Eswari Electricals (PVT) Limited v Empower Installation Limited & another [2017] KECA 739 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Court of Appeal ruled that courts can only force a defendant to deposit security if there's real evidence of asset-dissipation—not mere suspicion.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether an order for security could rest on order 40 rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules
Order 40 rule 11 was inapplicable because the 1st respondent never claimed the appellant held money as trustee for it, nor did the appellant admit holding money for it; the Judge also failed to express any view on the provision
The application invoked order 40 rule 11, which applies only where a party admits holding money or property as trustee for another or that it is due to another. The 1st respondent made no such claim and the appellant made no such admission. The Judge was addressed on the provision but expressed no view on it, and instead decided the matter on order 39 rule 5 without saying so, deciding a basis neither pleaded nor argued.
Whether the conditions precedent under order 39 rule 5 for an order of security were satisfied
The conditions were not met: there was no evidence that the appellant was about to dispose of or remove property from the jurisdiction with intent to obstruct or delay execution of a decree
Order 39 rule 5 requires proof, by affidavit or otherwise, that a defendant with intent to obstruct or delay execution is about to dispose of or remove property from the jurisdiction. The Judge instead found a flight risk from the appellant's failure to disclose the bank account receiving payments and its foreign status. That unfairly shifted the burden of proof to the appellant and involved consideration of irrelevant matters, leading to a wrong conclusion unsupported by evidence of any preparation to leave.
The nature and purpose of an order for security for a prospective decree (the Mareva-type relief)
Security for a claim before judgment is a means of preventing a defendant from dissipating assets or absconding so that execution of a decree is not defeated; it is grounded on the maxim that equity does not act in vain and must be granted with caution
Drawing on Lord Denning MR's exposition in The Mareva, the court explained that where a debt is due and there is danger the debtor will dispose of assets to defeat it, the court may in a proper case grant interlocutory relief to prevent dissipation. Because such orders are made before the dispute is determined on merit, the power is to be exercised with great caution and only on proper evidential foundations.
Legal principles established
#- An interlocutory application must be decided on the provisions and grounds invoked and canvassed by the parties; a judge may not base a decision on provisions not relied on or addressed
- To order a defendant to furnish security for a decree, there must be evidence that the defendant, with intent to obstruct or delay execution, is about to dispose of or remove property from the jurisdiction; a mere possibility of flight or failure to disclose a bank account is insufficient
- The power to order a party to furnish security before trial is to be exercised with great caution since the dispute has not been determined on merit
- An appellate court will interfere with a discretionary decision where the judge took into account irrelevant factors
Court orders
#- 1.The appeal is allowed with costs
- 2.The orders issued on 14th August 2014 directing the appellant to furnish security are set aside
- On appeal from
- High Court of Kenya at Nairobi, Commercial and Admiralty Division
- Civil Case No. 106 of 2013
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appellate jurisdiction under the Civil Procedure Act (appeal from the High Court)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Eswari Electricals (PVT) Limited v Empower Installation Limited & another [2017] KECA 739 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2017). Civil Appeal No. 286 of 2014. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2017/739/eng@2017-03-03
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.