Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealPartially AllowedCivil Appeal No. 239 of 2013· [2014] KECA 703 (KLR)

Kakuta Maimai Hamisi v Peris Pesi Tobiko & 2 others [2014] KECA 703 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
10 March 2014
9,101 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~36 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal confirmed the Kajiado East election result despite irregularities, but ruled the losing candidate shouldn't pay costs for problems the electoral body caused.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This appeal arose from the Kajiado East Constituency National Assembly election of 4th March 2013, in which the 1st respondent, Peris Pesi Tobiko, was declared winner over the appellant by a narrow margin of 23,645 to 22,771 votes. The High Court (Kimondo, J) dismissed the appellant's election petition, finding that although irregularities existed, they did not affect the result and the petition had failed to meet the standard of proof. The appellant mounted 14 grounds of appeal attacking the treatment of irregularities in Forms 35 and 36, the limited scrutiny of five polling stations, the exclusion of his witnesses, alleged bias, and the award of costs of up to Kshs. 4 million against him. The Court of Appeal, exercising its first-appeal mandate to reappraise the evidence, framed its determination around the legitimate expectation of the electorate, candidates and electoral bodies. It re-evaluated the scrutinised ballot boxes, the handwritten Forms 36, the broken seal and the discrepancies between parliamentary and presidential votes, and agreed with the trial Judge that the errors were minor, not deliberate, and did not go to the root of the election. Applying Section 83 of the Elections Act and the principles in Raila Odinga v IEBC and Morgan v Simpson, the Court confirmed the election of the 1st respondent. However, it partially allowed the appeal on costs, holding that because the irregularities were attributable to the 2nd and 3rd respondents, the appellant should not have been penalised; it set aside the costs order and substituted costs against the 2nd and 3rd respondents in favour of the appellant and 1st respondent, capped at Kshs. 4 million, with the appellant to receive back his security deposit.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the irregularities and non-compliance in the Kajiado East election vitiated the election under Section 83 of the Elections Act

Holding

The election was not vitiated: the irregularities were minor, not deliberate, and did not affect the result of the election

Reasoning

The Court reassessed the evidence on Forms 35 and 36, the broken seal, handwritten Forms 36 due to a malfunctioned printer, and discrepancies between parliamentary and presidential votes. It found no evidence of deliberate fiddling, no allegation that votes were lost or switched, and that the announced results were accurate. Minor irregularities that did not disadvantage any candidate or go to the root of the poll fall within the safety valve of Section 83, so a narrow win of even one vote is sufficient.

p. 13
02

Whether the burden of proof lay on the petitioner to demonstrate non-compliance that affected the result

Holding

Yes; the appellant bore the evidential and legal burden and did not discharge it

Reasoning

Applying the Supreme Court's decision in Raila Odinga v IEBC, the person alleging that the law of election was infringed must produce the necessary evidence in the first place, after which the evidential burden shifts. The appellant admitted on oath that he had no issues with voting and counting, did not allege his votes were taken away, and produced no evidence of deliberate fiddling by poll officers.

p. 7
03

Whether the trial Judge erred in limiting scrutiny to selected polling stations and in shutting out the appellant's witnesses

Holding

No; the Court was entitled to manage the petition within statutory timelines, and the abandoned scrutiny grievance could not be revisited

Reasoning

Regulation 17 gave the Court wide powers to manage petitions to ensure speedy disposal, and the Judge acted within his powers in enforcing timelines; the shut-out evidence was not shown to have tilted the scales. The complaint about partial scrutiny formed the basis of an intended appeal against the scrutiny ruling which was never pursued, so it was deemed abandoned.

p. 13
04

Whether the order of costs against the appellant was justified

Holding

No; the costs order was set aside and costs awarded against the 2nd and 3rd respondents because the irregularities that occasioned the litigation were their responsibility

Reasoning

Although costs ordinarily follow the event and the trial Judge had discretion, the Court found that the existence of admitted irregularities attributable to the 2nd and 3rd respondents made the appellant's petition legitimate rather than frivolous. It was therefore erroneous in principle to make the appellant pay costs for lapses wholly caused by the electoral bodies.

p. 13

Legal principles established

#
  • An election will not be declared void for non-compliance where the non-compliance did not affect the result or where the election was conducted in accordance with constitutional and statutory principles (Section 83, Elections Act)
  • On a first appeal, the Court of Appeal is mandated to reappraise the evidence and draw its own conclusions on the facts
  • Irregularities attributable to the electoral body, not the petitioner, should not ground an order of costs against a petitioner who had a genuine grievance

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The appellant's appeal as against the result of the parliamentary elections in Kajiado East is dismissed and that election is confirmed
  2. 2.The order of costs as against the appellant is set aside
  3. 3.Costs are awarded against the 2nd and 3rd respondents in favour of the appellant and the 1st respondent, capped at Kshs. 4 million (Kshs. 2 million to the appellant and Kshs. 2 million to the 1st respondent)
  4. 4.The appellant shall receive the deposit for security for costs that he paid into Court

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya 2010Article 1(1)
  • Constitution of Kenya 2010Article 20(1), (2) and (4)
  • Constitution of Kenya 2010Article 21(1)
  • Constitution of Kenya 2010Article 22(1)
  • Constitution of Kenya 2010Article 23(1) and 24(1)
  • Constitution of Kenya 2010Article 38
  • Constitution of Kenya 2010Article 81
  • Constitution of Kenya 2010Article 88
  • Constitution of Kenya 2010Article 105
  • Elections Act No. 24 of 2011Section 4 (IEBC Act)
  • Elections Act No. 24 of 2011Sections 25 and 26
  • Elections Act No. 24 of 2011Sections 58, 59, 65 and 67
  • Elections Act No. 24 of 2011Sections 79-85A, including 80, 80(d), 82, 83, 84, 85 and 85A
  • Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules 2013Rules 17(1) and (2), 32, 33, 35, 36(1) and (2), 37, 37(3)
  • Election (General) Regulations 2012Regulation 59 and Regulation 83
  • Court of Appeal Rules 2010Rule 29(1)

Cases cited (7)

  • Morgan and others v Simpson [1974] All ER 151
    [1974] All ER 151
  • James Omingo Magara v Manson Onyango Nyamweya & 2 others [2010] eKLR
    [2010] eKLR
  • Rashid Hamid Ahmed Amana and IEBC and 2 others [2013] eKLR
    [2013] eKLR
  • William Kabogo Gitau v George Thuo and 2 others
    Nairobi Milimani Commercial Court Election Petition Number 10 of 2008
  • Raila Odinga v IEBC and others, Petition Number 5 of 2013
    Petition Number 5 of 2013
  • S.K. Njuguna and the Electoral Commission of Kenya v John Kiarie Waweru and Beth Wambui Mugo
    Nai CA. No. 219 of 2008
  • Peters v Sunday Post [1958] EA 424
    [1958] EA 424
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya at Nairobi
H.C.CC. No. 4119 of 1993 (Petition No. 5 of 2013)
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal to the Court of Appeal under the Court's Rules 2010 (Rule 29(1)) arising from an election petition under the Constitution (Article 105) and the Elections Act 2011

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (1)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Kakuta Maimai Hamisi v Peris Pesi Tobiko & 2 others [2014] KECA 703 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2014). Civil Appeal No. 239 of 2013. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2014/703/eng@2014-03-10

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.