Pauline Kitti Nyale v Principal Magistrate’s Court, Kilifi & another [2016] KECA 757 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Court of Appeal confirmed you can ask a judge orally to review a decision, and judges must hear parties before striking out judicial review applications.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Identification of the decision appealed against where two decisions were made on the same day
The appeal lies against the second decision dismissing the oral application for review, as leave to appeal was granted only in respect of that decision and Rule 75(3) requires a notice of appeal to target a specific decree or order.
Rule 75(3) of the Court of Appeal Rules requires a notice of appeal to be in respect of a specific decree or order, so separate decisions cannot be the subject of a single notice. The record showed the notice was expressed to be lodged pursuant to leave granted on 27th January 2015, and of the two decisions leave was granted only in respect of the second. The record further showed counsel asked for a review, not a 'reconsideration'.
Whether oral review of an order is permissible
Depending on the circumstances, a party may apply orally for review; here, where the ex parte chamber summons was struck out in chambers without hearing counsel and without service, an oral application for review was proper.
Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules permits review of orders from which no appeal lies or has been preferred. The Court held that nothing in the circumstances stops an oral application. Because the leave application was decided in chambers without hearing counsel and without service on the opposite side, it was proper for counsel to seek review orally rather than by formal application.
Exercise of discretion in refusing to review the order striking out the leave application
The learned Judge improperly exercised his discretion: an application for leave, decided ex parte without hearing counsel, could not sustain a finding that no prima facie case existed, and striking it out in limine was an error.
The purpose of the leave stage is to filter out frivolous and vexatious claims without going into the matter in depth. From Order 53 Rules 1(3), 2 and the proviso to Rule 4, where a judge is not inclined to grant an ex parte order the proper course may be to order service for hearing inter partes. Without hearing the applicant and the respondent, the judge could not establish whether a prima facie case existed; refusing review was therefore an error.
Legal principles established
#- A notice of appeal must be in respect of a specific decree or order; separate decisions cannot be challenged by a single notice of appeal.
- There is no such relief as 'reconsideration of a decision' in the Civil Procedure Rules; the recognised relief is review.
- A party aggrieved by an order may, depending on the circumstances, apply orally for review, particularly where an ex parte application was decided without hearing the party.
- It is good practice to hear counsel or the party on any ex parte application even where the court is minded to grant the orders sought.
- The leave stage of judicial review is a filter against frivolous, vexatious and hopeless claims; the court must not go into the matter in depth and cannot properly determine a prima facie case without hearing the parties.
Court orders
#- 1.Appeal allowed with no orders as to costs
- 2.Order declining review of the earlier orders set aside
- 3.Substituted order of review of the earlier decision
- 4.Earlier orders striking out the application dated 26th January, 2015 set aside
- 5.Application for leave to be placed before a judge (besides Angote, J.) of the Environment and Land Court (in Mombasa) for fresh consideration
- On appeal from
- High Court of Kenya at Malindi
- H.C. Misc. App. No. 5 of 2015
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appeal against discretionary decisions of the High Court under the Court of Appeal Rules (certificate of appealability / leave granted on 27th January, 2015)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Pauline Kitti Nyale v Principal Magistrate’s Court, Kilifi & another [2016] KECA 757 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2016). Civil Appeal No. 25 of 2015. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2016/757/eng@2016-02-26
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.