Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealDismissedCivil Appeal No. 179 of 2017· [2017] KECA 439 (KLR)

Jeconia Okungu Obutu & another v Orange Democratic Movement Party & 6 others [2017] KECA 439 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
14 July 2017
3,001 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~12 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal confirmed that anyone challenging a party nomination must prove their case with evidence—irregularities only matter if they changed the result.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is an appeal to the Court of Appeal at Nairobi against the judgment of the High Court (Mwita, J) of 9th June 2017, which had allowed an appeal by Cornel Rasanga Amoth against a PPDT decision nullifying his nomination as the ODM gubernatorial candidate for Siaya County in the 8th August 2017 general elections. The two appellants, ODM members and voters, had petitioned the PPDT alleging that the 25th April 2017 nominations contravened the Constitution, the Elections Act and ODM's nomination rules - chiefly the use of the 2013 IEBC voters roll instead of the party register, disenfranchisement, and malpractices. The PPDT nullified the nomination principally because ODM failed to comply with a consent order to avail the results tally and party register. The High Court reversed, holding PPDT had shifted the burden of proof and that the appellants had not even proved party membership. The Court of Appeal, in a single judgment of the court (Githinji, Okwengu and J. Mohammed, JJ.A), affirmed the High Court. It held the appellants bore the legal burden of proving the pleaded facts, including membership and use of the unofficial register, and that the consent order did not discharge that burden, particularly as ODM was not a party to it. It further held that no irregularity was shown to have affected the result, and that the appeal served no legitimate interest, appearing to be pursued on behalf of the 4th respondent who had left the party. The appeal was dismissed with no orders as to costs. The High Court judgment stands affirmed and binds subordinate tribunals and courts on burden of proof in nomination disputes.

Key legal issues

#
01

Burden of proof in nomination disputes before PPDT

Holding

The High Court rightly found that PPDT unlawfully shifted the burden of proof to the 3rd respondent; the appellants bore the legal burden of proving all pleaded facts, including their own membership and the alleged use of the IEBC 2013 register.

Reasoning

The nullification of a nomination rests on pleaded grounds which are issues of fact. The appellants had to produce a member's card or register to prove membership, show that the 2013 IEBC register rather than the party register was used, and show a post-2013 register existed. The consent order requiring ODM to avail documents did not establish membership or shift the evidential onus, especially as the party was not party to the consent order and its non-production could not prove the appellants' case.

p. 6
02

Effect of unproven irregularities on a nomination

Holding

Allegations of malpractice and irregularities, even if supported, cannot justify nullification unless shown to have affected the result of the nomination.

Reasoning

The High Court re-evaluated the evidence and found all allegations unsubstantiated. General statements about over-voting, ballot stuffing and disenfranchisement were not elaborated or supported by tangible evidence. The Court of Appeal agreed that absent proof that irregularities affected the outcome, the nomination of the 3rd respondent could not be nullified.

p. 6
03

Legitimate interest in pursuing the appeal

Holding

The appeal served no legitimate interest: the appellants were not candidates, the unsuccessful candidates did not participate, and the appeal appeared to be pursued on behalf of the 4th respondent who had left the party.

Reasoning

The appellants did not seek nomination; the 5th and 6th respondents neither participated in the appeal nor challenged the nomination before NAT or PPDT; the 4th respondent had resigned, been nominated as an independent candidate, and lost before NAT; and the same advocates appeared for him and the appellants, supporting the inference of a surrogate appeal.

p. 6
04

Alleged incomplete record and fair hearing

Holding

The ground that the Judge relied on an incomplete record failed: the appellants could not introduce the missing documents as fresh evidence without leave, and their counsel had agreed the appeal should proceed.

Reasoning

The documents allegedly omitted were not mentioned in written submissions; the appellants never instituted proceedings to compel ODM to produce them; the documents would constitute fresh evidence requiring leave; and the record showed counsel agreed the appeal proceed, while the Judge in fact considered the replying affidavit and annexures the appellants filed.

p. 5

Legal principles established

#
  • A party challenging the validity of a nomination bears the legal burden of proving the pleaded facts, including proof of party membership and use of an unofficial register; a tribunal may not shift that burden to the candidate whose nomination is challenged.
  • A party's failure to produce documents ordered in a consent order does not relieve the petitioner of the duty to obtain and prove its case with evidence; unavailability of such documents cannot substitute for proof.
  • To warrant nullification of a nomination, irregularities must be shown to have affected the result.
  • An appeal which does not serve a legitimate interest, e.g. where the appellants never sought the nomination and appear to be pursuing another candidate's cause, will be dismissed.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The appeal is dismissed
  2. 2.No orders as to costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Political Parties Actsection 39(1)
  • Political Parties Actsection 40(1)
  • Political Parties Actsection 41(2)
  • Political Parties Actsection 41(4)
  • Elections Actsection 13
  • Elections Actsection 28
  • ODM Election and Nomination RulesRule 19.21
  • ODM Election and Nomination RulesRule 23(1)
  • ODM Election and Nomination RulesRule 23.2
  • Political Parties Regulation, 2012Regulation 20(1)
  • Evidence Act
  • Civil Procedure Act
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya at Nairobi
Election Petition No. 92 of 2017
Jurisdiction invoked
Section 41(2) of the Political Parties Act - appeal to the Court of Appeal from PPDT decisions lies on points of law

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Jeconia Okungu Obutu & another v Orange Democratic Movement Party & 6 others [2017] KECA 439 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2017). Civil Appeal No. 179 of 2017. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2017/439/eng@2017-07-14

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.