Lakhani & 2 others v Ismail Kamau [2004] KECA 47 (KLR)
The bottom line
#In a Kenyan fatal accident claim, dependants must prove their actual losses with solid documents; being related to the deceased alone wins nothing.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the trial judge erred in disbelieving the existence of Prescott SA and the deceased's earnings from it, despite uncontradicted evidence from the deceased's auditor.
No. The judge was entitled to entertain doubt about the company's existence and to disregard the alleged income when assessing loss of dependency.
The only evidence of Prescott SA came from Saujani, who conceded he could not produce bank statements; the company was registered in Panama, described as a tax haven, and collapsed with the deceased. No certificate of incorporation - ordinarily conclusive proof of existence - was tendered. The USD 80,379 figure was inserted into the plaint by amendment only after the close of the case. The appellate court therefore could not fault the trial judge's doubt and declined to revise the damages upwards for any of the three appellants.
Whether Saujani's oral testimony could establish the existence and contents of the Prescott SA bank statements and certificate of incorporation.
No. Oral accounts of a document's contents may only be given by a witness who has personally seen and read the original, and parol evidence proves the contents of a lost document only where loss is established.
Relying on Naran v Hurry Narain, the court held that a witness giving oral accounts of a document's contents must have seen and read the original. Saujani never said he had seen the bank statements, never explained what became of them, and never testified that they or the certificate of incorporation were lost. Read v Price, permitting parol evidence of lost written acknowledgments, did not assist because there was no suggestion of loss. Saujani's testimony therefore could not prove the documents or the income they allegedly recorded.
Whether the second and third appellants (the daughters) proved their claims for loss of dependency.
No. Although they were dependants of the deceased, they proved no general damages suffered on his death, and the dismissal of their claims was affirmed.
The parties had agreed that all three appellants were dependants and had lost the value of that dependency, but the trial judge found no dependency damages proved for the daughters and dismissed their claims. On its review of the entire evidence, the Court of Appeal agreed with that finding: dependency alone does not establish quantum, and the daughters had not proved the general damages they suffered. The widow's award of Kshs. 672,000 under the Fatal Accidents Act was likewise undisturbed, so the appeal failed in its entirety.
Legal principles established
#- A person giving oral accounts of the contents of a document must himself have seen and read the original documents; oral testimony from a witness who never saw the originals cannot prove the documents' existence or contents.
- A party alleging the existence of a company must tender a certificate of incorporation, which ordinarily is conclusive evidence of the company's existence; in its absence, the court is entitled to doubt that the company ever existed.
- In a fatal accident claim, establishing that a claimant is a dependant of the deceased is not by itself sufficient - the dependant must also prove the general damages actually suffered by reason of the death.
Court orders
#- 1.The appeal was dismissed with costs, i.e. the appellants to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal.
- On appeal from
- High Court of Kenya at Nairobi
- H.C.C.S. No. 3442 of 1990
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Not expressly stated in the judgment; the appeal is a first appeal from the judgment and decree of the High Court of Kenya at Nairobi (Khamoni, J.) in H.C.C.S. No. 3442 of 1990, and no constitutional or statutory provision is cited as the source of appellate jurisdiction.
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Later judgments citing this (2)
#Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.
- James Njiiri, James Muthee & Edward Karumba v Francisca Pendo & Mwaka Jefwa Kalu (Legal Representatives of the Estate of BJ also known as BJC)[2019] KEHC 2420 (KLR)15 Oct 2019
- Abson Motors & Others v Sinema Kitsao & Another[2016] KEHC 3690 (KLR)15 Aug 2016
Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Lakhani & 2 others v Ismail Kamau [2004] KECA 47 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2004). Civil Appeal No. 159 of 2002. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2004/47/eng@2004-04-30
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.