Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
Supreme CourtAllowedPetition (Application) E019 of 2023· [2024] KESC 4 (KLR)

Export Processing Zones Authority v KM (Minor suing through mother and best friend SKS) & 16 others

Supreme Court of Kenya
1 March 2024
1,444 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya LawDownload the judgment (PDF) Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~6 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Supreme Court: NEMA's cross-appeal extension unnecessary; time had not yet started running.

What this practically means

#

NEMA asked the Supreme Court for more time to file a cross-appeal, but the court said it wasn't needed. Under the rules, a cross-appeal must be filed within 30 days of service or 30 days before the hearing, whichever is later. Since the main appeal hadn't been scheduled for hearing, NEMA was still within time. The court allowed the filing anyway for good order but ordered NEMA to pay costs because the application was unnecessary.

Executive summary

#
This ruling by the Supreme Court of Kenya (a five-judge bench) addressed a notice of motion by the 14th respondent (National Environment Management Authority - NEMA) seeking leave to extend time to file a cross-appeal against the consolidated appeals arising from a Court of Appeal judgment of 23 June 2023. The 14th respondent argued that the delay was caused by the need to comply with public procurement procedures to hire external counsel. The 1st to 10th respondents opposed the application, contending it was an afterthought and would cause prejudice to victims of pollution. The court examined Rule 47(2)(b) of the Supreme Court Rules, 2020, which requires a cross-appeal to be lodged within 30 days of service or not less than 30 days before the hearing, whichever is later. Since the consolidated appeals were still undergoing compliance before the Deputy Registrar and had not been set down for hearing, the court found that the 14th respondent was still within time and did not require leave. The application was therefore unnecessary. Nevertheless, the court allowed it for good order and directed the 14th respondent to file its memorandum and record of appeal within 14 days. On costs, the court applied the principle from Jasbir Singh Rai that costs follow the event, and ordered the 14th respondent to bear the costs because the application was superfluous and could have been avoided by proper perusal of the rules.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the 14th respondent required leave to extend time to file a cross appeal.

Holding

The 14th respondent did not require leave because the consolidated appeals were still undergoing compliance and had not been set down for hearing, so the 30-day window before hearing had not yet begun to run.

Reasoning

The court examined Rule 47(2)(b) of the Supreme Court Rules, 2020, which requires a cross-appeal to be lodged within 30 days of service or not less than 30 days before the hearing, whichever is later. Since the main appeals were still in the compliance stage before the Deputy Registrar and no hearing date had been set, the 14th respondent was still within time. The application for extension of time was therefore unnecessary, but the court allowed it for good order and directed the cross-appeal to be filed within 14 days.

02

Whether the delay in filing the cross-appeal was excusable.

Holding

The court did not need to decide on the excusability of the delay because it found the application for extension of time was unnecessary; however, it noted the 14th respondent's explanation regarding the public procurement process for legal services.

Reasoning

The 14th respondent argued that the delay was caused by the need to comply with the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015 in hiring external counsel. The 1st to 10th respondents opposed, arguing the delay was inordinate and prejudicial. The court did not resolve this dispute because it found the application unnecessary on procedural grounds.

Legal principles established

#
  • A cross-appeal must be filed within 30 days of service or 30 days before the hearing, whichever is later.
  • If the main appeal has not been set for hearing, the 30-day window before hearing has not yet started.
  • A respondent does not need leave to extend time if they are still within the rule's timeframe.
  • Costs follow the event; an unnecessary application will attract costs against the applicant.
  • Public procurement delays do not automatically excuse procedural non-compliance, but the court did not decide this issue.
  • The court may allow a filing for good order even if the application for extension was unnecessary.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The notice of motion dated 26th January, 2024 be and is hereby allowed.
  2. 2.The applicant to file and serve its memorandum of appeal and record of appeal within fourteen (14) days of delivery of this ruling.
  3. 3.The applicant to bear the costs of the application.

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 48
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 50(1)
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 260
  • Supreme Court Rules, 2020Rule 15(2)
  • Supreme Court Rules, 2020Rule 47(2)(b)
  • Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act, 1999Section 7
  • Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015

Cases cited (1)

  • Jasbir Singh Rai & 3 Others v Tarlochan Singh Rai Estate of & 4 others
    SC. Petition No. 4 of 2012; [2013] eKLR
On appeal from
Court of Appeal
Civil Appeal No. E019 of 2023 (Consolidated with Civil Appeal No. E021 of 2023)
Jurisdiction invoked
Articles 48 and 50(1) of the Constitution; Rule 15(2) of the Supreme Court Rules, 2020

Key timeline

#
2023-06-23
Court of Appeal delivers judgment in the environmental pollution case.
2024-01-26
NEMA files notice of motion seeking leave to extend time to file a cross-appeal.
2024
Supreme Court rules that the application was unnecessary; NEMA still within time under Rule 47(2)(b).

Practical implications

#
For lawyers

Check timing before filing extension motions

Before applying for extension of time to file a cross-appeal in the Supreme Court, verify whether the main appeal has been set for hearing. Under Rule 47(2)(b), the deadline is 30 days before the hearing date. If no hearing date is set, you are still within time and do not need leave. Filing an unnecessary motion wastes resources and may result in an adverse costs order.

For businesses

Procedural rules can save litigation costs

If your business is involved in Supreme Court litigation, understand that procedural rules like Rule 47(2)(b) can work in your favour. A cross-appeal may be filed without a separate extension application if the main appeal is not yet scheduled for hearing. However, be cautious: filing unnecessary applications can lead to costs being awarded against you, as happened to NEMA here.

For individuals

Court penalizes unnecessary legal applications

Individuals involved in environmental or other cases should know that courts expect parties to follow the rules carefully. NEMA's unnecessary application for more time was dismissed as superfluous, and they had to pay costs. This means you can be penalized for wasting the court's time, even if you are a government agency. Always check the rules before filing procedural motions.

Frequently asked questions

#
What is a cross-appeal in Kenya?+

A cross-appeal is when a respondent in an appeal also challenges part of the lower court's decision. In the Supreme Court, it must be filed within 30 days of being served with the main appeal or 30 days before the hearing, whichever is later.

How long do I have to file a cross-appeal in the Supreme Court of Kenya?+

Under Rule 47(2)(b) of the Supreme Court Rules 2020, you must file a cross-appeal within 30 days of service of the main appeal, or not less than 30 days before the hearing date, whichever is later. If no hearing date is set, you are still within time.

Can I get an extension of time to file a cross-appeal in Kenya?+

Yes, but only if you are outside the time allowed by Rule 47(2)(b). If the main appeal has not been set for hearing, you do not need an extension because the 30-day window before hearing has not started. Filing an unnecessary extension application may result in costs against you.

What happens if I file an unnecessary application in a Kenyan court?+

The court may still allow it for good order, but you risk being ordered to pay the other side's costs. In this case, NEMA was ordered to bear costs because its application for extension of time was unnecessary and could have been avoided by reading the rules.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Export Processing Zones Authority v KM (Minor suing through mother and best friend SKS) & 16 others", Case Analysis (2024). Petition (Application) E019 of 2023. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.orghttps://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kesc/2024/4/eng@2024-03-01

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.