Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealAllowedCivil Appeal No. 281 of 2003· [2013] KECA 269 (KLR)

Amratlal Stores Limited v Shah Hirji Manek Limited (Civil Appeal 281 of 2003) (Civ) [2013] KECA 269 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
20 September 2013
2,924 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~12 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal discharged a company from paying promissory notes because a new endorser was added without consent and the lender waited over four years to demand payment.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Court of Appeal (Nambuye, Gatembu Kairu and Murgor, JJ.A) allowed the appellant's appeal against a High Court judgment (Mwera, J, dated 19 September 2003 in HCCC No. 552 of 2001) awarding the respondent Kshs 29,095,500 on nine dishonoured promissory notes. The court first held the respondent was a holder in due course, there being no fraud, duress or illegality. On the material alteration issue, the court drew a critical distinction: the insertion of the word 'days' and the due dates when discounting the Notes merely completed inchoate instruments without touching the unconditional promise to pay, the sum or the holder's title, and so was not a material alteration. However, the addition of Harish Devani as an endorser without the appellant's consent - following Gardener vs Walsh - unequivocally altered the Notes and the parties' obligations, entitling the appellant to avoid them. On notice of dishonour, applying sections 52(3) and 90 of the Bills of Exchange Act and African Overseas Trading Co., the court held that notice of dishonour is not necessary to be given to the maker of a promissory note, rejecting that limb of the appellant's case. Finally, the court held the respondent's delay of over four years in demanding repayment (from January 1997 to March 2001) was inordinate and unreasonable for time-bound instruments, discharging the appellant. The appeal was allowed with costs to the appellant. This judgment binds subordinate courts on the completion-versus-alteration distinction and the discharge of makers for inordinate delay.

Key legal issues

#
01

Holder in due course status

Holding

The respondent was a holder in due course as there was no evidence of fraud, duress, force, fear or illegality affecting the Notes.

Reasoning

Section 30(2) of the Bills of Exchange Act deems every holder to be a holder in due course; the burden shifts only where fraud, duress, force and fear or illegality is admitted or proved. The record contained no such evidence, so the respondent's status as holder in due course under section 29 stood and framed the subsequent analysis.

p. 2
02

Material alteration - insertion of due dates and the word 'days'

Holding

The insertion of the word 'days' and the due dates did not constitute a material alteration; it was completion of the Notes.

Reasoning

Whether an alteration is material depends on whether it changes the legal basis of the contract and the parties' rights and obligations. The insertions did not touch the unconditional promise to pay, the sum payable or the holder's title. They merely completed inchoate Notes to give effect to the parties' agreed intentions, following the trial judge's finding that the parties knew what the figures stood for.

p. 3
03

Material alteration - addition of Harish Devani as endorser

Holding

The inclusion of Harish Devani as an endorser without the appellant's consent materially altered the Notes, entitling the appellant to avoid them.

Reasoning

Relying on Gardener vs Walsh, where adding a new maker to a joint and several note was held a material alteration, the court found that the endorsement added a party and altered the respective obligations of the parties without the appellant's knowledge or consent. The alteration was discovered only when payment was demanded after Harish Devani's death.

p. 3
04

Notice of dishonour to the maker

Holding

No notice of dishonour was necessary to be issued to the appellant as maker of the promissory notes.

Reasoning

Although sections 45, 47 and 48 of the Bills of Exchange Act require presentment and notice of dishonour for bills of exchange, Part IV and section 90(1) apply the Act to promissory notes with necessary modifications, and section 52(3) provides that notice of dishonour need not be given to render the acceptor liable. African Overseas Trading Co. confirms notice of dishonour of a promissory note is unnecessary.

p. 5
05

Inordinate delay in pursuing repayment

Holding

The respondent's delay of over four years after dishonour was inordinate, unreasonable and discharged the appellant from repayment.

Reasoning

The Notes were time-bound negotiable instruments which, having regard to the Act, the nature of the bill and the usage of trade, required pursuit within a reasonable time. Repayment fell due around January 1997 but no demand was made on the appellant until March 2001, after Harish Devani's death. Applying Lickborrow vs Mason as approved in Universal Bank, the loss from inactivity falls on the party who enabled it.

p. 5

Legal principles established

#
  • Insertion of the period of credit and due dates to complete an inchoate promissory note is completion, not material alteration, so long as the parties' agreed obligations are untouched.
  • Addition of a new endorser or party to a promissory note without the consent of the maker is a material alteration which entitles the maker to avoid the note.
  • Notice of dishonour is not necessary or mandatory to be given to the maker of a promissory note, by virtue of sections 52(3) and 90 of the Bills of Exchange Act.
  • Inordinate and unexplained delay of over four years in pursuing repayment after dishonour of time-bound negotiable instruments discharges the maker from liability.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Appeal allowed with costs to the appellant

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Bills of Exchange ActSection 29(1)
  • Bills of Exchange ActSection 30(2)
  • Bills of Exchange ActSection 64
  • Bills of Exchange ActSections 45 to 49
  • Bills of Exchange ActSection 45(2)(a)
  • Bills of Exchange ActSection 47(1)
  • Bills of Exchange ActSection 48
  • Bills of Exchange ActSection 52(3)
  • Bills of Exchange ActSection 90(1)
  • Bills of Exchange ActSection 90(2)
  • Bills of Exchange ActPart IV
  • UK Bills of Exchange Act 1882

Cases cited (8)

  • Geometra E.A. Ltd vs Road Sea Link Limited
    (2001) 2 EALR page 378
  • Gardener vs Walsh
    1855 5 E & B 83
  • Caunt vs Thompson
    (1849) 7 CB 400
  • Re Fenwick, Stobart & Co Limited
    1902 I Ch 507
  • Nanji Khodabhai vs Sohan Singh and Another
    1957 EALR 291
  • African Overseas Trading Co. v Bhagwanji Harjiwan
    (1960) E.A. 417
  • Lickborrow & Another vs Mason & Others
    (1775-1802) All ER Rep 1
  • Universal Bank Limited vs Double Whiteland Stationary & Printers and 2 Others
    HCCC No 561 of 1998
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya at Nairobi
HCCC No. 552 of 2001
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal to the Court of Appeal from the High Court (constitutional/statutory provision not expressly stated in the judgment)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (2)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Amratlal Stores Limited v Shah Hirji Manek Limited (Civil Appeal 281 of 2003)  (Civ) [2013] KECA 269 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2013). Civil Appeal No. 281 of 2003. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2013/269/eng@2013-09-20

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.