Maina Kaniaru & another v Josephat M. Wang'ondu [1995] KECA 150 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan court cannot reduce your compensation for your own negligence unless the other side formally pleads it in their defence.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether contributory negligence could be found where it was not pleaded
It was wrong for the trial judge to make a finding of negligence against the deceased in the absence of a plea of contributory negligence, and equally wrong to reserve a discretion to consider the unpleaded issue after refusing amendment
The action was brought for damages for the respondent's negligence and there was no allegation that the deceased had been negligent. Respondent's counsel should have pleaded contributory negligence from the outset and did not seek amendment until trial commenced. Having refused leave to amend on the ground of prejudice, the judge could not then treat the matter as if a plea of contributory negligence existed before him. The persuasive English authority in Fookes v Slaytor was directly on point and supported the appellants.
Interaction of Law Reform Act and Fatal Accidents Act damages
Damages under the Law Reform Act for the benefit of the estate are in addition to, not in derogation of, Fatal Accidents Act rights, but where the same persons benefit, Law Reform Act damages must be deducted from the Fatal Accidents Act award to prevent double recovery
Section 2(5) of the Law Reform Act (cap 26) confers rights in addition to and not in derogation of dependants' rights under the Fatal Accidents Act. However, following the House of Lords decision in Davies v Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries Ltd, damages under the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act must be taken into account in assessing Fatal Accidents Act damages where the dependants benefit under both. The Shs 60,000 award for loss of expectation of life was therefore deducted, and the cross-appeal succeeded.
Effect of the respondent's conviction for causing death by dangerous driving
The court did not disturb the trial judge's apportionment on this basis once the 50% contributory negligence finding was removed; the appellants' contention that the respondent should have been found solely to blame was subsumed in the success of the main appeal
Mr Mureithi submitted that, the respondent having admitted conviction for causing death by dangerous driving, the judge erred in not finding him solely to blame. The court did not deal with this ground separately, holding that the finding of contributory negligence could not stand for want of a plea. It stated it saw no substance in the other grounds and declined to revisit them, allowing the appeal on the pleading point.
Legal principles established
#- Contributory negligence must be specifically pleaded by way of defence to a claim in negligence; a court cannot make a finding of contributory negligence against a plaintiff in the absence of such a plea
- A judge who has disallowed an application to amend a defence to plead contributory negligence errs in retaining a discretion to consider the unpleaded issue in the final judgment
- Damages recovered under the Law Reform Act which devolve on the dependants of the deceased must be taken into account in reduction of damages recoverable under the Fatal Accidents Act; there is no double recovery
Court orders
#- 1.Appeal allowed; decision of the High Court dated 18th March 1988 set aside
- 2.Cross-appeal allowed with costs; the sum of Shs 60,000 awarded under the Law Reform Act taken into account in reduction of damages under the Fatal Accidents Act
- 3.Appellants to have judgment in the sum of Shs 222,500 together with 3/4 of the costs of the appeal and interest at Court rates
- On appeal from
- High Court of Kenya at Nairobi
- Not stated in the judgment
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appeal to the Court of Appeal (appellate jurisdiction; no specific provision stated in the judgment)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Maina Kaniaru & another v Josephat M. Wang'ondu [1995] KECA 150 (KLR)", Case Analysis (1995). Court of Appeal, Nairobi (Civil Appeal from High Court, Mbogholi-Msagha J judgment of 18 March 1988). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/1995/150/eng@1995-07-11
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.