Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealPartially AllowedCivil Application (Notice of Motion dated 10th October, 2013) arising from Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2013· [2013] KECA 141 (KLR)

Bichage v Tongi & 2 others (Civil Application 39 of 2013) [2013] KECA 141 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
22 November 2013
5,525 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~22 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal paused the Nyaribari Chache by-election until Bichage's election appeal was decided, ruling that one arguable point is enough for a stay.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is a ruling of the Court of Appeal at Kisumu (Onyango Otieno, Azangalala and ole Kantai, JJA) on a Notice of Motion by Chris Munga Nyamaratandi Bichage, whose election as Member of Parliament for Nyaribari Chache was nullified by Murithi J. in Election Petition No. 5 of 2013 on 7th October 2013. Pending his appeal (Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2013, fixed for hearing on 9th December 2013), the applicant sought stay of the Speaker's declaration of vacancy and restraint of the IEBC from conducting a by-election. The court held it had jurisdiction under Rule 5(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules notwithstanding the electoral time-lines, reasoning that Article 87 of the Constitution does not bar such applications and that the six-month period for hearing election appeals includes connected applications. Applying the settled twin test for stay - an arguable appeal and nugatory value - the court found the appeal raised arguable points, notably whether an electoral court may make conflicting findings on core issues, the value of a scrutiny report limited to one ballot box, and whether judgment may rest on unpleaded matters. Prayer (c) was refused as overtaken by events, the vacancy having already been declared and gazetted, and loss of parliamentary privileges being an expected consequence of an election petition. Prayer (d) was granted: the IEBC and the Returning Officer were restrained from taking any further steps towards the by-election until the appeal was heard and determined, the court fearing a constitutional crisis should a by-election winner and a restored appellant both hold valid certificates. The stay could not exceed six months. Costs were ordered to be in the appeal. The application was partially allowed.

Key legal issues

#
01

Jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal to grant stay in an election matter

Holding

The Court has jurisdiction under Rule 5(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules to hear a stay application in an election appeal; Article 87 of the Constitution does not bar such applications.

Reasoning

The court held that although the Elections Act and its Rules fix the periods for filing and hearing election appeals, other procedural matters such as filing and serving a Notice of Appeal are governed by the Court of Appeal Rules. Article 87 only prescribes filing time-limits for petitions and does not prevent the Court from hearing applications for preservation of the subject matter connected to a filed appeal. Once an appeal is filed, the Court is bound to hear applications necessitated by its existence.

p. 6
02

Arguability of the appeal

Holding

The appeal was arguable on whether conflicting findings on core issues can stand in one judgment, the legal value of a scrutiny report covering one box only, and whether judgment can rest on unpleaded matters.

Reasoning

The court identified three specific arguable points: whether an electoral court may make conflicting findings on core issues in the same judgment; the legal value to be attached to a scrutiny report limited to counterfoils of one ballot box; and whether judgment or part of it may be based on unpleaded matters in an election petition. The court emphasised that a single arguable point suffices and that arguable points need not ultimately succeed.

p. 7
03

Nugatory value and preservation of the subject matter

Holding

Proceeding with the by-election before the appeal is heard could create a serious constitutional crisis if the appeal later succeeded, so a stay of further by-election steps was warranted.

Reasoning

If the by-election proceeded on 19th December 2013 and a third party won, while the appeal heard on 9th December 2013 subsequently succeeded and restored the applicant, two persons could hold valid certificates for the same seat. Loss of parliamentary status and privileges was not itself a ground for stay, but avoiding the crisis justified preservatory orders. The stay could not exceed the six-month period for completing the appeal.

p. 8

Legal principles established

#
  • The twin test for stay of execution pending appeal: the applicant must demonstrate that the appeal is arguable and that if the order is not granted the success of the appeal, were it to succeed, would be rendered nugatory; both limbs must be satisfied.
  • One arguable point suffices to establish that an appeal or intended appeal is arguable.
  • The six-month period within which an election appeal must be heard by the Court of Appeal includes the hearing of applications directly connected to the appeal, and a stay of a by-election may be granted but cannot exceed the six-month period set for completing the appeal.
  • Arguable points need not be points that will succeed; they need only be points worth ventilation by the court.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Application allowed in terms of prayer (d): save for what has already been done, the second and third respondents restrained from taking any further action towards the by-election for Nyaribari Chache Constituency until Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2013 is heard and determined
  2. 2.Prayer (c) dismissed
  3. 3.Costs of the application to be in the appeal

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 159(2)
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 87
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 105
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 87(1) and 105(2) and (3)
  • Elections ActSection 85
  • Elections ActSection 85A
  • Elections ActSection 86
  • Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules, 2013Rule 35
  • Court of Appeal RulesRule 5(2)(b)
  • Court of Appeal RulesRule 75
  • Elections RulesRule 35

Cases cited (3)

  • Ferdinand Ndungu Waititu vs Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission, IEBC and 9 Others
    Civil Application No. 137 of 2013
  • Silverstein v Chesoni
    [2002] 1 EA 296
  • Reliance Bank Limited v Norlake Investments Limited
    [2002] 1 EA 227
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya at Kisii
Election Petition Number 5 of 2013
Jurisdiction invoked
Rule 5(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules as read with Section 85A of the Elections Act and Rule 35 of the Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules, 2013

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (17)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Bichage v Tongi & 2 others (Civil Application 39 of 2013) [2013] KECA 141 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2013). Civil Application (Notice of Motion dated 10th October, 2013) arising from Civil Appeal No. 48 of 2013. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2013/141/eng@2013-11-22

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.