • Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections Petition) Rules, 2017Rule 16

Cases cited (12)

  • Samuel Kamau Macharia & Another v Kenya Commercial Bank & 2 Others
    Application No. 2 of 2011
  • SMEC Australia Pty Ltd v McConnell Dowell Constructors (Aust) Pty Ltd
    (2011) VSC 492
  • Kenya Pharmaceutical Association & Another v Nairobi City County & the 46 other County Governments & Another
    Constitutional Petition No. 97 of 2016
  • Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission and Another v Stephen Mutinda Mule and Others
    Civil Application No. 219 of 2013
  • Gatirau Peter Munya v Dickson Mwenda Kithinji & 2 Others
    [2014] eKLR
  • Wavinya Ndeti & Anor v IEBC & 2 Others
    Election Petition Appeal No. 8 of 2018
  • Sumra Irshadali Mohammed v The Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 2 Others
    Election Petition Appeal No. 22 of 2018
  • Law Society of Kenya v Centre For Human Rights And Democracy & 13 Others
    Civil Appeal No. 308 of 2012
  • Raila Odinga & Others v The Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & Others
    Supreme Court Election Petition No. 5 of 2013
  • Raila Odinga & Another v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & Others
    Supreme Court Presidential Petition No. 1 of 2017
  • John Murumba Chikati v Returning Officer Tongaren Constituency & 2 Others
  • Albeity Hassan Abdalla v The Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 3 Others
    Election Petition Appeal No. 2 of 2018
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya at Nairobi
Election Petition No. 6 of 2017
Jurisdiction invoked
Section 85A of the Elections Act (appeals from the High Court in election petitions on matters of law only)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Hassan Aden Osman v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) & 2 others [2018] KECA 446 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2018). Election Petition Appeal No. 11 of 2018. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2018/446/eng@2018-07-20

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.