Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & another v Godfrey Masaba & another [2014] KECA 545 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Court of Appeal ruled that courts cannot penalise litigants in costs for registry misplacements and cannot award costs to non-parties in election petitions.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Burden of explaining a genuine but disputed court receipt
The learned Judge erred in shifting the burden of explaining the issuance of a genuine court receipt to the 1st and 2nd respondents; she ought to have enquired from her own registry staff.
The receipt was acknowledged by all parties, including the judge, as a genuine official court receipt. The originator of the receipt was a registry officer under the judge's supervision, and the master receipt book was in the custody of the court registry, not the respondents. Shifting that burden to the litigants was improper, and any misplacement of documents in the registry could not justify penalising them in costs.
Whether the response to the petition had been filed
The Court found that the 1st and 2nd respondents had in fact filed their response to the petition before the ruling on costs, and that the judge's contrary finding was a misdirection resulting in an erroneous decision.
The receipt whose authenticity the judge did not doubt covered payments for not less than six documents; counsel had pointed the judge to the receipt and assessment at page 2 of the record before the reserved ruling; and the scanned original receipt had been e-mailed to the Deputy Registrar on 19th September 2013. Had the judge addressed her mind to these matters, she would not have concluded that no response had been filed.
Hearing parties before capping costs
A judge should hear parties before capping costs, as this fosters justice and fairness and forestalls arbitrary awards.
The Court agreed that hearing parties on costs before capping enables the court to arrive at an informed decision and prevents accusations of arbitrary inordinately low or high awards. However, this procedural lapse did not by itself justify interference with the quantum, which the Court found reasonable in the circumstances.
Interference with quantum of costs
The global award of Kshs 700,000/= was reasonable and not inordinately low; the Court declined to enhance it but varied its apportionment to an equal split.
Costs are discretionary and must be exercised judicially and judiciously, taking account of all circumstances. Although the judge took into account the erroneous view that no response had been filed, the total award was not so low as to warrant interference. Having found the response was filed, equal apportionment among the three respondents was appropriate.
Costs to purported 'interested parties' in an election petition
The persons referred to as interested parties were not parties to the election petition and should not have been awarded costs; that order was set aside as a misdirection on a point of law.
Their names came into the case only after the petitioner claimed they were behind his filing the petition, acting as their 'gun for hire'; they were merely summoned to clarify that issue, which did not make them interested parties. In an election petition there can only be petitioners and respondents, so awarding them costs was a misdirection the appellate court could correct.
Legal principles established
#- Where a trial judge doubts the circumstances under which an official court receipt was issued, the burden of explanation lies with the court's own registry staff under the judge's supervision, not with the litigants.
- A judge should hear parties on the issue of costs before capping or fixing costs.
- An appellate court will only interfere with an award of costs where it is inordinately low or manifestly high, or where the judge considered extraneous matters or failed to consider relevant matters.
- Litigants should not be penalised in costs for misplacement of documents attributable to the court registry.
- In an election petition there can only be petitioners and respondents; persons merely summoned to clarify issues do not become interested parties entitled to costs.
Court orders
#- 1.Set aside the order on apportionment of costs and ordered that the Kshs 700,000/= be apportioned equally, awarding the 1st and 2nd appellants Kshs 350,000/= and the 3rd respondent Kshs 350,000/=
- 2.Set aside the order awarding Kshs 100,000/= to the so-called interested parties and ordered that amount be awarded to the respondents in the petition
- 3.Upheld the award of Kshs 700,000/= to the respondents in the petition
- 4.Made no orders on the costs of the appeal
- On appeal from
- High Court of Kenya at Bungoma
- Election Petition No. 8 of 2013
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appellate jurisdiction under the Constitution over appeals from the High Court in election petition matters; specific enabling provision not stated in the judgment.
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & another v Godfrey Masaba & another [2014] KECA 545 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2014). Civil Appeal No. 328 of 2013. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2014/545/eng@2014-06-13
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.