Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealPartially AllowedCivil Appeal No 295 of 2000· [2003] KECA 179 (KLR)

Kenya Bus Services Ltd v Dina Kawira Humphrey [2003] KECA 179 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
21 November 2003
2,191 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~9 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal confirmed vehicle owners pay for their drivers' negligence, but cut the family's compensation after spotting an inflated earnings figure.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This Court of Appeal judgment (Omolo, Tunoi and Githinji, JJA, delivered at Nairobi on 21 November 2003) determined a first appeal against a Commissioner of Assize's finding of 100% liability and damages of KShs 2,364,000/= for a passenger killed when the appellant's bus overturned into the Nithi river on 7 January 1998. On liability, the appellant argued that vicarious liability was never pleaded because the served plaint lacked the word 'vicariously', the hand-amended version having mysteriously appeared on the record. The court accepted the respondent's explanation that the corrected plaint was filed on 18 December 1998 and was validly on record before submissions. More fundamentally, it held that express pleading of vicarious liability is unnecessary: it suffices that the primary facts and the master-servant relationship are pleaded, from which liability is inferred as a matter of law. The appellant had admitted ownership and employment in its defence, did not contest the driver's negligence, and failed to rebut the presumption under res ipsa loquitur. On quantum, the court held that the validity of the grant of letters of administration could not be raised for the first time on appeal, and that a grant is not invalidated by the size of the later award. However, applying Butt v Khan, it found the multiplicand of KShs 14,000/= erroneous: the deceased's proved net earnings of KShs 7,589/= less one third (KShs 5,060/=) should have been used. The appeal was dismissed on liability but allowed on quantum: the dependency award of KShs 2,240,000/= was set aside and replaced with KShs 1,214,400/=, making a total of KShs 1,338,400/=. The appellant received one half of the costs of the appeal. Lower courts are bound by the holding that vicarious liability may be inferred from pleaded primary facts without express pleading.

Key legal issues

#
01

Pleading of vicarious liability

Holding

Vicarious liability was properly before the court; even absent the hand-amended plaint, the primary facts pleaded in paragraph 5 were sufficient for the doctrine to be inferred as a matter of law.

Reasoning

The corrected plaint was validly on record before the hearing, as the Commissioner of Assize recognised. In any event, the law requires only that the primary facts be pleaded and evidence led showing the relationship between driver and owner, from which vicarious liability follows as a matter of law. The appellant admitted ownership and employment averments in its defence, and the failure to sue the driver or expressly plead vicarious liability was not decisive.

p. 2
02

Res ipsa loquitur and burden of proof on negligence

Holding

The doctrine applied; the appellant, having admitted ownership and that the bus was driven by its servant, did not discharge the burden of showing the accident occurred without its driver's negligence, having pleaded only inevitability and Act of God.

Reasoning

The appellant admitted it was the registered owner and that the bus was driven by its driver within the scope of duty, yet contested only the particulars of negligence, pleading inevitable accident and Act of God. It did not contest the finding of negligence either at trial or on appeal, and led no evidence. A properly maintained, serviced and driven bus does not simply run over a bridge and plunge into a river without explanation, so the presumption against the owner stood unrebutted.

p. 3
03

Award of damages under the Law Reform Act notwithstanding challenge to the grant of letters of administration

Holding

The claim under the Law Reform Act was competent: the grant was pleaded as having been obtained before filing of the suit, the validity of the grant was not before the trial court and cannot be raised on appeal, and the size of the subsequent award cannot invalidate the grant.

Reasoning

The only issue argued at trial was whether the grant existed before the filing of the suit, which it did on the pleaded facts. The attack on the Runyenjes magistrate's jurisdiction to make the grant was new on appeal. Moreover, the magistrate could not have known the quantum of damages in advance, so the subsequent award of about KShs 2,000,000/= said to exceed the magistrate's pecuniary jurisdiction could not by itself invalidate the grant.

p. 3
04

Multiplicand for loss of dependency

Holding

The multiplicand of KShs 14,000/= was wrong; the deceased's net monthly earnings of KShs 7,589/= less one third (KShs 5,060/=) should have been used, reducing the dependency award to KShs 1,214,400/=.

Reasoning

The deceased's pay slip showed a net monthly salary of KShs 7,589/=, and the respondent's counsel conceded the multiplicand should have been that figure less one third, i.e. KShs 5,060/= per month. Applying the agreed multiplier of 20 years and 12 months yields KShs 1,214,400/=. The appeal therefore succeeded in part on quantum, and the total award became KShs 1,338,400/=.

p. 4
05

Standard of appellate interference with damages

Holding

Assessment of damages is discretionary; an appellate court will not disturb an award unless it is inordinately high or low, is based on wrong principles, or rests on a material misapprehension of the evidence.

Reasoning

Relying on Butt v Khan and the other Kenyan authorities, the court reaffirmed the classic test for interference with discretionary awards of damages. Applying it, the multiplier of 20 years for a 32-year-old teacher with three young children involved no error of principle, and no basis was shown for reducing the loss of expectation of life head, so quantum was varied only as to the multiplicand.

p. 4

Legal principles established

#
  • It is sufficient for vicarious liability that the primary facts are pleaded and evidence led showing the master-servant relationship; express reference to vicarious liability is not necessary as liability can be inferred as a matter of law.
  • Where a car has caused damage by negligence, a presumption arises in the absence of contrary evidence that it was driven by a person for whose negligence the owner is responsible, strengthened or weakened by the surrounding circumstances.
  • An appellate court will not disturb an award of damages unless it is so inordinately high or low as to represent an entirely erroneous estimate, or the judge proceeded on wrong principles or misapprehended the evidence in some material respect.
  • An issue that was not before the superior court cannot be raised for the first time on appeal; a grant of letters of administration is not invalidated merely because the damages later awarded exceeded the magistrate's pecuniary jurisdiction.
  • A claim for damages under the Law Reform Act is competent where the grant of letters of administration was obtained before the filing of the suit, unless the appellant proves the grant was obtained subsequently.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Appeal on the issue of the appellant's vicarious liability dismissed
  2. 2.Appeal against assessment of damages for loss of dependency under the Fatal Accidents Act allowed to the extent that the award of KShs 2,240,000/= is set aside and replaced with an award of KShs 1,214,400/= (5060 x 12 x 20)
  3. 3.Total award fixed at KShs 1,338,400/= (1,214,400/= + 100,000/= + 24,000/=)
  4. 4.Appellant awarded one half of the costs of the appeal

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Fatal Accidents ActNot stated (generally, loss of dependency)
  • Law Reform ActNot stated (generally, fatal accidents/loss of expectation of life)

Cases cited (7)

  • Dritoo v West Nile District Administration
    [1968] EA 428
  • Karisa v Solanki
    [1969] EA 318
  • Bernard v Sully
    (1931) 47 TLR 557
  • Butt v Khan
    (1977) 1 KAR 1
  • Kenya Bus Services v Mayende
    (1989-1992) 2 KAR 232
  • Kemfro v (A M Lubia) Olive Lubia
    (1982-88) 1 KAR 72
  • Kitavi v Coastal Bottlers Ltd
    [1985] KLR 470
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya (tried by a Commissioner of Assize, suit originating in the Senior Resident Magistrate's Court, Runyenjes)
Not stated in the copy of the judgment supplied
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal to the Court of Appeal from the High Court (sitting with a Commissioner of Assize) in a fatal accident/negligence claim; the specific constitutional or statutory appeal provision is not cited in the judgment.

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (25)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Kenya Bus Services Ltd v Dina Kawira Humphrey [2003] KECA 179 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2003). Civil Appeal No 295 of 2000. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/2003/179/eng@2003-11-21

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.