Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealPartially AllowedCivil Appeal No. 100 of 2012· [2015] KECA 388 (KLR)

Hellen Makone v Brenda Michieka [2015] KECA 388 (KLR)

Court of Appeal
25 September 2015
2,532 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~10 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal set aside a Kshs.18.5 million default judgment, ruling that cases should be decided on their merits, not procedural technicalities.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The appellant and respondent are sisters. The respondent sued claiming Kshs.18,500,000 as the market value of half an acre at Runda Estate, alleging she sent the appellant US$5,700 in 1993 to purchase the plot, which the appellant fraudulently registered in her own name. Interlocutory judgment was entered in the sum of Kshs.18,500,000 after the appellant failed to enter appearance; her application to set it aside was dismissed by Khaminwa, J. on 15th March 2012 on the ground that she had been served and the proposed defence was a sham raising no triable issues. On first appeal, the Court of Appeal (Karanja, Otieno-Odek and Kantai, JJA) framed two issues: whether the appellant was served, and whether the proposed defence raised triable issues. On service, the Court held that the appellant's affidavit was a bare denial which did not specifically rebut the process server's affidavit of service, so service stood. On triable issues, the Court found the trial judge misdirected herself: the plaint pleaded an alternative claim for US$5,700 plus 69% per annum interest, which exceeds court rates and raises a triable issue; there was no agreement for sale of an identified plot, making the measure of compensation a triable issue; and the fraud-based claim required oral evidence at trial. Applying the established principles that appellate courts interfere with discretionary decisions only where the discretion was wrongly exercised, the Court allowed the appeal in part: it set aside the High Court ruling and the interlocutory judgment with all consequential orders, granted the appellant 21 days to file and serve her defence, ordered her to bear the costs before the High Court (service having been proved), and directed that each party bear her own costs of the appeal.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the appellant was served with summons to enter appearance

Holding

Service was properly effected; the appellant's affidavit was a bare denial and did not specifically rebut the affidavit of service, and the process server was not called for cross-examination.

Reasoning

The affidavit of service deposed by the process server stated that the appellant was known to him and had been served with a letter in the same matter. The appellant's supporting affidavit did not challenge these specific averments, containing only a bare denial. The process server was not cross-examined, and unchallenged specific averments stand. The Court therefore found the trial judge did not err on service.

p. 4
02

Whether the proposed defence raised triable issues such that the interlocutory judgment should have been set aside

Holding

Yes. The proposed defence raised triable issues, including whether 69% per annum interest is payable and the measure of compensation where no specific plot was agreed, so the trial judge misdirected herself in holding the defence a sham.

Reasoning

The plaint pleaded alternative claims: market value of Kshs.18,500,000 or refund of US$5,700 plus 69% per annum interest. The rate exceeds court rates, disclosing a triable issue. Further, there was no agreement for sale of an identified plot, raising a triable point on the measure of compensation. Proof of fraud, on which the claim was founded, requires oral evidence and trial. The trial judge ignored these matters and erred in holding the defence a sham.

p. 4
03

The standard for appellate interference with discretionary decisions

Holding

An appellate court will interfere with a discretionary order only where the discretion was exercised wrongly - on misdirection, acting on wrong matters, or ignoring relevant matters, resulting in a wrong conclusion or miscarriage of justice.

Reasoning

Relying on Mbogo v Shah, Edward Sargent v Chhotabhai Jhaverbhat Patel and Chemwolo v Kubende, the Court restated that it will not lightly differ with a trial court's finding of fact or interfere with discretionary orders unless the discretion was not exercised judicially or was clearly wrong, causing a wrong decision or miscarriage of justice. It found the trial judge had misdirected herself by ignoring relevant facts, justifying interference.

p. 3

Legal principles established

#
  • A bare denial of service does not suffice; a specific averment in an affidavit of service requires specific rebuttal, and failure to challenge it leads to a finding that service was effected.
  • Where conflicting affidavits exist as to service of process, the deponents should be examined on oath to establish the truth; and courts should lean towards deciding cases on their merits rather than encouraging ex parte judgments based on procedural technicalities.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Setting aside the ruling and order of the High Court dated 15th March 2012
  2. 2.Substituting an order setting aside the interlocutory judgment entered in favour of the respondent and all consequential orders arising therefrom
  3. 3.Granting the appellant leave to file and serve her statement of defence within twenty one (21) days of the date of the judgment
  4. 4.The appellant to bear the costs before the High Court
  5. 5.Each party to bear her own costs in the appeal

Authorities

#

Cases cited (9)

  • Selle -vs- Associated Motor Boat Co.
    [1968] EA 123
  • Abdul Hameed Saif vs. Ali Mohamed Sholan
    [1955] 22 E.A.C.A. 270
  • Sanitam Services (EA) Ltd. -v- Rentokil
    [2006] 2 KLR 70
  • Edward Sargent -v- Chhotabhai Jhaverbhat Patel
    [1949] 16 EACA 63
  • Haman Singh & Others -v- Mistri
    [1971] EA 122
  • Mbogo & Another -v- Shah
    [1968] EA 93
  • Chemwolo & another -v- Kubende
    [1986] KLR 492
  • Kenya Safari Lodges & Hotels Ltd -v- Tembo Tours & Safaris Ltd.
    [1985] KLR 441
  • Karatina Garmanets Ltd -v- Nyanarua
    [1976-80] 1 KLR 114
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya at Nairobi
HCCC No. 452 of 2011
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal to the Court of Appeal under the Court of Appeal's appellate jurisdiction

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Hellen Makone v Brenda Michieka [2015] KECA 388 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2015). Civil Appeal No. 100 of 2012. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2015/388/eng@2015-09-23

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.