Nuru Chemist Limited & another v National Bank of Kenya [2008] KECA 281 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Court of Appeal restored a chemist's defence against National Bank, ruling that any genuine dispute about a debt must go to full trial.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the defence raised triable issues warranting a full trial rather than striking out or summary judgment.
The Court held that the denial that the respondent took over the debt and the claim that the debt had been fully repaid were substantial triable issues, and that the letters acknowledging the debt had to be read together with the later replying affidavit.
The plaint alleged the respondent took over Standard Chartered Bank's debts; the defence denied knowledge of that takeover. The Court found this raised the question whether the respondent had locus standi and privity, and the replying affidavit sworn three years after the acknowledgment letters asserted the debt had been repaid by Barclays Bank cheques. These were issues worth ventilating at a full trial where documents proving payment could be produced.
The principles governing striking out a pleading under Order 6 rule 13(1)(b) and (c) versus summary judgment under Order 35 rule 1.
The two provisions are distinct and each sets out its own requirements: striking out requires the pleading to be scandalous, frivolous or vexatious or to prejudice, embarrass or delay fair trial; summary judgment applies to liquidated demands where the defendant shows no bona fide defence.
The Court noted the application was brought under both provisions and each has distinct requirements. Under Order 6 rule 13(1), the applicant must show the defence raises no issues worth ventilating. Under Order 35 rule 1(a), a plaintiff may apply for judgment on a liquidated demand without waiting for a defence, and the defendant must then show leave to defend by affidavit or otherwise.
Whether the Court of Appeal should interfere with the learned Judge's discretion.
Although the Court is generally reluctant to interfere with a judge's exercise of discretion, it interfered because the Judge did not direct his mind to the governing legal principles and failed to consider the need for a full hearing on the alleged payments.
The Court invoked Mbogo v Shah on reluctance to interfere with discretion, and found the adjournment refusal properly exercised. However, the Judge erred by declaring the defence a sham on the strength of acknowledgment letters without considering the later replying affidavit and the need to prove payment of the debt at a full hearing, warranting appellate intervention.
Legal principles established
#- A defence that raises a triable issue - for example, a denial of the plaintiff's locus standi to sue on an assigned debt - is neither scandalous, frivolous nor vexatious and cannot properly be struck out under Order 6 rule 13(1)(b) and (c).
- Summary judgment under Order XXXV is confined to cases where there is no reasonable doubt that the plaintiff is entitled to judgment; where a defendant shows a fair case for defence or reasonable grounds for setting up a defence, leave to defend must be given.
- An appellate court is reluctant to interfere with a trial judge's exercise of discretion but will do so where the judge failed to direct his mind to the applicable legal principles.
Court orders
#- 1.Appeal allowed.
- 2.Order striking out the defence set aside.
- 3.Judgment entered in favour of the respondent against the appellants by the superior court's ruling dated 24th May 2002 set aside.
- 4.Substituted an order dismissing the notice of motion dated 5th February 2001.
- 5.Suit to proceed to full hearing.
- 6.Respondent to pay the costs of the appeal and the costs of the notice of motion in the superior court.
- On appeal from
- High Court of Kenya at Milimani Commercial Courts
- H.C.C.C No. 1343 of 2001
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appellate jurisdiction over appeals from the High Court (appeal as of right against an interlocutory ruling and order of the High Court; the judgment does not cite a specific constitutional or statutory provision).
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Later judgments citing this (8)
#Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.
- Yash Karnik v Kuku Foods Limited [2019] KEELRC 945 (KLR)[2019] KEELRC 945 (KLR)2 Aug 2019
- John Kagechu Muiruri t/a Muiruri Auto Parts & 5 others v Kihumo Property Developers (K) Ltd [2017] KEELC 905 (KLR)[2017] KEELC 905 (KLR)29 Nov 2017applied
- Suchan Investments Limited v Dipa Pulling [2017] KEELC 1913 (KLR)[2017] KEELC 1913 (KLR)22 Sept 2017applied
- KENYA COMMERCIAL BANK LIMITED v V E R SU SBLUESHED FREIGHTERS LIMITED[2014] KEHC 3119 (KLR)28 Aug 2014
- SHEPHERD CATERING LTD v NAIROBI HOLDINGS LTD & 2 others[2010] KEHC 1194 (KLR)5 Oct 2010applied
- TWIGA MOTORS LIMITED v HON DALMAS OTIENO ONYANGO[2009] KEHC 1589 (KLR)21 Oct 2009
- Peter Sollacher T/A Petley's Launding v (Defendant - landlord, unnamed in extract)[2009] KEHC 2053 (KLR)27 Aug 2009followed
- HOUSING & INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT CONTRACTORS LIMITED v CAPITAL CONSTRUCTION LIMITED[2009] KEHC 2481 (KLR)8 May 2009applied
Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Nuru Chemist Limited & another v National Bank of Kenya [2008] KECA 281 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2008). Civil Appeal No. 219 of 2002. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2008/281/eng@2008-04-25
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.