Patrick Mutie Kimau & Another v Judy Wambui Ndurumo (suing through her next friend Catherine Otanga Kibara)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Court of Appeal threw out a KSh 1.5 million injury award, ruling the pedestrian—not the lorry driver—caused the accident by crossing carelessly.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Liability for the road traffic accident
The respondent, not the appellants, was responsible for the accident; the trial judge erred in holding the appellants wholly to blame.
The court found it more likely than not that the respondent crossed the three-lane Racecourse Road in front of a stationary bus without taking extra care as required by the Highway Code. The trial judge's reasoning, including his query why the respondent did not stop as the lorry passed, was unrealistic, and the manoeuvre attributed to the lorry was improbable. The respondent therefore failed to prove negligence against the appellants.
Relevance of the Highway Code to civil liability
Breach of the Highway Code may be relied upon in civil proceedings to establish or negative liability under section 68(3) of the Traffic Act.
The court reproduced clauses 6 and 7 of the Highway Code governing pedestrians crossing roads and taking extra care near stationary vehicles, and relied on section 68(3) of the Traffic Act to give those provisions evidential weight in determining negligence, applying them to find the respondent at fault.
Excessive award of general damages
The appeal was allowed and the entire judgment, including the damages award, set aside; no separate finding on quantum was necessary.
Counsel for the appellants contended the award of Kshs. 1,500,000/- had no basis and that Kshs. 500,000/- to 600,000/- would have been reasonable. Since the court found the respondent wholly responsible for the accident, the damages question fell away with the reversal on liability.
Legal principles established
#- A pedestrian owes a duty of care to other highway users and must take extra care near stationary vehicles or obstructions, as reflected in the Highway Code, whose provisions may be relied upon in civil proceedings to establish or negative liability.
- Under section 68(3) of the Traffic Act, failure to observe the Highway Code is not itself criminal but may be relied upon in civil proceedings on liability.
Court orders
#- 1.Appeal allowed
- 2.Judgment of the superior court in the sum of K.sh. 1,507,275/- together with costs and interest set aside
- 3.Appellants to have the costs of the appeal and of the suit in the superior court
- On appeal from
- High Court of Kenya at Nairobi
- H.C.C.C. No. 4169 of 1987
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appeal to the Court of Appeal against the judgment and decree of the High Court (statutory appellate jurisdiction)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Later judgments citing this (21)
#Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.
- Francis K. Righa v Mary Njeri (Suing as the Legal Representative of the Estate of James Kariuki Nganga (Civil Appeal 100 of 2017) [2021] KECA 710 (KLR)[2021] KECA 710 (KLR)16 Apr 2021
- Bash Hauliers Limited v Anastacia Ndinda Kimonye[2020] KEHC 1022 (KLR)15 Dec 2020
- Felix Kimanthi Musyoka & Car Link Tours & Travel Limited v Alice Chebet Chepkwony (Suing as a Legal Representative of the Estate of the Deceased, Thomas Kiprono Chepkwony)[2020] KEHC 2180 (KLR)22 Oct 2020
- TRAKANA MOMBASA LIMITED & another v VERSUSGEORGE AMWAYI ISAYA[2020] KEHC 6162 (KLR)7 May 2020
- DANIEL MBECHE SERO v HUSSEIN GULAMALI SAIGER[2020] KEHC 8395 (KLR)24 Jan 2020applied
- Lawrence Asava v Gesalt Gild Limited & Anthony Munyua Njoroge[2019] KEHC 759 (KLR)20 Dec 2019applied
- Wildlife Tracks Tours & Travel & Another v Richard Kariuki Kagiri's Representatives (as legal representatives of the estate of the late Richard Kariuki Kagiri)[2019] KEHC 10276 (KLR)8 Feb 2019
- Mary Wairimu Nyuguto & Another v. The Appellants (Appeal from Nyeri CMCC No. 61 of 2013)[2018] KEHC 3911 (KLR)28 Sept 2018
- Mary Wairimu Nyuguto & Another v. The Appellants (Appeal from Nyeri CMCC No. 61 of 2013)[2018] KEHC 3911 (KLR)28 Sept 2018
- Cosmas Muisu Mutisya v JAP Quality Motors Ltd & F.K. Wambua[2018] KEHC 6460 (KLR)30 May 2018
- WAKIM SODAS LIMITED & another v WAKIM SODAS LIMITED[2017] KEHC 3427 (KLR)28 Sept 2017
- DAVID MWANGI KARIUKI v STEPHEN MWANGI & another[2017] KEHC 5736 (KLR)13 Apr 2017applied
- Jane Doe (Plaintiff) v S.S. Mehta & Sons Limited & Another (Defendants)[2015] KEHC 6638 (KLR)30 Jan 2015
- Leah Wairimu Zakaria & Another (suing as legal representatives of the Estate of Peter Wangi Munyoro) v John Lundu Kahi, Kabansora Millers Ltd & James Kabiru[2014] KEHC 1842 (KLR)14 Nov 2014
- Peter Kanithi Kimunya v Aden Guyo Haro[2014] KEHC 1547 (KLR)28 Oct 2014applied
- Premier Diary Limited v Amarjit Singh Sagoo & another [2013] KECA 95 (KLR)[2013] KECA 95 (KLR)22 Nov 2013distinguished
- Cornelia Elaine Wamba (suing as personal representative of the Estate of Philipe Wamba, deceased) v Shreeji Enterprises Limited & Another; Third Party: Thiri B. Kamau[2012] KEHC 5827 (KLR)21 Sept 2012
- Julius Omolo Ochanda & Another v Samson Nyaga Kinyua[2010] KEHC 3504 (KLR)24 Feb 2010applied
- Brian Omwega Nyabuto (a minor suing through his next friend Sophie Nyabuto) v [1st Defendant transport company] & Joel Kipkorir Abiomto (2nd Defendant)[2005] KEHC 1454 (KLR)20 Jul 2005
- Brian Omwega Nyabuto (a minor suing through his next friend Sophie Nyabuto) v [1st Defendant transport company] & Joel Kipkorir Abiomto (2nd Defendant)[2005] KEHC 1454 (KLR)20 Jul 2005
- Nzula Kimatu & Another v Mitau Kyendw & Another[2001] KEHC 522 (KLR)11 Jul 2001
Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Patrick Mutie Kimau & Another v Judy Wambui Ndurumo (suing through her next friend Catherine Otanga Kibara)", Case Analysis (1997). Civil Appeal 254 of 1996. Source:
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.