Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealAllowedCivil Appeal No. 276 of 2013· [2014] KECA 692 (KLR)

Lempaka v Aramat & 2 others (Civil Appeal 276 of 2013) [2014] KECA 692 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
28 March 2014
5,808 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~23 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal ruled that candidates disputing only the vote count— not the election's validity—get a recount without proving massive irregularities first.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Court of Appeal (Waki, Musinga and Gatembu Kairu, JJ.A.) allowed the appellant's appeal against the dismissal by Emukule, J. of his election petition challenging the declared result of the Narok East Constituency National Assembly election of 4th March 2013, which the 1st respondent won by 441 votes. The appellant's sole remaining relief before the High Court was a recount of votes, having abandoned his earlier prayer for scrutiny. The trial judge had refused the recount, holding that a petitioner had to demonstrate 'massive irregularities' and 'sufficient reason' before a recount could be ordered, relying on pre-2011 case law decided under the repealed National Assembly and Presidential Elections Act. The Court of Appeal held that this misinterpreted the electoral framework. Section 80(4) of the Elections Act, 2011, read with rule 32 of the Elections Petition Rules, 2013, creates a special summary jurisdiction for petitions in which the validity of the election is not questioned and the only issue is the count or tally of votes; such petitions do not require proof of sufficient reason or massive irregularities, and a competent petitioner is entitled to an order of recount. The 'sufficient reason' threshold belongs to rule 33 applications, which may involve scrutiny where the validity of the election is in issue; and in appropriate cases both scrutiny and recount may be ordered together. The court also upheld the trial judge's entitlement to deliver a final judgment rather than a ruling after full evidence and submissions, but faulted his failure to cap costs as mandated by rule 36(1)(a). The judgment and decree of 5th September 2013 were set aside and substituted with an order for a recount of all votes in all 69 polling stations, supervised by the Deputy Registrar at Nakuru, with IEBC directed to deliver ballot boxes within ten days, and costs capped at Kshs.1,500,000 for the petition and Kshs.300,000 for the appeal, payable to the appellant.

Key legal issues

#
01

Distinction between recount under Section 80(4)/rule 32 and scrutiny/recount under Section 82/rule 33

Holding

Rule 32 confers a summary jurisdiction where the validity of the election is conceded and only the count or tally is disputed; it does not require 'sufficient reason'. Rule 33, for scrutiny and recount where validity is questioned, requires sufficient reason.

Reasoning

The court traced the genesis of Section 80(4) to the Elections Act, 2011 enacted under Article 87(1) to provide mechanisms for timely settlement of electoral disputes. Where a petitioner accepts the election's validity but disputes only the count, a full trial would render the provisions otiose. Rule 33 expressly requires the court to be 'satisfied' of 'sufficient reason'; rule 32 contains no such requirement, evidencing a legislative intent to afford a quick summary remedy.

p. 10
02

Standard to be met for a rule 32 recount

Holding

The petitioner need only state in the petition and supporting affidavits the basis of his belief that he obtained the highest votes and committed no election offence; once the petition and application are competent, the recount ought to be ordered unless there are very good reasons such as gross incompetence.

Reasoning

The court held that the trial judge misinterpreted rule 32 by importing the 'massive irregularities' standard from pre-2011 case law decided under the repealed National Assembly and Presidential Elections Act, which had no provision for count-only petitions. Imposing that onerous obligation negates the jurisprudential gain of Section 80(4).

p. 8
03

Whether the judgment was flawed for disposing of the petition when only a recount application was argued

Holding

No. Having heard all parties, witnesses and submissions, the judge was entitled to deliver a final judgment; the recount was the main remaining relief since scrutiny had been abandoned.

Reasoning

The record showed the court had directed submissions limited to whether there would be a recount, and counsel addressed the court on facts and law with authorities. The appellant's advocate never indicated he had further submissions, so no prejudice arose and ground one of the appeal failed.

p. 4
04

Capping of costs under rule 36(1)(a)

Holding

The election court was obliged to cap costs at the conclusion of the petition and its failure to do so was an error; the appellate court remedied this by capping petition costs at Kshs.1,500,000 and appeal costs at Kshs.300,000.

Reasoning

Rule 36(1)(a) stipulates that the court shall, at the conclusion of an election petition, specify the total amount of costs payable. This is a new and mandatory requirement in electoral law, and the trial judge's non-compliance warranted appellate intervention.

p. 8
05

Whether scrutiny and recount can be ordered together under rule 33

Holding

Although rule 33(2) speaks of 'scrutiny or recount', the court may in appropriate cases order both, since scrutiny usually goes hand in hand with recount where validity of the election is questioned.

Reasoning

Where a party questions the validity of an election and raises multiple issues including the count, it would be illogical to limit the court to one remedy. The situation differs where validity is not in question and the petitioner merely seeks verification of the count.

p. 8

Legal principles established

#
  • A petition brought solely under Section 80(4) of the Elections Act and rule 32 of the Elections Petition Rules, where the petitioner does not question the validity of the election but only the count or tally, is a summary procedure and the petitioner has a right to an order of recount once the petition and application are competent.
  • Requiring 'massive irregularities' or 'sufficient reason' for a recount under rule 32 misinterprets the rule; the 'sufficient reason' threshold applies only to applications under rule 33.
  • No scrutiny of electoral materials is permissible under the Section 80(4)/rule 32 jurisdiction; only retally or recount may be sought.
  • An election judge who has heard all evidence and submissions is entitled to deliver a final judgment rather than a ruling on an outstanding recount application, so long as there is no indication of further submissions.
  • Rule 36(1)(a) of the Elections Petition Rules makes capping of costs at the conclusion of an election petition a mandatory requirement.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The judgment and decree dated 5th September 2013 are set aside and substituted with an order for recount of all the votes cast in all the 69 polling stations in Narok East Constituency for election of the area member of Parliament.
  2. 2.The recount shall be carried out in the High Court of Kenya at Nakuru, supervised by the Court's Deputy Registrar, and results forwarded to any judge in that station except Emukule, J., for declaration in terms of Section 80(4) of the Elections Act.
  3. 3.IEBC ordered to deliver all ballot boxes for the Narok East Constituency parliamentary election to the High Court at Nakuru within ten (10) days.
  4. 4.Costs of the election petition in the High Court, capped at Kshs.1,500,000, to be paid by the loser to the winner and to the 1st and 2nd respondents jointly, as between the appellant and the 1st respondent, subject to determination of the winner on recount.
  5. 5.Costs of the appeal capped at Kshs.300,000 and payable to the appellant by the respondents.

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 86
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 87(1)
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 105(2)
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 35(1)
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 53
  • Elections Act, 2011Section 80(4)
  • Elections Act, 2011Section 82
  • Elections Act, 2011Section 84
  • Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules, 2013Rule 32
  • Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules, 2013Rule 33
  • Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules, 2013Rule 36(1)(a)
  • National Assembly and Presidential Elections Act (Cap 7) (repealed)null

Cases cited (5)

  • Richard Kalembe Ndile & Another v Dr. Patrick Musimba Mweu
    Machakos High Court Election Petition No. 1 of 2013
  • Hassan Ali Joho v Jotham Nyange & Another
    [2006] eKLR
  • Burundi Nabwera v Silvester Kamaru
    Election Petition No. 4 of 1983
  • William Maina Kamanda v Margaret Wanjiru & 2 Others
    [2008] eKLR
  • Onamu v Maitsi
    Election Petition No. 2 of 1983
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya at Nakuru
H.C. Election Petition No. 2 of 2013
Jurisdiction invoked
Appeal from the High Court sitting as an election court under the Elections Act, 2011; election petitions are appealable to the Court of Appeal under the Constitution and Elections Act framework (Articles 87(1) and 105(2) of the Constitution cited).

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (25)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Lempaka v Aramat & 2 others (Civil Appeal 276 of 2013) [2014] KECA 692 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2014). Civil Appeal No. 276 of 2013. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2014/692/eng@2014-03-28

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.