Voi Development Company Limited v Agam Investments Limited [2016] KECA 416 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Court of Appeal dismissed a land dispute appeal but cancelled a company director's jail term, ruling courts can't pile multiple contempt punishments on one offender.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Availability of review where an appeal has been pursued
Review was unavailable to the appellant because it had exercised its right of appeal against the judgment it sought to review, and the application was made after inordinate and unexplained delay
Under Order 45 rules 1(1)(a) and 2, review lies only where there is a right of appeal but no appeal has been brought, or where no appeal is allowed. The appellant appealed to the Court of Appeal, which dismissed the appeal on 7th February 2014. The review application, filed on 26th November 2014, some three years after the High Court judgment, was therefore late and barred. The alleged newly discovered evidence of substitution of the suit properties was also not new, having been litigated before the trial court and the Court of Appeal.
Service requirements for contempt proceedings against a company
Service of the order by substituted service in a newspaper was valid; personal service was dispensable where the contemnor had notice, and the appellant had notice by its conduct
Section 5(1) of the Judicature Act, until January 2016, donated contempt jurisdiction to the High Court to be exercised as for the time being in England. The applicable procedure was the Civil Procedure (Amendment No.2) Rules of England of 1st October 2012. Rule 81.5 requires service of the order before committal; for a company, service is on a director or officer. Rule 81.8 dispenses with personal service where the contemnor was present when the order was made or was subsequently notified. The respondent served the decree by substituted service in the Daily Nation of 2nd February 2015, which was acceptable.
Multiplicity of contempt sanctions
The learned Judge erred in imposing committal, sequestration and a fine simultaneously, especially after directing the Deputy Registrar to execute the transfer documents; the committal and attachment orders were set aside and a fine substituted
The court had authorised the Deputy Registrar to execute the transfer documents, making attachment of the appellant's property and committal of its director to civil jail unnecessary. Committal, sequestration and a fine are all punishments; imposing all three at once was irregular. The Judge should also have considered the director's age of over 80 years. The appellate court set aside the committal and attachment orders and substituted a fine of Kshs.100,000 or five days' imprisonment in default under section 36(3) of the High Court (Organization and Administration) Act.
Jurisdiction of the High Court over the applications
The High Court had jurisdiction; the appellant's Article 165(5) objection was raised too late, after losing all four applications it had itself initiated or defended
What was before the High Court was a simple application for review filed by the appellant itself, and the respondent's applications were defended by the appellant. The jurisdictional objection was never raised in limine but only after the appellant lost all four applications. The objection therefore lacked substance and the learned Judge had jurisdiction to entertain the applications.
Legal principles established
#- A party who had a right of appeal and exercised it cannot subsequently seek review of the same judgment; the remedy of review is available only where either there is a right of appeal but no appeal has been brought, or no appeal is allowed
- The prevailing law and procedure of contempt in England, which section 5(1) of the Judicature Act imported, must be ascertained at the time the contempt application is brought before the Kenyan courts
- In the case of a company, a judgment or order sought to be enforced by committal must be served on a director or other officer, but personal service may be dispensed with where the contemnor was present when the order was made or was subsequently notified of its terms, including by substituted service
- Committal to civil jail, sequestration and a fine are all forms of punishment for contempt and the court errs in imposing all of them simultaneously, particularly where it has already authorised execution of the transfer documents by the Deputy Registrar
- A party cannot raise the question of the court's jurisdiction for the first time after losing on the merits, where it was the party that invoked the court's jurisdiction
- The power of review under Order 45 is to be exercised within the statutory parameters: discovery of new and important matter after due diligence, mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or any other sufficient reason, and without delay
Court orders
#- 1.Appeal dismissed save to the limited extent that the order committing the appellant's director to jail and attaching the appellant's property, Grant No. C.R. 13016/1, was set aside
- 2.In place of the committal and attachment, substituted a fine of Kshs.100,000 or in default five (5) days imprisonment in accordance with section 36(3) of the High Court (Organization and Administration) Act
- 3.Costs of the appeal awarded to the respondent
- On appeal from
- High Court of Kenya at Mombasa
- H.C.C. No. 308 of 2007
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Appellate jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal under the Constitution; the appeal challenged the High Court's exercise of review and contempt jurisdiction (Article 165(5) of the Constitution was raised on the scope of High Court jurisdiction)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Voi Development Company Limited v Agam Investments Limited [2016] KECA 416 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2016). Civil Appeal No. 55 of 2015. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2016/416/eng@2016-07-01
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.