Board of Trustees National Social Security Fund v Jorim Wahome Marenya [2014] KECA 284 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Court of Appeal let Co-operative Bank file its employment appeal late, ruling that settlement talks with the other side can justify some delay.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Test for extension of time under Rule 4
The court exercises a judicial discretion weighing length of delay, reasons, merits and prejudice, guided by the overriding objective.
Rule 4 gives the Court an unfettered discretion to extend time on such terms as it thinks just. The discretion must be exercised judicially by considering all relevant circumstances including the length of and reasons for the delay, the merits of the appeal, prejudice to the respondent, and the interests of the administration of justice. No single factor is decisive; all factors are weighed and balanced against the material before the court.
Exclusion of time under proviso to Rule 82(1)
The applicant applied in writing for proceedings within 30 days; the period certified in the certificate of delay is excluded from computation of time.
The applicant lodged a notice of appeal within 7 days and applied in writing for certified proceedings within 30 days of the judgment. Although service of the request letter on the respondent was disputed, the court found it more probable than not that service occurred, since the respondent's advocate did not deny on oath that the letter was not served. The certificate of delay certified the period taken to prepare proceedings, which is excluded under the proviso to Rule 82(1) as read with Rule 82(2).
Whether pursuing settlement constitutes a reasonable explanation for delay
An appeal put on hold at the respondent's request to explore out-of-court settlement is a reasonable explanation, though it does not exonerate the applicant entirely.
The respondent had requested an exit package and settlement negotiations, and the applicant instructed its advocates to hold the appeal until negotiations failed on 6th March 2014. Although this did not exonerate the applicant from blame, it constituted a reasonable explanation. The resulting delay of about 3 months and 8 days was not inordinate, especially given ongoing other proceedings between the parties in the Industrial Court.
Coexistence of review and appeal under the Industrial Court Act
Neither the Industrial Court Act nor its Rules preclude a review application where an appeal has been preferred or allowed, unlike the Civil Procedure Act provisions.
Section 16 of the Industrial Court Act and Rule 32(1) of the Industrial Court (Procedure) Rules 2010, unlike section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules, do not confine review to situations where no appeal is allowed or preferred. Thus the dismissal of the applicant's review application did not render the intended appeal incompetent. That question, together with the service of the notice of appeal, is for the full appellate court.
Merits of the intended appeal
The grounds of law raised, including the legality of reinstatement of an employee dismissed over 7 years ago and the bar on specific performance of contracts of service, are not frivolous.
An appeal from the Industrial Court lies only on a matter of law under section 17(2) of the Industrial Court Act. The memorandum of appeal raised questions of law, including the legality of ordering reinstatement of an employee dismissed more than seven years earlier and the statutory principle against orders of specific performance in contracts of service except in exceptional circumstances. These issues were arguable and not frivolous, favouring extension of time.
Prejudice to the respondent
Any prejudice to the respondent in being kept out of the fruits of his judgment can be adequately compensated by an award of costs.
The respondent contended he would be denied the fruits of his judgment for a long time if extension was granted. The court balanced this against the applicant's undoubted right of appeal and concluded that costs would adequately compensate any prejudice. This weighed in favour of allowing the application in the interests of substantive justice.
Legal principles established
#- In exercising discretion to extend time under Rule 4, the court must consider judicially all relevant circumstances: length of delay, reasons for delay, merits of the appeal, and prejudice to the respondent, with no single factor decisive.
- The overriding objective principle and the duty to administer substantive justice without undue regard to procedural technicalities is a paramount consideration in extension-of-time applications.
- The time certified by a certificate of delay for preparation and delivery of proceedings is excluded from computation of the 60-day period for instituting an appeal under Rule 82(1).
Court orders
#- 1.Leave granted to file and serve the record of appeal out of time (prayer 1 of the notice of motion dated 11th June 2014)
- 2.The record of appeal lodged on 13th May 2014 and served on 27th May 2014 in Civil Appeal No. 110 of 2014 deemed filed and served on time (prayer 2)
- 3.Time for service of the notice of appeal, which service is disputed, extended
- 4.Costs of the application to the respondent
- On appeal from
- Industrial Court of Kenya
- null
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Rule 4 of the Court of Appeal Rules 2010 (extension of time), read with sections 3A and 3B of the Appellate Jurisdiction Act
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Board of Trustees National Social Security Fund v Jorim Wahome Marenya [2014] KECA 284 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2014). Civil Application No. Nai. 110 of 2014. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2014/284/eng@2014-11-07
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.