Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Court of AppealDismissed· [1995] KECA 2 (KLR)

Kaittany & another v Wamaitha (Civil Appeal 108 of 1995) [1995] KECA 2 (KLR)

Court of Appeal of Kenya
21 August 1995
15,233 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~61 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Court of Appeal ruled that the person named as executor in a will has the primary right to decide where and how to bury the deceased.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This was a first appeal to the Court of Appeal at Nairobi from the judgment of Githinji J delivered on 4th April 1995, dismissing a suit by the appellants (the deceased's first widow and eldest son) seeking the right to bury the deceased, Hezron alias Hassan Kipkosgei Kaittany, at Kaptagat Settlement Scheme, Eldoret. The deceased married the first appellant under Islamic law in 1967, converted to Christianity in 1976, and married the respondent in church in 1977; he died of cancer on 14th December 1994, having executed a will appointing the respondent sole executrix and expressing a wish to be buried at his father's Belgut farm in accordance with PCEA rites. At the outset the court barred reliance on unpleaded Keiyo customary law, applying Kimani v Gikanga: customary law must be pleaded and proved by the party invoking it. The majority (Gicheru JA, with Lakha JA agreeing) held that the deceased's apostasy rendered his Islamic marriage to the first appellant void, that his Christian marriage to the respondent was valid, and that the duty to bury fell on the respondent as executrix, whose title sprang from the will and not from any grant of probate. The appeal was dismissed and the trial court's order for burial at Belgut farm was confirmed, with no order as to costs. Kwach JA dissented substantially, holding that apostasy does not automatically dissolve a marriage without a declaration at a party's suit, and would have allowed the appeal; he agreed, however, that the order in favour of the non-party brother was made in error and that the father was estopped from resiling from his consent to the Belgut burial. The judgment binds lower courts on the pleading and proof of customary law, the absence of proprietary rights in a corpse, and the primacy of the executor's duty to bury.

Key legal issues

#
01

Pleading and proof of African customary law

Holding

Customary law must be pleaded by the party invoking it, and the onus of accurately and definitely establishing it rests on that party, who must ordinarily call evidence to prove it.

Reasoning

Relying on Kimani v Gikanga, the court held that although courts take judicial notice of African customary law applicable to African parties, the applicable customary law must be pleaded to avoid surprise and ambush tactics, and must be established as a fact, usually by witnesses, since authoritative texts and case law are lacking. Evidence of Keiyo customary law having been led at trial but never pleaded was wasted labour and could not be relied upon on appeal.

p. 8
02

Effect of apostasy on an Islamic marriage (majority view)

Holding

The majority (Gicheru JA, Lakha JA agreeing) held that the deceased's baptism and profession of Christianity on 30th May 1976 rendered his Islamic marriage to the first appellant void, so that his subsequent Christian marriage to the respondent was valid.

Reasoning

Gicheru JA, drawing on Islamic religious leaders' evidence and a commentary on Muslim personal law, reasoned that Islam absolutely prohibits marriage between a Muslim woman and a non-Muslim man, so the deceased's renunciation of Islam rendered the marriage void. Lakha JA agreed, finding the judge's conclusion on the evidence of the two eminent Muslim scholars correct. Kwach JA dissented, holding that dissolution is not automatic and requires a declaration at the suit of a party.

p. 10
03

Duty and right to bury the deceased

Holding

The duty to bury falls primarily on the executor; the respondent, appointed sole executrix under the will, answers the description of executor even without a grant of probate, and the trial court was right to confirm burial at Belgut farm in accordance with the deceased's wishes.

Reasoning

Lakha JA, reviewing this Court's earlier decisions in Apeli v Buluku and Wambui Otieno v Ougo & Siranga, held that there is no property in a dead body, that directions as to burial though not legally binding should be given effect to as far as possible, and that the duty falls on the executor. An executor's title springs from the will and not from the grant of probate, and a pending challenge to the will does not place executorship in abeyance.

p. 20
04

Release of the body to a non-party (Yusuf Kipkorir Kaittany)

Holding

The trial court's order releasing the body to Yusuf Kipkorir Kaittany, a non-party, was confirmed by the majority on the footing that there are no proprietary rights in a corpse, but was held by Kwach JA to have been made in error and without legal basis.

Reasoning

Gicheru JA reasoned that since there are no proprietary rights in a dead body, nothing was wrong in including the deceased's brother, who was in occupation of the burial site and had undertaken to be grave-minder. Kwach JA, dissenting, agreed entirely with the appellants that the order in favour of a man who was not a party and laid no formal claim had no legal basis and should be set aside; his voluntary obligation to mind the grave needed no court order.

p. 15
05

Estoppel of the father regarding the burial site

Holding

The deceased's father, having consented before the deceased's death to burial at Belgut farm upon which the deceased relied and acted, could not resile from that agreement; the appellants, not having appealed, could not complain that the order was incapable of performance.

Reasoning

Kwach JA found that the father gave his consent, subject only to a distance condition, before the deceased died, and that the deceased made a firm decision to be buried at Belgut in reliance on it; the father cannot now impose new conditions and is estopped forever from raising any objection. Gicheru JA added that the father, being directly affected, had not appealed, so the appellants had no mandate to speak for him. Lakha JA likewise would not allow the father to resile.

p. 15

Legal principles established

#
  • A party who invokes African customary law must plead it and prove it; the onus of establishing a particular customary law rests on the party who relies on it, and courts cannot rely solely on assessors' opinions.
  • There are no property (proprietary) rights in a dead body, and the executor's duty is to give effect to the wishes of a deceased person as far as practicable.
  • The duty to bury a deceased person falls primarily on his personal representative/executor.
  • An executor's title dates from the death of the testator and springs from the will, not from the grant of probate; a grant of probate is not necessary for the executor to act.
  • A challenge to the validity of a will must be mounted in accordance with the special procedure of the Law of Succession Act in the probate cause, and not collaterally in a burial suit.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Appeal dismissed
  2. 2.Decision of the superior court confirmed: the body of the deceased to be released to Yusuf Kipkorir Kaittany, Mustafa Kibet Kaittany (second appellant) and Mary Wamaitha Kaittany (respondent), or to any two of them, for burial at any suitable site on the portion of twenty (20) acres occupied by Yusuf Kipkorir Kaittany on Belgut farm, Kaptaren Village, Mutei Location of Keiyo District, in accordance with the Christian rites of the Presbyterian Church of East Africa
  3. 3.No order as to costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Judicature Act, Chapter 8, Laws of Kenyasection 3(2)
  • Kenya (Jurisdiction of Courts and Pending Proceedings) Regulations, 1963regulation 4
  • Evidence Act, 1963section 60(1), (2) and (3)
  • Evidence Actsection 13
  • Evidence Actsection 51(1) and (2)
  • Civil Procedure Codesection 87(1)
  • Law of Succession Act (Cap 160)section 2(1)
  • Law of Succession Act (Cap 160)section 80(1)
  • Law of Succession Act (Cap 160)section 82
  • Law of Succession Act (Cap 160)section 83
  • African Christian Marriage and Divorce Act (Cap 151)
  • Hindu Marriage and Divorce Actsection 10(1)
  • Court of Appeal Rulesrule 5(2)(b)
  • Court of Appeal Rulesrule 90

Cases cited (13)

  • Ernest Kinyanjui Kimani v Muiru Gikanga & Another
    [1965] E.A. 735
  • R v. Ndembra
    [1947] 14 E.A.C.A. 85
  • R v. Kiswaga
    [1948] 15 E.A.C.A. 50
  • Marantakah vs. Parakkal
    Indian Law Reporter (1992) 45 Madras, p.986
  • Mrs. Aiyasha Koreshi vs. Hishmatullah
    Pakistan Legal Decisions, 1972, Karachi, 635
  • Iqbal Ali (defendant) v Halima Begam (plaintiff)
    [1938] A.I.R. 296
  • Amin Beg v Saman
    [1910] I.L.R. 33
  • James Apeli and Enoka Olasi vs. Prisca Buluku
    Civil Appeal No. 12 of 1979 (unreported)
  • Virginia Wambui Otieno v. Joash Ochieng Ougo and Omolo and Siranga
    [1982-88] 1 KAR 1049
  • Kothari v. Qureshi
    1967 EA 564
  • Meyappa Chetty vs. Supramanian Chetty
    (1916) 1 A.C 603
  • Lindo vs Belisario
    [1795] 1 Hagg. Cons. 216
  • Lanston Monotype Corporation Ltd vs Anderson
    [1911] 2 KB 15
On appeal from
High Court of Kenya (the superior court)
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal to the Court of Appeal (no constitutional or statutory provision expressly invoked in the judgment for its appellate jurisdiction)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Kaittany & another v Wamaitha (Civil Appeal 108 of 1995) [1995] KECA 2 (KLR)", Case Analysis (1995). . Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keca/1995/2/eng@1995-08-21

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.